News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by codingdave on Friday June 29, 2018 @02:01PM (#17426266)
So biologists say there is a limit. But if you only look at the statistics from extreme examples of people over 105, mortality looks flat for a few years, so statisticians say we can live forever.

Is it just me, or is this just bad logic?

Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by ethbro on Friday June 29, 2018 @06:12PM (#17428237)
It's not bad logic, but it is a non-obvious conclusion. Which is why it gets misreported.

One of two things may be true:

1) As we age, mortality rate increases until certain

2) As we age, mortality rate increases, and then levels off at some point

The latter doesn't mean you'll live forever: you're still already rolling the dice at the highest handicap every year. But it does mean there's no fundamental age everyone MUST die by (aka "live forever", if you're one in a billion).

The more interesting differentiation between the two, and the reason biology is interested in the question, is as an answer to "If we want to maximally prolong life, what do we do?"

If the flattening risk (option 2) model is correct, then we could extend life very far indeed by simply preventing people from dying of things that normally kill them by age 85 (e.g. disease, cancer) and then provide them with high quality medical support (to best fight the risk of their expiring from "normal" causes, e.g. accidents).

On the other hand, if it's ever-increasing risk (option 1), we should instead spend our effort at untangling the microbiology mysteries at the root of aging, and see if we can instead re-engineer systems to not work the way they currently do.

Or as my father (PhD in pathology) quips on the whole matter, "At some point, old folks are past the point that all of things that normally kill people would have killed them. And by virtue of still being alive, it's probable they're more resistant. We say they've reached escape velocity."

Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by nonbel on Friday June 29, 2018 @08:02PM (#17428765)
Imagine you keep flipping 10 coins, stopping each once it has come up heads. Eventually all will have come up heads. But if you do this a bunch of times and keep track of how many times you flipped the last coin, there will be a certain number of flips at which the end is most commonly reached.

The "mortality rate" increasing then flattening out is just this curve reaching its peak then declining. The math of this is easy enough to figure out so not sure why there is a mystery amongst biologists about it.

Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by nonbel on Saturday June 30, 2018 @09:29AM (#17430813)
Well hopefully one person actually writes the simulation, etc then calculates the hazard rate curve.

I guarantee that once you understand how universal and simple the phenomenon is that's going here on you will be stunned at the ridiculousness of this "lifespan controversy".

Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by bcheung on Friday June 29, 2018 @03:41PM (#17427185)
It's bad logic and bad journalism.

People have a 50% chance of dying each year over 105 translates to there is no limit to longevity?

Also, the critic in me makes me want to see the actual distribution because I would think there is a tail effect going on and a small group of people are just genetically living much longer.

Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by bthornbury on Friday June 29, 2018 @06:13PM (#17428245)
My interpretation:

Death rates increase every year due to naturally occurring mechanisms in the body. Consider those mechanisms as a function with the body as a parameter and the output as a more aged body (or rather a body with higher probability of failure).

If the body reaches a point where the death rate ceases to increase year per year, it would suggest that those same naturally occuring mechanisms, thought of as a function, approaches some asymptote.

Note this doesn't necessarily mean you stop aging (in appearance), just that your body's rate of failure no longer increases. This suggests that if the reasons for failure can be treated properly, perhaps the body can remain in that equilibrium state indefinitely.

This study provides some preliminary evidence that such an asymptote may exist in the body's natural mechanisms. Both controversial and exciting. Worth exploring further.

Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by ethbro on Friday June 29, 2018 @06:27PM (#17428331)
Exactly. And the really cool thing is "Why?"

Because there are essentially two things that kill you. Either you die of something you get, or you die because your body wears out (as others have pointed out, we know body systems wear and become less effective with aging).

Therefore, if mortality stops increasing with respect to age at a certain point, but we know the body is accumulating additional wear that makes it less resilient, there must also be a corresponding decrease in mortality risk with respect to random things killing you.

So essentially, if you're 100 already... you might have a statistically smaller risk to die from heart disease, cancer, etc than someone who is only 92.

Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by Guest9812398 on Saturday June 30, 2018 @04:25AM (#17430007)
> Therefore, if mortality stops increasing with respect to age at a certain point, but we know the body is accumulating additional wear that makes it less resilient, there must also be a corresponding decrease in mortality risk with respect to random things killing you.

