Re:We're All Subsidizing People Who Use American Express
by foobarchu on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:55PM
(#17451766)
I question whether the interest is worth more than the merchant fees they get from wealthy people using the card constantly.
If one poor person is paying, say, 11% interest on their $500 balance for a year, then the company makes a few hundred bucks on the interest. If a wealthier person spends $50k (admittedly random number I made up, its going to vary vastly for different card-holders, and probably in the millions for many) with their card over the course of the year but pays it all off immediately, they've made between 1k and 1.5k risk-free on the 2-3% merchant fees, and the customer will probably continue to use that card.
Re:We're All Subsidizing People Who Use American Express
by segmondy on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:28PM
(#17451513)
I think his point is that wealthy people spend more, so the card brands can charge more interest to the merchants. If you spend $20,000 and Amex charges 5% that's $1000 in fees. But a poor person who spent $500 only earns them $25 in fees to the merchant. Now it's true that the poor person if they can't pay might pay 20% interest, but the real money maker for the card brands is not the late payment fees but the processing fees which is the gist of the lawsuit and the article.
Re:We're All Subsidizing People Who Use American Express
by mikeash on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:11PM
(#17451341)
You’d expect for them to hit an equilibrium where the expected values are similar. You’re absolutely right that a poor person who carries a balance forever and pays a ton of interest is extremely valuable, but that’s countered by people who stop paying altogether. It’s the same reason a wealthy person (or rather, a person with good credit, which I’m sure correlates strongly with wealth) can get a better interest rate on a mortgage or car loan.
It is true, however, that wealthy people carry much less risk for them so they may have similar expected values (this is just a guess)