News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by loup-vaillant on Thursday September 30, 2010 @11:05AM (#1743485)
What you are proposing is likely to trigger (or at least prolong) a dark age of the internet. And I'm not exaggerating the slightest.

If people have to pay for IP addresses, then the internet will be divided in two: those who can pay, and those who can't run a server. And I predict that the crushing majority of people who use the internet will be of the second category. This would obviously be a catastrophe for freedom of speech and even privacy.

The major win for v6 is enormous: an IP for everyone, and the possibility for a server at every home, which will at last give us the decentralized internet we should have had in the first place.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by tptacek on Thursday September 30, 2010 @11:28AM (#1743560)
If it costs $5/yr for a single IP address, I'm not too concerned about the cost.

Meanwhile, most of the applications YC-types build don't necessarily need routable IP addresses. In a better world, most of our content would be delivered via overlay networks that abstract away that detail anyways. In the immediacy, what matters is the DNS.

We are in a dark age of the Internet, and it's our own doing. We've tethered ourselves to an archaic protocol that already indentures us to massive telco and cable operators, and would even if we had portable /32's assigned directly and personally from ARIN.

I don't see why we should be focusing all our engineering efforts on this one technological detail, tethering us forever to the idea that a license to speak on the Internet entails an IP address. There's 15+ years of research behind better networking topologies that care no more about IP addresses than a home router cares about Ethernet MAC addresses. Let's go that direction. It's easier, and probably better.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by signa11 on Thursday September 30, 2010 @11:36AM (#1743588)
> I don't see why we should be focusing all our engineering efforts on this one technological detail, tethering us forever to the idea that a license to speak on the Internet entails an IP address. There's 15+ years of research behind better networking topologies that care no more about IP addresses than a home router cares about Ethernet MAC addresses. Let's go that direction. It's easier, and probably better.

can you please elaborate on the above a bit ? bunch of pointers to papers would be most appreciated. thanks !

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by tptacek on Thursday September 30, 2010 @11:46AM (#1743628)
A good place to start is RON, which is a MIT PDOS project that Frans Kaashoek and Robert Morris (that one) were involved in:

http://nms.csail.mit.edu/ron/

I had a funded startup in '99 doing this stuff (in our last year, we adapted the MIT Click Modular Router to the same idea).

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by poet on Thursday September 30, 2010 @12:49PM (#1743905)
Check out "A Layered Naming Architecture for the Internet". This is the paper we focused on in an Advanced Networking class when we talked about naming. It aggregates several key principles from the literature into one system. I haven't read the RON paper Thomas linked to, but based on a quick glance, I'd say both papers are definitely worth your time. The Naming paper is actually written by several of the same people who wrote or collaborated on RON.

Feel free to drop me an email if you want to discuss the Naming paper.

http://nms.csail.mit.edu/papers/index.php?detail=4

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by baq on Thursday September 30, 2010 @11:45AM (#1743619)
FYI: a public IP can cost anywhere between $0 and $25/year in Eastern Europe, depending on the ISP.
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by tptacek on Thursday September 30, 2010 @11:49AM (#1743645)
Virtually any number between $1 and $100/yr seems reasonable to me. Consider: for the rare (and hopefully rarer and rarer) cases where you need a "native" IP address, 1 will almost always do. Meanwhile, all these prices are feasible (in a first-world kind of way) for individuals, but untenable for wasteful use by company IT departments.

$6.5MM/yr may not sound like a dealbreaker for a F-500's /16, but that's actually quite a lot of headcount.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by omh on Thursday September 30, 2010 @02:03PM (#1744185)
Unfortunately $25k is quite a lot for a /24, and you need a /24 if you want to have a network with independent BGP routing (because this is the smallest block in most BGP routers)

I manage the networks for a small company and we only need a few public IPs, but because we want the reliability we have a dual-homed connection via two ISPs, and our own /24.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by tptacek on Thursday September 30, 2010 @03:12PM (#1744444)
Most small companies are not in a position to get a BGP-advertised default-free connection to multiple ISPs for an allocation as small as a /24. Can it be done? I'm sure, but only after a sizeable investment of time and effort.

