Re:The Opium of the Intellectuals (2005)
by extralego on Sunday July 01, 2018 @01:27AM
(#17434233)
Exactly my point! It’s almost entirely peripheral trivia mounted around a cheap smear. No elaboration, no explanation, no evidence beyond references to past claims.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Is every article supposed to contain the entire history of a topic?
This particular one did not feel like a smear to me as much as a presentation of an opposing perspective, one given in a calm respectful tone which contradicts your obvious tone in trying to smear the article itself.
OK. This was only my interpretation. I don’t have any goals or anything against the author. I actually like some of his art writing. I just think the article delivers a bold misrepresentation of it’s central figure; also one of the most studied persons of the 19th century. It seems silly that’s all.
> Is every article supposed to contain the entire history of a topic?
Every article is supposed to perform however much mental gymnastics are necessary to absolve Marx et al of any fault or flaw.