News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by singularity2001 on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @03:46AM (#17406443)
Is it reasonable to hate and avoid IPv6 for fears of further privacy erosion (easier tracking than with IPv4)?

With IPv4 my ISP has to shuffle IPs with every reconnect. With IPv6 you could get one IP for lifetime?

While ISP that hand out a static IPv4 can exist, it's much more unlikely, whereas with IPv6 it will become the norm.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by pilif on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @05:38AM (#17406867)
> Is it reasonable to hate and avoid IPv6 for fears of further privacy erosion (easier tracking than with IPv4)?

no. If an ISP assigns you a dynamic prefix and the various machines in your network use any one of the various privacy features like temporary addresses then the only additional information you leak is some information about how many devices are in your LAN, but as the devices make up additional addresses, it's very fuzzy.

> With IPv4 my ISP has to shuffle IPs with every reconnect. With IPv6 you could get one IP for lifetime?

Your ISP can hand out a new prefix whenever you connect, or even while you are connected. Most of them do this by default.

>While ISP that hand out a static IPv4 can exist, it's much more unlikely, whereas with IPv6 it will become the norm.

it doesn't look like it - at least here in Switzerland, all providers that do provide v6 addresses hand out dynamic prefixes by default and most don't even offer the option of getting a static prefix.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by vetinari on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @06:26AM (#17407064)
Technically, per IPv6 Address Allocation and Assignment Policy[1], there's no such things as a static IPv6 address, only address leased for a long enough period to be effectively static.

[1] https://www.ripe.net/publications/docs/ripe-552#4

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by bcaa7f3a8bbc on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @11:20AM (#17408852)
> no. If an ISP assigns you a dynamic prefix

oppressive regimes will assign people static IPv6 prefixes tied with their legal identities.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by pilif on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @11:34AM (#17408981)
oppressive regimes will assign people static IPv4 addresses tied with their legal identities.
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by bcaa7f3a8bbc on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @12:27PM (#17409468)
If IPv4 pools and carrier-grade IPv4 NATs spreads all over the network, a user's identity is revealed to the oppressive regimes in primarily two ways:

a) IP pool logging, requires a known IP address and time.

b) NAT logging, requires a known IP address, outgoing port number, and time.

It means the cost of tracking users is moderate to ISPs and authorities, also, for a random observer without access to internal records, a IPv4 user is effectively pseudonymous to the city-level until enough information is revealed.

But if the oppressive regimes really assign assign people static IPv6 prefixes tied with their legal identities intentionally, without any type of privacy extension, it would mean after I use my network connection for a while...

__everyone on the Internet, not just ISPs, can track my activity, possibility tied with my legal identity.__

I'm well aware of the existence of mass surveillance on IPv4, and I'm not advocating IPv4 for a false sense of security, I'm all for IPv6. But this is a true issue for consideration. Using a VPN, or Tor for day-to-day web browsing is the only practical solution to this problem I can think of...

On the other hand, IPv6 will bring end-to-end communications back to the Internet and revive P2P. To that day, perhaps a P2P-based, full mesh, optionally anonymous network will become practical. To this extent, IPv6 does more good than harm.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by supertrope on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @01:44PM (#17410201)
Belgium limited ISP side NAT to 16:1 for law enforcement/national security log retention reasons.
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by _trampeltier on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @06:37AM (#17407115)
In switzerland we have still no IPv6 on mobile phones at all in 2018 :-(

With my provider green.ch it is not possible to get a static IPv6.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by nickik on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @06:52AM (#17407173)
You can get static IPv6 from Fiber7.
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by pilif on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @11:36AM (#17409002)
I know. And they even delegate the ip6.arpa domain so you can do reverse lookups with your own DNS server.

source: I'm fiber7 customer since 2014 and they offered me to do the delegation when I asked them for the static prefix.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by nickik on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @02:23PM (#17410526)
Nice. I had the FTTH.300 and only got Fiber7 yesterday. I don't have my own DNS as friend hosts my stuff.

