News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by millstone on Monday June 25, 2018 @03:00AM (#17390441)
I want to understand this argument better. Are you claiming that any "structured low entropy process that dissipates energy" is alive? How are you defining life?
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by wool_gather on Monday June 25, 2018 @08:58AM (#17392019)
I may be putting words into the parent's mouth here, but I think the argument is just analogical. That there are emergent effects to physical processes that are difficult/nearly impossible to predict from basic physical law. And therefore we should withhold judgement about the difficulty of life forming, given that we so far have a limited understanding of the relevant physics.
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by andbberger on Monday June 25, 2018 @05:29PM (#17395974)
Nah I mean it pretty literally. You are very right that the necessary physics isn't really there, this is a really difficult thing to state rigorously.

However I would argue that the underlying reasoning emerges out of fairly fundamental physics.. and that while difficult to state rigorously the core idea is kindof... obvious... to anyone with a strong physics background...

Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by andbberger on Monday June 25, 2018 @05:24PM (#17395925)
Pretty much. I define life as any self-sustaining structured low entropy process that dissipates energy faster than diffusion. The low entropy part basically means that such a configuration is vanishingly improbable under _equilibrium_ statistical mechanics.

Under this definition convection rolls, viruses and eukaryotes are all alive.