In my experience, cash-only stores still exist. Stores that like cash are very frequent.
There's a lot of hand writing about cash users being subsidized by other customers. If it were that significant, we'd expect to see a lot of stores only accept credit card and compete with other stores. They would just be losing a few percentage points of revenue from transaction fees...
Nice attempt to turn my phrasing onto me, but I’m not actually claiming that cash users are being unfairly subsidized. Rather, I’m arguing that cash also costs, and the difference between cash and card (whichever way it goes) evidently isn’t all that important.
It was pointed it out that it was the perfect tax-free income mechanism; no vendor certification or registration, no fixed property, minimal ingredients, cash transactions...
Confused... I've been all over the US and every city has tons of cash-only stores. Especially smaller cities and towns. It wouldn't surprise me if half of the independent delis in the US are cash only. I'm guessing you live and spend most time in a suburb?
I don't necessarily agree, but it's an interesting thought. I've never considered the cash overhead before.
Also, I've encountered a couple card-only businesses lately (local example, Optimism Brewing).
I'm not sure they would be able to stay open if 2-5% was cut off their revenue. It's just money; not a conspiracy.
So if 50% of sales are in cash, it doesn't cost you 10x more.
But every incremental credit card transaction costs another 3%.
So you can't argue that cash customers are subsidized by card customers when cash costs are relatively fixed while card costs scale linearly with volume.
Also, I can store $500 in a locked drawer or I can comfortably bring it home with me. $5,000 would need a safe bolted to the floor. And if you have a safe, now you need a camera to watch the safe. Say you now want to hold $50,000. Now you need a bigger safe and more cameras.
Cash does not scale at all.
Cash handling isn't among them, though embezzlement controls are.
https://www.investopedia.com/articles/financial-theory/09/ri...
I find numerous results on procedures. None obviously addressing premiums.
Though the notion does seem likely.
https://duckduckgo.com/?q=cash+handling+business+insurance+r...
Just to give you a reference, here's a special package Nationwide offers: https://www.nationwide.com/crime-insurance.jsp
Taking another angle: what's your familiarity with this? Operating a small business or insurance firm yourself? Conversations?
A store can't compete on the 2-5% difference in price because it isn't enough of a persuasion on each small individual transaction, even though it's a huge percentage of the business cost when taken together.
Customers are incentivized to carry credit cards because of cash back rewards, need for a short term loan, convenience of not having to carry cash, and fraud protection.
Merchants are incentivized to accept credit cards because many potential customers carry little cash because it is inconvenient.
And in all this, we are implicitly paying a 2-3% tax for everything we buy that goes straight to the credit card companies.
How much does that cost the consumer? Is it less or more than the "tax" what we pay to the credit card companies?
Many years ago I worked retail. A few minutes after I sold something to a man, he came back to my counter angrily. He said I'd given him change for a $20, but he'd given me a $50. I was quite certain he'd given me a $20 and he was trying to steal from us. This is not a pleasant situation to be in, and it wouldn't have been possible if he'd paid with a card.
Reversing a card transaction on a CC is one call away on debit GL with that.
There’s a lot of hand wringing about credit card users being subsidized by other customers. If it were that significant, we’d expect to see a lot of stores only accept cash and compete with other stores by offering lower prices. In my experience, cash-only stores are extremely rare.