News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by Spartan-S63 on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:22AM (#17389865)
Additionally, the thought that we're not alone and we're not the most advanced species. If that's the case, then why haven't a more advanced species made contact yet?
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by aswanson on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:45AM (#17389940)
A bacteria in a Petri dish somewhere is saying you don't exist because you'd have sent it messages through sugar chemical signalling by now.
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by adrianmacneil on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:46AM (#17389945)
The answer to this is very obvious:

For the same reason that humans have not "made contact" with ants.

Why do you assume a higher intelligence would even be capable of making contact with us on a level we understand? The discussion would be meaningless, in the same way that an ant would not comprehend our desire to build a freeway right next to their ant hill.

Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by adrianN on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:56AM (#17389988)
We have "made contact" with pretty much every species that display even a little intelligence though, including ants. Ants just don't notice when they run inside some scientist's experiment. Do you propose that we're so drastically inferior that we don't even know someone is having us find the cheese in a maze?
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by millstone on Monday June 25, 2018 @03:18AM (#17390511)
Yes, I think this is literally true. Messages may be encoded in the arrangement of stars, via PCM-neutrinos, etc., and humanity would be ignorant.

The history of biology is discovering species in places previously thought unlivable: impossibly salty environments, volcanic vents, etc. A natural extension is finding species in places "above" humanity.

Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by pdonis on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:54AM (#17389979)
That just rephrases the question to: Why hasn't a higher intelligence built their equivalent of a freeway right through our ant hill?
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by adrianmacneil on Monday June 25, 2018 @01:29AM (#17390078)
An ant cannot "see" not comprehend the purpose of a freeway, no matter how hard we might try to explain it. It would walk right over it and not think it were any different than your average rock.
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by pdonis on Monday June 25, 2018 @02:09PM (#17394395)
Sure, but that doesn't change the fact that the ant's ant hill gets destroyed if the freeway is built over it. Or that the ant itself gets crushed if it gets run over while walking across the freeway. The ant will notice those things even if it doesn't understand what caused them.
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by adrianmacneil on Tuesday June 26, 2018 @10:55AM (#17401040)
Exactly. Thus far, all we can say for sure is that we have not yet been carelessly crushed to make room for some intergalactic freeway we do not understand.

That doesn't mean there isn't one right in front of our eyes though.

Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by pdonis on Tuesday June 26, 2018 @10:09PM (#17405310)
> That doesn't mean there isn't one right in front of our eyes though.

If there were, I would expect us to be carelessly crushed in a short period of time.

Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by okonomiyaki3000 on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:42AM (#17389931)
a) There are only around 500 stars within the 100-or-so-light-year radius that our transmissions have reached. Does intelligent life arise on 1/500 planets? I'd say not even close.

b) Maybe they have no way to reach us. Despite sci-fi speculation, we still have no reason to believe the speed of light is not the ultimate speed limit of the universe.

c) Maybe they don't care. Aliens in movies often come here to invade us, eat us, steal our resources, etc. But, if any species had the level of technology to come all the way here with a force large enough to subjugate us, they wouldn't need to. Far more resources than they could take from this planet are already freely available floating around in space much easier to take.

d) Maybe they're so different from us that they don't even notice we are anything. Maybe we wouldn't notice them either.

Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by squirrelicus on Monday June 25, 2018 @01:14AM (#17390032)
a) the kind of ship required to travel interstellar at a reasonable pace, such as a nuclear termal rocket or antimatter rocket or the like, is pretty well understood in theory. It will glow like a galactic beacon and would be visible from vastly further away than 100 light years. Unless we're somehow technologically ahead of all other existing civs in our light window, should see somewhere, anywhere, anywhen, a single ship. But we don't. There just ain't ships out there.

(b) I agree. We have all reasons to believe it is not possible to accelerate something with mass to 'c'. We know this with astronomical levels of certainty. Anything that changes location without acceleration is either pure energy or pure fantasy.

(c) I agree. Even Dyson spheres don't have the raw energy capture to move an Earth of resources out of the sun's gravity well. Perhaps an Earth has rare and valuable resources that are quickly expended, with high value per kilogram. But there's no reason to believe an Earth would be special. The only real reason aliens have to contact us are the same reasons they'd try to immediately genocide us to get us out of their way anyway.

(d) this is an entire field of xenospeculation, but high energy rockets are really bright and very probably the only way to get to a different place in space. You pretty much have to talk microbe scale to go unnoticed in space.

[Edit, misread point b]

Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by okonomiyaki3000 on Monday June 25, 2018 @08:11PM (#17396951)
The brighter a craft is, the less efficient it is. Every photon it emits in a random direction is energy that could have been better used to push it toward its destination. So, if any civilization out there really is super advanced, their ships may be extremely hard to detect. Also, a situation like Star Wars or Star Trek where beings in space vessels just cruise around the galaxy for personal reasons is highly unlikely at any technological level. We shouldn't expect to see a lot of ships out there.
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by squirrelicus on Monday June 25, 2018 @08:54PM (#17397147)
The brighter a craft is, the more thrust power (watts) it emits. Both rocket efficiency (exhaust velocity) and thrust (newtons) contribute to thrust power multiplicatively if I remember correctly.

