Re:Show HN: UnityShell, a “shell” for the Unity Editor
by pjmlp on Monday June 25, 2018 @09:52AM
(#17392393)
I have yet to see a professional game engine that wasn't GUI oriented.
Professional game studios are mostly Windows based, and developers are actually a minority in teams, mostly responsible for low level engine code.
So understandably the workflows are optimized for animators, artists, level designers, gameplay developers, script writers, ...
Re:Show HN: UnityShell, a “shell” for the Unity Editor
by mustacheemperor on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @09:00AM
(#17407766)
Aha, that's a very good explanation. Most of my experience with 3D development has been alongside something LOB oriented rather than a "game" per se; like the other commenter suggested Monogame is an example of what I had in mind in my post above.
I have to add the note, Monogame is absolutely up to par with "professional" engines in many ways. I quoted because Monogame originated from such an engine, XDE, Microsoft's managed SharpDX framework for developing games for Xbox Live Arcade. The community took over when MS cancelled XDE. I don't know if it can compete with Unreal or Unity on everything these days, given some of the demos I've seen of Unreal's lighting etc.
Re:Show HN: UnityShell, a “shell” for the Unity Editor
by icsllaf on Monday June 25, 2018 @10:40AM
(#17392751)
I believe MonoGame can be used as text oriented. At least when I tried to use it to make some small games. It's definitely not on the same level of professional use as Unreal or Unity though I think.
Most other engines have different tradeoffs in my experience, and Unity is hard to beat because of how relatively robust and stable it is.