Agreed. I assume older people are receiving higher levels of care, and therefore have a lower risk of dying from random things.

For example, someone age 100 has a small chance of falling and receiving a life threatening injury when they go to get a glass of water from the kitchen. Someone age 115 might have a smaller risk, because they're more likely to be in a wheelchair, and therefore will not stumble and fall. Do they need to change a light bulb? The 100 year old might try to stand on a chair and risk falling. The 115 year old will probably have full-time care, and push a button to alert someone else about the light bulb. Older people usually travel less often, so their chance of dying in a car crash starts to decrease. They're no longer diving with sharks, so shark attack deaths decrease. They're less likely to be outside in a thunderstorm, so lightning related deaths decrease.

Some of those examples are a little silly, but I think the idea is right. When you go from 100 to 115, you decrease your risk of dying from random things (usually because you're no longer doing those things), but you increase your risk of dying from age related factors. These two cancel each other out, and the chance of dying on any given year appears equal. This would mean the study is wrong, and there is a limit to longevity.

Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by mrfusion on Friday June 29, 2018 @07:18PM (#17428583)
It kind of sounds like a battle between repair and failure. And at a certain point they reach an equilibrium. Ie repair stops declining.
Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by meiraleal on Saturday June 30, 2018 @05:10PM (#17432765)
> Note this doesn't necessarily mean you stop aging (in appearance), just that your body's rate of failure no longer increases. This suggests that if the reasons for failure can be treated properly, perhaps the body can remain in that equilibrium state indefinitely.

So sooner you start the "treatment" the better as it is more fun to stop aging around 30 than 70 (which currently is already a thing, people aging a lot better than their parents).

Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by chiefalchemist on Friday June 29, 2018 @04:08PM (#17427457)
More "journalism" with no understanding of numbers? That can't be. (Sarcasm). Just the same, this is also the same profession that still doesn't know the difference between cause and correlation. How can you be allowed to graduate with a degree in journalism and not understand cause v correlation?

That being said, it seems that reading just about an scientific study these days makes you wonder if those doing the publishing understand data analysis, statistics, etc. It seems that too often they find some date, retro-fit a conclusion, ignore the flaws and holes, but still publish because they know the "journalists" won't figure it out either.

And then science complains about the public not buying into ever word science mutters? I don't get it.

Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by dibujante on Friday June 29, 2018 @03:05PM (#17426869)
It means you have a chance of living forever that asymptotically approaches, but does not reach, zero.
Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by frgtpsswrdlame on Friday June 29, 2018 @05:09PM (#17427893)
Isn't that just Zeno's paradox rephrased for aging? If I shoot this arrow it will asymptotically approach but never actually reach you.
Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by theoh on Friday June 29, 2018 @05:42PM (#17428072)
No, in the case of Zeno, we all agree that the arrow would impact at time t, we just argue that you can take tiny timesteps so you never get there. But after time t, the target has definitely been hit.
Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by goatlover on Friday June 29, 2018 @03:51PM (#17427315)
Assuming you can survive the heat death of the universe, and other events not so friendly to biology prior to that point.

It just sounds dumb because it doesn't take into account any physical limitations that would make the curve reach zero.

Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by std_throwaway on Friday June 29, 2018 @02:09PM (#17426351)
It means that they found data not agreeing with the model of limitless increase of mortality with age. This is just a statistical observation, not physics yet, not by a long shot.
Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by joe_the_user on Friday June 29, 2018 @08:14PM (#17428803)
If the statistical claim is true, that morality rates don't increase after 105, then it is "suggestive of the idea" that there isn't a structural limit to age, even if this doesn't in any way yield some immediate immortality (notice how weakly I phrase that). If the chance of dying is the same at 105 and 115, then maybe the things killing one at 105 and at 115 have the same root cause and heading them off could significantly increase lifespans. The alternative scenario is new things appear that would kill one at 115 but not at 105 but one would naively assume that the mortality increases (it may be old things retreat and new things appear however).

Obviously, there are a lot of "ifs" here but the result seems interesting and suggestive.

Re:There's no limit to longevity, says study that revives hu... by tomrod on Friday June 29, 2018 @02:53PM (#17426742)
"Selection" bias takes over at some point. Good genes, good habits, and luck result in a flat mortality rate. Nothing fishy here.