Any craft capable of moving things in our medium size realm or larger will glow. If you want to direct your exhaust along a cohesive line, you're basically talking lasers. And those can't really provide much thrust power.

If the hypothesis is that there are interstellar civs out there that don't exchange beings or materials, it's pretty hard to call them interstellar.

Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by okonomiyaki3000 on Monday June 25, 2018 @11:58PM (#17397767)
If you want to travel back and forth between inhabitable stars, forget rockets. They're just never going to get you moving fast enough.

I'm basically talking about a propulsion system that we haven't imagined yet. Because nothing we've (realistically) imagined would make an interstellar civilization possible.

I didn't say they wouldn't exchange beings or materials at all. I'm just saying that individuals will not be hopping in their space cars and cruising off to the crab nebula for the weekend.

Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by leeeeech on Monday June 25, 2018 @01:36PM (#17394158)
> It will glow like a galactic beacon

There's no reason to believe it would have to accelerate for all its curse.

> You pretty much have to talk microbe scale to go unnoticed in space.

There are myriads of stars we know nothing about, planets being discovered; and dust clouds only detectable because they are unbelievably huge.

Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by jbigelow76 on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:42AM (#17389933)
One theory I've come across (can't recall where though) is that we aren't worth contacting given how un-advanced/different we are relative to whoever else is out there. The analogy goes, when the Spanish Conquistadors arrived in the Caribbean and Americas in the 16th century they walked ashore and didn't even notice the little ants under foot as they claimed the land and killed the indigenous peoples; we're the ants in this scenario, we haven't been contacted because we aren't worth it.
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by pdonis on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:56AM (#17389984)
The ants weren't "contacted" in the sense of being asked anything, but that doesn't mean they were undisturbed. The question is not why intelligent aliens way beyond our tech level haven't tried to talk to us; the question is why they haven't just happened to crush us underfoot in the course of going about their normal business.
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by jbigelow76 on Monday June 25, 2018 @01:21AM (#17390050)
Part of the explanation of the whole conquistador/ant analogy addressing that point is that maybe other beings travel inter-dimensionally or in some other manner that isn't what we take for granted to be the only logical way to get around the universe, big ass spaceships, those would definitely disturb our ant pile.
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by booleandilemma on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:59AM (#17389993)
Maybe we’re being kept isolated like in C.S. Lewis’ “Out of the Silent Planet”:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Out_of_the_Silent_Planet

Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by vl on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:56AM (#17389985)
Because of the prime directive, of course.
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by thereau on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:26AM (#17389875)
Even if there are more advanced species, maybe they can't travel far enough to contact us. Or maybe they contacted other civilisations and we are just too far to bother.
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by fzeroracer on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:44AM (#17389937)
Imagine the various uncontacted tribes that still exist. Considering how many humans there are, why hasn't there been more malicious actors striving to make contact with these people?

Granted this isn't a 100% proper analogy because a lot of these tribes have been contacted prior and have knowledge of the outside world. Yet it could be as something as simple as that; if there are far more advanced species we could be simply left to our own devices on purpose.

Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by xenadu02 on Monday June 25, 2018 @01:10AM (#17390020)
1. Space is very, very large. 2. Traveling between stars takes a very long time. 3. Other than a desire for exploration there is no need. Resources and planets are plentiful. 4. It now appears there is only an extremely brief window during which a technological species broadcasts in a detectable way.

#4 is probably the biggest problem. Digital compressed broadcasts would be difficult to detect, and by the time you have that technology you can build much more sensitive receivers and don't waste energy dumping millions of watts into space.

There could be 1000 intelligent species in the Milky Way right now and it is still unlikely any would visit our solar system within the past 10,000 years, nor in the next 10,000 and we would not be able to detect their faint compressed, encrypted broadcasts.

Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by mirimir on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:33AM (#17389903)
Because they've seen enough TV to know that we're dangerous.
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by Herodotus38 on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:41AM (#17389930)
Read the book "The Three Body Problem" and the rest of the trilogy, it provides a very interesting and scary theory that I don't want to ruin.
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by keithnz on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:40AM (#17389923)
well, our RF penetration of the galaxy is tiny... just over 100 years or so. and the galaxy is about 100k light years across.... so.....
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by econochoice on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:30AM (#17389894)
Why assume an alien species would value contact?
Re:Model predicts we're the only advanced civilization in th... by VvR-Ox on Monday June 25, 2018 @03:31AM (#17390571)
exactly, if they'd see what we do and were inteligent they would just leave us here to die :D