> It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.
EDIT: my comment seems random the way it is, but the quote implies that a theory must be correct/consistent in order to matter at all... while he knows there is an unresolved inconsistency!
This does not detract from his phrase in any way.
Of course, Feynman was right to dismiss those experiments. It's his quote which is cute, oversimplified, and wrong. It's Duhem-Quine all over.
"You have to worry about your own work and ignore what everyone else is doing" - stepsandleaps.wordpress.com/2017/10/17/feynmans-breakthrough-disregard-others/
I'm not sure if that's true. At the very least, his story is given a lot of attention in my country's high school physics syllabus.
The Michelson-Morley experiments were a failure in that they didn’t find what they were looking for (Aether), but relativity came out of trying to understand that “failure” (rather, the null results of the experiment - calling not seeing something you expect a failure is an oversimplification)
I must note that Michelson-Morley didn't find Aether _wind_, which is expected if you take in account Sagnac effect.
"All these challenges arise because of physics’ adherence to reductive unification. Admittedly, the method has a distinguished pedigree. During my PhD and early career in the 1990s, it was all the rage among theorists, and the fiendishly complex mathematics of string theory was its apogee. But none of our top-down efforts seem to be yielding fruit. One of the difficulties of trying to get at underlying principles is that it requires us to make a lot of theoretical presuppositions, any one of which could end up being wrong."
"Instead, many of us have switched from the old top-down style of working to a more humble, bottom-up approach. Instead of trying to drill down to the bedrock by coming up with a grand theory and testing it, now we’re just looking for any hints in the experimental data, and working bit by bit from there."
In practice, both ways to look at the evidence are needed. And in pure science, sometimes a lot has to be done in many different directions before some of non-obvious directions bear fruits. One of big dangers is inventing the experiments that will surely "confirm." The big insights come also when something expected by the most is not confirmed, like the famous
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelson%E2%80%93Morley_exper...
Without these experiments Einstein wouldn't be able to invent General Relativity. The popular culture talks too much about Einstein but sadly doesn't understand and hardly even knows Michelson.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Albert_A._Michelson
His experiment, from the end of the 19th century, is also the basis of the LIGO experiments that just recently confirmed gravitational waves:
https://www.ligo.caltech.edu/page/ligos-ifo
"Although much more sophisticated, at their cores, LIGO's interferometers are fundamentally Michelson Interferometers, a device invented in the 1880's."
The 1880's experiments didn't "confirm" what was "expected" but they are one of the most impressive science success stories, looking from what we know now.
Of course, LIGO itself is a technological marvel compared to what was possible in 1880, and we should celebrate all the advanced experiments where our reach extends. Not "confirming" expected can be even much bigger story, even if it disappoints those whose "pet" "expected" theory is not confirmed.