My point being, it's not as if this is a capability IPv4 currently provides that is imminently going to be snuffed out by address exhaustion. The ship sailed on free/easy multihoming when Sprint started filtering anything smaller than a /19, back in '97.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by omh on Thursday September 30, 2010 @03:26PM (#1744482)
You obviously have more experience with this than me, but in the UK we had no trouble getting BGP advertising with two ISPs for incoming connections (though we're not default-free, just using HSRP between ISPs for outbound).
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by tptacek on Thursday September 30, 2010 @03:32PM (#1744504)
There are plenty of people who have done this more recently than 1998, which is the last time I had to register an ARIN allocation. That was for a fairly large regional ISP in Chicago, for the sole purposes of multihoming, and it was a nightmare; I ended up having to call in a favor from a friend close to ARIN.

Surely someone who runs a multihomed hosted app (maybe a YC company) can chime in on how easy it is for a startup to get a BGP advertisement in 2010.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by abalashov on Thursday September 30, 2010 @05:29PM (#1744945)
Most IP allocations to organisations these days are not PI (provider-independent) blocks from RIRs; they are simply aggregated from an upstream ISP's larger announcement. That doesn't mean you can't punch holes in their aggregate by announcing that same block (if it's a /24 or larger) through ISP #2, but it does not result in any new numbering allocations from ARIN, net.

It's pretty rare to get a PI block these days unless you're pretty dang large, and taking aim for at least a /20.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by tptacek on Thursday September 30, 2010 @05:39PM (#1744990)
Can you advertise a /24 from Level3 at, say, Verizon? Don't the backbones filter advertisements by ASN?

(Back in the dark ages when I was actually doing this stuff, you couldn't advertise anything smaller than a /19 unless you were grandfathered in.)

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by abalashov on Friday October 01, 2010 @12:25AM (#1746002)
Well, you have to have your own ASN to announce it, yes. :) And certainly, you have to get the other ISP to allow this announcement from you through their filters, but that's a normal part of establishing BGP routing with another provider.

But the point is that if Level3 announces 4.0.0.0/8, yes, you can announce 4.16.73.0/24 through them, and through Global Crossing as well. Level3 does have to forward your announcement to its peers de-aggregated, though; that is, if they just fold it into their 4.0.0.0/10 announcement, incoming traffic will prefer your /24 announcement through GX because the prefix is longer/more specific, and plus that gives Level3 no way to withdraw the announcement if the link goes down. Not everybody will happily let you punch holes in their nice, clean aggregate like that, potentially hosing their AS as a whole with flap dampening penalties and such if the link is flaky. However, it is normal order of business with Tier 1s.

But yes, if you have an ASN, you can announce a /24 or bigger directly. You can't do anything smaller, though I have the sneaking suspicion that may change. There are some cranky network operators out there who have not upgraded to equipment with the horsepower and RAM (most importantly RAM) to hold a full BGP view consisting of prefixes down to the /24 granularity, and will indeed filter higher, but they're techically misrouting -- their problem. In any case, that's not the norm, no.

If everybody filtered prefixes smaller than /19 or /20, then multihoming would be the province of a relatively small plutocracy of institutions. I haven't run the numbers any time remotely recently, but most announcements, by volume, are of prefixes smaller than /19 for sure.

Take a look at this:

http://bgp.potaroo.net/as2.0/bgp-active.html

If I'm reading "Prefix Length Distributions" right, 52% of all announcements are /24s, and average prefix length is 22.33.