The static prefix is nice and they will also basically give you static IPv4 even without paying.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by icebraining on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @04:18AM (#17406576)
Are they that unlikely? My IPv4 is stable for months/years, despite being "dynamic". I don't even run a dynamic DNS client, since it's so rare that it actually changes.
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by dEnigma on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @07:52AM (#17407418)
It really depends on the ISP. Back when we were still using A1 (what used to be the Austrian telecom basically), we would receive a new IP address every time we reconnected. Now after switching to Liwest (a very local provider, only serves this city and some small towns around it) our IP is for all intents and purposes static, even though it wasn't advertised as such.
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by pixl97 on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @10:11AM (#17408241)
>we would receive a new IP address every time we reconnected.

Some devices like cable modems rarely 'reconnect'. As long as your router and cable modem stay powered you can keep your IP for months.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by dEnigma on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @10:17AM (#17408300)
We used to turn them off as soon as we stopped using the internet (this was also before any of us had a smartphone). I think the ISP also cut the connection every 24 hours and changed the IP to prevent people from having a static IP "for free".
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by lmm on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @04:17AM (#17406566)
No, it's not reasonable.

Allocation of IPv4 address by your ISP is not a secure process; if your privacy depends on it your privacy is already compromised. And address allocation policy is independent of which protocol you're using anyway.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by Symbiote on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @10:51AM (#17408580)
As an example, until about a month ago the reverse DNS of the IPv4 address my ISP assigned to me resolved to [modem-mac-address].large-isp.countrycode

The forward DNS still exists, and is useful (I have a CNAME pointing to it), but the reverse DNS was probably just a convenient but privacy-leaking configuration that was noticed while preparing for GDPR.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by claudex on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @03:52AM (#17406475)
Some ISP provide a different IPv6 at each connection (to sell static IPv6 at higher price). Other ISP provide a /56, which means, you can shuffle on a lot of /64 on your own.

Morevover, there is the privacy extension for IPv6 that change the local part of the IPv6 at regular interval to avoid tracing.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by tjoff on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @09:53AM (#17408086)
I wouldn't be surprised if it will be trivial to look at a certain IP and query how large pool that particular ISP are allocating for each user.
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by Arnt on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @04:15AM (#17406558)
The short version is: No. Not reasonable.

v6 isn't easier to track. Some of the trackability from v4 remains, some goes away. As an example of the latter, if you go to a café with a wlan and stay for an hour, your laptop may use three different v6 addresses in that time.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by rnhmjoj on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @03:55AM (#17406485)
In the worst case the ISP will give you a /64 prefix which you can complete to form an IPv6 address via SLAAC. Operating systems will generate many different temporary addresses with a short lifetime and use those for outbound connections to reduce tracking.
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by lmns on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @03:57AM (#17406493)
You should have a look at the IPv6 privacy extensions. IPv6 doesn't work as you think it does. Your devices use temporary IPs even with a static IPv6 prefix.
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by singularity2001 on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @04:09AM (#17406535)
Can't trackers just map the prefix to your id, or do many users share a prefix? will look it up...
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by Arnt on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @04:19AM (#17406580)
Sometimes, sometimes.

Most ISPs give you a new prefix occasionally, such as every night. They don't need to, but so many do it anyway that a tracker cannot assume that 2001:a61:2574:a00/64 is the same customer as yesterday. It may be the same, usually isn't, so tracking is very imprecise.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by skrause on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @05:12AM (#17406772)
And technically it would be easily possible with IPv6 to have multiple prefixes at the same time. An ISP could give you one static prefix for incoming connections and then an additional dynamic prefix which rotates between customers every 24 hours (leaving old prefixes actives for a week in case you have long-living connections).
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by azernik on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @05:36AM (#17406859)
A single user has at least a /64 (which in IPv6 must correspond to a subnet). This is the equivalent of a NATted IPv4 address for privacy purposes.

