News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The independent researcher by arcanus on Saturday June 30, 2018 @01:53PM (#17431832)
> I have a feeling that something like Universal Basic Income would give this freedom of time to crowds that can lead towards more people doing science and hence more discoveries.

Agreed. When I was in graduate school I remember thinking that if we had UBI, everyone would become a scientist. I'm sure this was biased by my own interests, but the work often was truly thrilling. Sadly, it is very difficult to find opportunities in academia or industry to pursue work that one finds meaningful without major strings attached.

Most of my graduate school colleagues have left research. I'm a research scientist in industry, but it is increasingly obvious to me that this is relatively rare, particularly given the intellectual freedom and institutional support I am provided. And certainly much of my time is focused on work that has benefit to the corporation, versus open ended projects.

Re:The independent researcher by p1esk on Saturday June 30, 2018 @08:28PM (#17433417)
if we had UBI, everyone would become a scientist

Very few people want to be scientists. To see why, just replace "scientist" with "nerd", because for most people those are synonyms.

Moreover, anyone who wants to do science can become a grad student. That's at least 5 years of "basic income", and access to mentors/tools/resources. All you have to do is to find a lab that does what you're interested in.

Re:The independent researcher by rwallace on Sunday July 01, 2018 @12:32AM (#17434109)
I never heard of a grad student program that pays you to do your research project. The ones I've seen, always offer a choice between paying you to work on someone else's research project, or you get to work on your project but you don't get paid; you do get access to facilities, but you have to pay an exorbitant fee for this. Am I missing something?
Re:The independent researcher by noobhacker on Sunday July 01, 2018 @09:14PM (#17438693)
That's the opposite of my experience and understanding as a fresh PhD. In my field, social science, PhD students 100% own their research agenda. We get paid via a combination of grant (i.e. free money) and RA / TA work (i.e. money you work for). The better the program, the more of the money is free. And you always have the option to apply for external grants to fund yourself. In my (very fortunate) case, I rarely work on others' projects for more than 5 hours a week.

My friends in the natural sciences are more tied to the projects of their supervisors. But in the end they are still expected to be a mature researcher with their own agenda.

Caveat: I'm only certain that this is true for top-50 programs.

Re:The independent researcher by p1esk on Sunday July 01, 2018 @01:05AM (#17434189)
That's why I said you have to find a lab that does what you're interested in. I have done just that, and for the last 5 years as a phd student I've been paid mostly to do what I would do as a hobby otherwise (read/implement deep learning papers), and try to advance state of the art.
Re:The independent researcher by n1231231231234 on Sunday July 01, 2018 @09:26PM (#17438741)
from my own experience, this is the exception, though. even in CS, if you pick some of the more theoretical problems or a not-so-hot area, you might not get funding - (almost) no matter how good you are. and that's CS. move to other subjects like sociology, linguistics, history, and you will find that barely anyone gets funded.
Re:The independent researcher by p1esk on Monday July 02, 2018 @02:37PM (#17444288)
I haven't heard about anyone in any PhD program in US who's not funded one way or another. Sure, you might need to TA a class, but it's usually not that hard, and leaves plenty of time to do research.
Re:The independent researcher by ModernMech on Sunday July 01, 2018 @12:24AM (#17434089)
> anyone who wants to do science can become a grad student

A grad student is an apprentice. This article is about a less taken path for a master. As a former PhD grad student, I can say most grad students are not in a position to conduct independent research. Most get attached to some funding obtained by someone more experienced than them, and then spend most of their time getting up to speed until they are able to write their own papers on that topic. But this leaves them a very narrow set of skills. This is why most academics go through a postdoc.

Re:The independent researcher by p1esk on Sunday July 01, 2018 @01:10AM (#17434198)
write their own papers on that topic

As long as that topic is what they would like to research, I don't see a problem. And if it's not, then they chose a wrong lab/advisor.

But this leaves them a very narrow set of skills

I developed a pretty wide range of skills as a phd student. From developing device models in Spice, to Tensorflow. In fact, I wish I focused on a subset of those skills.

Re:The independent researcher by em3rgent0rdr on Saturday June 30, 2018 @05:22PM (#17432818)
"if we had UBI, everyone would become a scientist"

But then if everyone became a scientist (or whatever else they wanted to do) living off UBI, then where would the UBI come from?

Re:The independent researcher by mmt on Saturday June 30, 2018 @06:08PM (#17432987)
The robots, of course! Joking aside, though, I believe the idea is that, because UBI is subsistence-level, there's still an incentive for those who can earn more (presumably by producing something) to do so, such that they can afford greater luxuries.

Although I'm not categorically opposed to UBI (for some definition of "B"), I am indeed, often concerned that proponents are taking their own personal attitudes and experiences, extrapolating to all other humans, without fully considering less appealling parts of human nature or potential negative emergent/systemic effects at scale.