Now, technically, what's being announced != what's being filtered by influential backbones. But it has to be pretty dang close, or ~52% of all announced networks would not be routable from Sprint. :-)

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by zoomzoom on Thursday September 30, 2010 @12:48PM (#1743902)
I agree that the internet would be better off if it was more decoupled from monolithic backbones. Even more, the commercialization arguments underway sound a lot like arguments to deregulate housing loans in 1995...I do not think that IP addresses should be controlled by cable and datacenter companies, who have every interest to inflate the prices. And that is what market regulation without any standards or rational planning will result in.

An IP address is a human right on the same order as education and cultural freedom. But I bet that even with v4 people could figure out creative ways to get servers running for a lot more people. Let's not be sensationalist.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by tptacek on Thursday September 30, 2010 @03:13PM (#1744448)
Why is an IP address a human right? Isn't "first-class access to the Internet" the right, and IP addresses just an implementation detail?
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by 1053r on Thursday September 30, 2010 @04:08PM (#1744630)
Why is first-class access to the Internet a human right? Isn't "ability to communicate freely" the right, and the Internet just an implementation detail?
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by loup-vaillant on Thursday September 30, 2010 @05:04PM (#1744840)
Well, it's the implementation detail. Right now, without a first class internet connection, you can't completely exercise your ability to communicate (and publish) freely. Likewise, I think that right now, without a public IP, you don't have a first class internet connection.

So, by the contraposition, the transitivity of the implication, and my mathematical powers, having a public IP should be treated as the fundamental right it enables.

Of course, if there are several efficient "implementation details" which enable the layer above, then you just need one of those.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by tptacek on Thursday September 30, 2010 @05:09PM (#1744859)
Your public IP address is also not a first-class Internet connection. You think it is[1], because you have a crappy Internet connection. But if you were an established company trying to use the address for real connectivity, you'd quickly realize that your IP address is nothing more than a stamp your ISP is putting on a connection it's lending you. You cannot, for instance, advertise your /32 on two different networks through BGP. Other people can, because they have better, more meaningful addresses.

So this notion that we all have a fundamental right to full and fair access to the Internet is already subverted by the fact that we're all default-routed second class citizens of the Internet.

In an overlay network world --- a world that is easier for us to travel to than an all-IPv6 world --- this wouldn't be a problem. Addresses would be inherently portable, multihomed access (both through ISPs and through our friends and neighbors) would be the norm, the notion of "server" addresses and "home" addresses (where you can't take port 25 connections) would be extinct.

Unfortunately --- but very importantly --- this is not equally true of an all-IPv6 world. There is nothing magical that IPv6 does to give us all access to the BGP RIB's of top-tier providers. You're still going to be some ISP's b+tch whether your IP address is 32 bits long or 128 bits wrong.

I'm not arguing that people don't have this fundamental right you want them to[2]. I'm saying that the IP address doesn't actually give it to them. Static IP addresses are just something for geeks to argue about while the telcos continue locking down the Internet.

[1] I'm being presumptive because it simplifies the point I'm making; sorry.

[2] All though I don't think they in fact have that right; things that compromise the "right to IP addresses" are invariably first-world kinds of problems.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by loup-vaillant on Thursday September 30, 2010 @05:30PM (#1744946)
Well, being your own ISP[1] is indeed important. To bad it's (1) such a hassle, and (2) the big players don't want to peer with the small ones any more. (In France, the http://fdn.fr non-profit is taking steps towards solving (1))

Overlay networks sound fantastic. Maybe Eben Moglen's FreedomBox (or something similar) could make it a reality?

[1]: For instance by being a member of a non-profit which itself is the actual ISP.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by caf on Saturday October 02, 2010 @10:57AM (#1750545)
So why don't overlay networks, if they're scaled to the size of the global Internet, have exactly the same routing problems internally that BGP has?
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by tptacek on Thursday September 30, 2010 @05:03PM (#1744836)
Sure, if that's what you think. I don't have a problem with that. What I don't understand is why a personal 32-bit (or 128-bit) identifier is a human right. If it is, most of you, including the ones with static addresses, are getting shafted. Your address means less than you probably think it does.