Tell me where else a poor farmer's kid from Alabama, a child of refugees who spoke no English at home, someone from an unpopular religion, a kid who grew up in the ghetto without a father, someone from the working class who speaks with a regional accent, etc. etc. can compete on a pretty level playing field with wealthy elites?
Kind of. There is a fair criticism to be made about tests being unintentionally culturally slanted towards the people that make them, often white Americans.
Of course, in this case, your point is correct, since the people that are overindexing on the tests are Asian-Americans.
If a test contains questions that favor a particular race, then that is an outright problem, and schools should stop that.
In this case, it's actually the opposite. When a test is in English, often Asians have to learn English, which is often not their primary language at home. So by default, an English-speaking race taking a test, has a HUGE advantage over an Asian test taker.
Which is why the stereotype is that "asians are good at math". Asians are NOT particularly good in math. It's just that in math tests, it's mostly numbers. The language barrier becomes less of an issue, the playing field levels out, so you suddenly notice Asians tend to get higher scores.
I suspect it would be the same for, say, geography tests, if the same test was translated to an Asian language. Suddenly "Asians are good at geography". Not really.
If anything, tests in English are culturally slanted away from Asians where English is often not their primary language.
"Singapore is routinely ranked at or near the top in global comparisons of mathematical ability and boasts one of the most admired education systems in the world. In a league table based on test scores from 76 countries published by the OECD in May last year, Singapore came first, followed by Hong Kong, South Korea, Japan and Taiwan. The rankings, based on testing 15-year-olds’ abilities in maths and science, reinforced a sense that western children were slipping behind their Asian peers. The UK was in 20th place and the US 28th in the table. "
I thought that was always a bullshit excuse, especially considering that these test scores closely track IQ scores.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2014/03/05/these...
https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/e7a0/dfdee8ad5b91e1d179e9e2...
If intelligence is at all heritable, you'd expect to see this. If educated parents tend to push their own children to become more educated, you'd expect to see this.
I wonder what the chart looks like broken down by where parents went to school or some non-financial metric. I would bet the children of well-educated college professors or journalists also score well, despite growing up with a more middle class household income.
You do not intervene after the test. At that point the learning process for that material is already over. The student has already "missed out" on the learning opportunity. You would just be giving a good grade to someone who doesn't know the material.
Yes we need to help folks who are intergenerationally poor. But, you do that by helping their kids learn better and meet the testing bar.
You are not helping them by lowering the bar for them. Giving the kids better grades even if they don't know the material, would actually hurt them.
But you are helping underperforming students by placing them into top schools, comingled with better students - lots of research shows that. So lowering the bar for admission really does help.
I think the open question is how that balances against the cost of having fewer slots available at those top schools for the very best students.
But I am pretty sure that if, say, a student can't pass a multiplication test, but you give that student an A+ anyways, and then let that student into a "top calculus class", that's going to hurt the student more than it helps.
Ya sure the student gets to mingle with better students. But what you would usually get is, the student would end up being someone who mentions a lot of buzz words like "fractal integrals" just to fit in, but have zero idea what is going on, or what is being taught in class.
This policy change is exactly that - an attempt to encourage poorly performing students to do better, where a large majority of poorly performing students also happen to be underrepresented ethnicities. The NYC Department of Education has and continues to try many actions to increase educational outcomes for their students overall -- de Blasio is trying to accelerate the process before he's out of office.
And why is this bias mostly helping Asians, a minority group, who more likely to be learning English as a second language?
And indeed, the definition of "best" in this context is circular.
I'm not saying you're wrong, just that you can't be certain you're right.
On most of these tests, you have to solve math or logic problems, or read passages and synthesize information. It's hard to imagine someone could do exceptionally well answering those questions quickly & accurately and not perform in a classroom, or be unable to do those tasks yet excel academically.
It's entirely possible to have the latter be true without the former.
As for your "It's hard to imagine..." in my career teaching I've met both phenotypes.
I agree that the effect is small if anything in today's society, however.
It's great that schools are looking for a better "mix" of ethnicities in the incoming class, but they should encourage the underrepresented ethnicities to do better, in tests or other race-blind admission standards.
They should not put an admission "cap" based on the color of your skin