Often, in order to allow customers to use multiple subnets, ISPs will allocate a /56 (256 subnets) to customers.

For privacy purposes these have the same behavior as IPv4 addresses, in that they in theory can be rotated between users but in practice have lifetimes on the order of months.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by unethical_ban on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @10:51AM (#17408575)
My IPv4 lease has been static for the past several months. It very rarely changes; I would have to spoof a MAC address on my WAN router to get it to change.
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by clord on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @12:00PM (#17409248)
you don't have to spoof, just leave the WAN device off around the time when your dhcp lease expires. When you come back online, you'll find you have a new lease with likely a new address.
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by supertrope on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @01:53PM (#17410271)
My ISP no longer issues a new IP address upon router change. I'd probably have to go offline for at least a few hours or simultaneously change modem and router. In the meantime my household would notice, our phones would consume more of our cellular quota, my IP phone wouldn't ring, and even my thermostat would lose remote control functionality.

I'm not sure if it's the IPv4 shortage or copyright infringement/government surveillance pressure to maintain tight linkage between IP address, account, and legally liable person or address to raid.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by okket on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @04:51AM (#17406694)
IP client addresses can and do change, be it that they move from landline to mobile or cafe wifi etc. I doubt many use the IP address to track clients for an extended period of time (one hour? one day?).

There are better tools for tracking, like cookies, session IDs, anything that client software voluntarily sends with some request of any kind. Nowadays even with least trackable protocol possible, DNS, as of DNS-over-HTTPS...

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by JdeBP on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @05:33AM (#17406849)
It's the part in the lower 64 bits that does not change as one moves around changing prefixes that worries people. And of course ways to pseudo-randomize that already exist, as mentioned already in this very discussion.
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by pilif on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @05:40AM (#17406881)
for the last 10 years or so, every single OS out there randomises the lower bits by default and even rotates it every few connections.

The thing that remains static is the prefix you got from your ISP but that works in exactly the same way as your v4 address you get when you connect.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by JdeBP on Saturday June 30, 2018 @07:04AM (#17430368)
Not in the scenario actually under discussion by okket here.
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by neojima on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @09:53AM (#17408084)
> With IPv4 my ISP has to shuffle IPs with every reconnect. With IPv6 you could get one IP for lifetime?

In theory, yes; in practice, most ISPs will give you a new prefix via DHCPv6-PD anytime your DUID changes (plus sometimes when it doesn't!).

Your web browser is more liable to erode your privacy than IPv6 is (any more than IPv4, anyway).

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by djsumdog on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @06:40AM (#17407128)
Besides what others are saying, you also have to keep in mind that IPv4 exhaustion means that at some point, IPv4 addresses could become very expensive. Many countries are already totally out. I worked in one data center where we were purchasing blocks from companies in Africa.

My question is, without continued adoption of IPv6, could we get to the point where there are two Internets? One that is more accessible for companies that can still afford IPv4 addresses for their servers? Or will worrying about IPv4 users be such an edge case that it will be like designing for IE11?

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by repolfx on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @03:38PM (#17411128)
Bear in mind privacy advocates also tend to like decentralised systems, but p2p networks benefit from IPv6 a lot.

We can't have it both ways. Either we have flat connectivity and a global address space like IPv6 and have static IPs, or we have to host all services in the cloud. I'd rather have static IPs.

Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by Eech0Shu on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @05:22AM (#17406807)
For the 64bit suffix there are ipv6 privacy extensions. For the prefix some ISPs hand out a whole /56 to the user so their CPE can rotate through multiple /64s over time. And of course just like they can shuffle IPv4s they can also shuffle IPv6s.
Re:Going IPv6 Only [pdf] by detaro on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @10:16AM (#17408289)
I don't hink it's much more unlikely. And in the same vein, some ISPs change your IPv6 prefix regularly. It really depends on the ISP, their technology and their policies.