News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by ggambetta on Friday June 22, 2018 @10:49AM (#17374352)
I'm confused.

When engineers from a company who deals with the military (or some other ethically objectionably client) don't refuse to work on these projects, HN questions their values and urges them to make a stand, refuse, find another job if necessary, etc.

When the engineers do refuse, HN criticises them for beign self-righteous, virtue-signalling, and unpatriotic because countries with a lower ethical bar (Russia and China are the usual ones) are going to surpass the US in cyberwar.

So... which is it?

Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by nemild on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:16PM (#17375131)
There is not often a monolithic "HN", but instead a group of people who decide to engage or not based on the subject matter.

We need more media literacy around HN and Reddit. You just need a few users to upvote something, and people often respond when they see the opposing view (this is why conservatives and liberals in the US so often take the most extreme statements on the other side, and critique/retweet them; better engagement and an easier way to caricature the opposing side).

It's interesting to think about how different posts attract wholly different tribes, meaning HN is hundreds of sub-groups not a monolith. There might be a post on a Ruby gem, and the entire commenter group are Ruby-ists who hold common views on opposing languages. You might see this as "HN believes X", but instead it's the subset of people attracted by that post that you're really interacting with.

Will add this as an example to my media literacy guide for engs:

https://github.com/nemild/hack-an-engineer

Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by asafira on Friday June 22, 2018 @01:36PM (#17375795)
To expand a bit: I think we need to embrace the fact that often times we have posts that don't have a "right" response --- i.e., where you can get a good view of exactly the right way to feel about something given the first few comments. Lots of these issues have many angles you can come from, and I hope people are

(a) willing to keep themselves to a high-enough standard to think for themselves and see that it's a grey area (that they might have a bias for one side or another). You can't just assume the top post is definitely the right thing, even with a good number of upvotes.

(b) willing to read more posts further down, giving them plenty of respect, and contribute to the conversation.

Maybe a better way to rank comments is something more probabilistic rather than just ranking by (num_upvotes - num_downvotes). (Actually, how is it done now?)

Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by crankylinuxuser on Friday June 22, 2018 @01:57PM (#17375946)
> I think we need to embrace the fact that often times we have posts that don't have a "right" response

Indeed. I know I keep seeing during the immigration debate (of which is recent). Liberal-leaning say that we should provide due process and let in refugees. This is argument in good faith.

Conservatives say that we have a body of law that must be adhered to regarding immigration. This too is a valid argument. I may disagree with its interpretation, but I believe it too is in good faith.

"Womp womp", "I dont really care do u" is the style of discourse we're seeing. If the administration comments were on here with HN, dang would likely make the comment dead and leave a message of a ban.

Back to the main point - it feels like society as a whole (and HN within that) is lowering the accuracy and persuasive qualities of language to something I saw elsewhere. Idiocracy. Who can shout the loudest; Who can rapid-fire lies and half-truths; who can redirect hatred and bile - these people seem to be the ones on top dictating properness these days.

Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by nemild on Friday June 22, 2018 @02:28PM (#17376163)
But even Dang is just a single person. We really need to design systems (social networks) that encourage this type of thoughtful debate. Right now, all the incentives in social media are around "engagement" (upvotes, likes, retweets, large amounts of comments)
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by andrei_says_ on Friday June 22, 2018 @02:11PM (#17376045)
Thank you for the resource you’ve created on github. Love seeing using that platform for non-code related projects.
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by Judgmentality on Friday June 22, 2018 @01:46PM (#17375870)
> and people often respond when they see the opposing view (this is why conservatives and liberals in the US so often take the most extreme statements on the other side, and critique/retweet them; better engagement and an easier way to caricature the opposing side)

https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2013-04-07

Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by nemild on Friday June 22, 2018 @02:37PM (#17376239)
This is great! Added to my media literacy guide:

https://github.com/nemild/hack-an-engineer/commit/3d8091960e...

Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by emaginniss on Friday June 22, 2018 @10:52AM (#17374388)
There's probably more than one person on HN
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by Bartweiss on Friday June 22, 2018 @11:13AM (#17374564)
True, but there's at least something to which comments end up at the top. My sense has been that "programmers need better ethics" almost always tops out the "programmers worked with the government" stories, and outside of this chain "programmers are being self-righteous and unpatriotic" has had basically all the top slots in this thread.

I suppose the easy guess is just that people who disagree with a story are more likely to come argue in the comments than people who read it and agree, so every story gets its opposite upvoted.

Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by taneq on Friday June 22, 2018 @11:34AM (#17374753)
There's probably more than one person voting on HN.
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by vbezhenar on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:08PM (#17375066)
Also different topics attract people with different views.
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by Cthulhu_ on Friday June 22, 2018 @11:35AM (#17374776)
When it comes to voting, strong opinions (one way or the other) will always end up on top.
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by hungerstrike on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:24PM (#17375216)
I have pretty strong opinions that never get to the top, such as "Apple tech is mostly gimmicky, trendy garbage whereas Microsoft tech is mostly the best mix of freedom, flexibility and quality". Probably even just using that as my example here will harm me!

There are definite, identifiable leanings from the denizens here on HN.

Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by always_good on Friday June 22, 2018 @01:34PM (#17375783)
Yes, but that's a poor example since the reverse would get downvoted as well.

If you want to be the top comment, your dismissal needs to be more middlebrow and noncommittal.

Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by hungerstrike on Thursday June 28, 2018 @09:06AM (#17416500)
Incorrect. Here's proof - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17414081

Their comment: Windows is terrible. (No downvotes.)

My comment: Windows is the best. (-4 downvotes.)

Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by spoiledtechie on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:05PM (#17375035)
Agreed! Glad we don't always come to a consensus. Discourse is allowed.
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by fixermark on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:55PM (#17375503)
[citation needed] ;)
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by aplummer on Friday June 22, 2018 @10:58AM (#17374434)
The problem with discourse in 2018 is outrage motivates people to comment more than anything. “What gets rewarded gets done” so the place becomes an outrage factory, then online discourse self selects for outrage, then cycle.
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by aplummer on Friday June 22, 2018 @11:02AM (#17374468)
Maybe I should change that.

In this case frankly I can see both sides. I refused to work on a cigarette company once, but didn’t refuse to work on operation sovereign borders (because of project specifics) other people might decide differently in each case.

Bit of a dull comment probably, but I think there are two sides to it.

Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by Kurtz79 on Friday June 22, 2018 @10:56AM (#17374414)
"HN" is not a single entity and it is made up of los of people with different opinions and values.

If everybody had the same point of view, there would be no ground for a discussion...

Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by briankirby on Friday June 22, 2018 @10:55AM (#17374410)
I'm confused.

You seem to think everyone on HN agrees with each other.

Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by stonogo on Friday June 22, 2018 @11:19AM (#17374624)
Are you really confused, or did you just phrase your comment that way to mock the parent comment?
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by buddhistan on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:23PM (#17375207)
Are you really wondering their intent, or did you just phrase your question to point out the implication of their comment?
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by Kluny on Friday June 22, 2018 @01:07PM (#17375585)
I'm personally glad that HN is not a complete echo chamber and that multiple points of view can surface to the top. Do you find it a problem that the thousands of people who read this site don't all share a consistent philosophy?
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by ggambetta on Friday June 22, 2018 @01:36PM (#17375802)
Not at all. I'm just surprised that when an article says X, everyone seems to be against X. Then shortly afterwards there's an article that says (not X), and everyone seems to be against (not X).
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by gcb0 on Friday June 22, 2018 @11:30AM (#17374718)
lol. right now the HN front page item right under this one has everyone celebrating a spacex military contract.
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by jimbofisher1 on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:22PM (#17375192)
Elon Musk is some kind of enlightened prophet to most techies despite mountains of evidence that he is a shitty person running shitty companies.
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by throwaway37585 on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:48PM (#17375439)
> mountains of evidence

> shitty person

> shitty companies

Elaborate?

Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by fixermark on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:59PM (#17375532)
He's in the middle of a culture clash between (traditionally union-friendly) automotive industry and (traditionally union-hostile) Silicon Valley startup, and he appears to be tossing his lot with the SV startup ecosystem.

That has rubbed a lot of people the wrong way.

(Possibly more importantly: he's also fallen prey, it seems, to the traditional SV startup ecosystem behavior of overselling capabilities in the Tesla cars, which may be contributing to avoidable deaths as people assume the low-tier driver assist the cars actually have is real self-driving functionality. I'm not sure why this bug hasn't propagated to SpaceX; perhaps he's populated the company with enough rocketeers to know that it's very much a "Screw up and people die" industry, and he's hands-off enough to let them succeed).

Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by s73v3r_ on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:59PM (#17375530)
It's almost like there's more than one person on HN, with different thoughts and ideas.
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by dominotw on Friday June 22, 2018 @01:39PM (#17375822)
You can refuse the work assigned to you and not get fired? Sounds like my dream job :D.
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by gojomo on Friday June 22, 2018 @03:00PM (#17376457)
Mu. There is no "HN" as a single mind.
Re:Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Mi... by Bhilai on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:22PM (#17375195)
To each his own.