Where could I go to read up on this without being a networking expert? Are there any safe ways to play with BGP in a lab environment? How expensive would said lab be to set up?
How expensive would said lab be to set up? it heavily depends on what you want. for a high available lab you would of course need multiple nodes/routers, depends on what you want to do.
for just playing with bgp, actually using bird http://bird.network.cz/ is good enough.
Actually ripe sometimes publishes articles with BGP. Here is one that sets up a ANYCAST routing with BGP https://labs.ripe.net/Members/samir_jafferali/build-your-own...
BIRD is super easy to setup, too.
Especially when there are several-year old bugs open against consul, where it just completely loses consensus and can't deal with losing a single node(0)
0: https://github.com/hashicorp/consul/issues/993#issuecomment-...
I don't have skin in the game but it makes sense that a much older, tested technology would have more people who know it well.
You don't need application level "discovery" when the IP never changes; the network will tell you where it currently lives.
I'll take a layer 3 network over raft/consul any day and all night.