News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by gorpomon on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:03PM (#17360227)
Absolutely disgusting, there's really not much more nuance to this. I can't fathom a situation where we want to automate what should be human interactions. Talking with children, in person, where they can learn from their mistakes, is a great way to create long lasting discipline. Sure it's hard work, but if we offload this to computers we're actively removing humanity from the situation.
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by mschuster91 on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:25PM (#17360396)
> but if we offload this to computers we're actively removing humanity from the situation.

This massively reminds me of the "The machine fired me" [0] post from today morning's HN front page. Or, for what it matters, of the inhumanity that currently goes on in the US, with even toddlers being detained (https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/tender-age-shelters-tru...).

Following orders, eh?

> I can't fathom a situation where we want to automate what should be human interactions.

I can, it's called fascism. Break the individual responsibility of a human down and you can get them to do anything. There is a reason why in firing squads some members always have blank magazines [1] and why in the lethal injection sites a random of the required buttons for delivery will not work[2]. The individual member can try to evade responsibility by thinking "it was my button/gun that had the blanks" (apparently called "Diffusion of responsibility").

I recommend everyone able to do so a visit to Europe and one of the concentration camps the Nazis built. No matter which one, there are more than enough sites to remind us of what humans can do.

[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17350645 (thanks to @larkeith for pointing it out)

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Execution_by_firing_squad#Blan...

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lethal_injection#Procedure_in_...

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by lainga on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:32PM (#17360448)
As they say, Mussolini made the trains driverless.
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by lockes5hadow on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:51PM (#17360596)
I can't find the article you mention, "A machine fired me". Do you have a link?
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by larkeith on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:59PM (#17360658)
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by pmh on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:53PM (#17360614)
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by gowld on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:52PM (#17360606)
Continuing off-topic... What of the inhumanity of parents dragging their toddlers across national borders without a plan to safely reach a destination?
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by mschuster91 on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:08PM (#17360722)
> What of the inhumanity of parents dragging their toddlers across national borders without a plan to safely reach a destination?

Compared with certain death, either due to hunger or being forced to fight for drug cartels or in pointless wars, fleeing without a safe plan is the lesser evil.

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by ilikehurdles on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:06PM (#17360705)
Perfect excuse to kidnap the children of the neediest among us.

/s

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by kickopotomus on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:57PM (#17360637)
Yeah, you are right. They should have just ditched the kid and crossed alone. /s
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by fake-name on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:07PM (#17360257)
> I can't fathom a situation where we want to automate what should be human interactions.

I can. When you're a for-profit organization. People are expensive.

This is basically late-stage capitalism.

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by darawk on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:33PM (#17360461)
> I can't fathom a situation where we want to automate what should be human interactions.

Really? You'd rather call the taxi company and make an appointment with a person than use Uber? You'd rather ask a librarian to do your google searches for you?

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by tylerhou on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:38PM (#17360500)
He said "we shouldn't automate what we shouldn't automate", not "we shouldn't automate anything."
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by darawk on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:43PM (#17360533)
Yes, which is a pointless tautology.
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by bigiain on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:48PM (#17360941)
Tautology yes - pointless - perhaps not.

It points out that there are many things which are automatable, but that the capability to automate things cannot be the decision driver of whether things should be automated.

At one end of the scale, ATMs replacing some bank tellers seems to have been widely accepted as OK. In the middle, self serve supermarket checkouts (here in .au at least) are saving staff costs for the supermarkets with the side effect of pushing shoplifting prevention and enforcement costs off to the local police instead of supermarket staff, which is not such a great automation outcome (unless you're the manager who got the bonus for reducing headcount costs at the supermarket). At the end alluded to in the discussion of this article, I think it's pretty clear that attempts to automate discipline of children is an abhorrent idea.

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by tylerhou on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:19PM (#17360774)
Okay, but then your response is just as pointless as his tautology.
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by darawk on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:26PM (#17360816)
My point is that "should be human interactions" is a meaningless standard. The only way it could be meaningful is if it meant "anything that used to involve human interaction, and now doesn't". I was rebutting that interpretation of it, which seemed to me to be what the OP was implying.
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by candu on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:44PM (#17360920)
They provided a pretty clear example: actually talking to children is important to develop socialization and maturity (read: executive function). This is one area where machines absolutely cannot do the job anywhere near equally well - i.e., something that should involve human interaction.
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by darawk on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:54PM (#17360962)
> This is one area where machines absolutely cannot do the job anywhere near equally well

Citation needed. You're neglecting the fact that there are millions of under-interacted kids in the world. Providing a cheap source of interaction for them could be extremely valuable. Just saying "their parents/teachers/whoever should do it" does absolutely nothing to solve the problem. Building them a robot does.

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by quadrangle on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:50PM (#17360949)
[note: this is my first post on the thread]

> "should be human interactions" is a meaningless standard

What irony! The entire concept is that there is a place for real human judgments and not just rigid programs/rules!

What "should be human interactions" is not meaningless. It means: there should be humans judging what should be left to human judgment. It's an assertion that there ARE things that shouldn't be just standards we blindly follow.

It wasn't saying any human interaction automatically matters. Tasks where a human would just follow rigid protocol are ones that should be automated…

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by darawk on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @08:24PM (#17361094)
> What "should be human interactions" is not meaningless. It means: there should be humans judging what should be left to human judgment. It's an assertion that there ARE things that shouldn't be just standards we blindly follow.

You mean...humans like the humans who decided to buy this software? Presumably you don't just mean 'humans'. You mean the 'right' humans. But which humans are those? Who decides which ones the right humans are? It's just a circular argument that reduces to "humans should do human stuff", unless you want to actually articulate a standard, but you have definitely not done that yet.

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by quadrangle on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:39AM (#17366136)
> Presumably you don't just mean 'humans'

Bad presumption. The argument is about the difference between humans versus computer programs. Whichever case, I want the 'right' ones (i.e. the best ones doing good not evil), so the 'right' ones isn't the differentiation here.

Whatever the argument is, there's an argument that having real people instead of programs matters for some things. And the standard we can use is something like "the things where they aren't interchangeable" at least (although others may have other qualities to emphasize). So, a person who literally just does the exact same thing a program can do can be replaced by the program. For example, data entry. A person who cannot be duplicated nearly exactly by a program is where we want to be careful about considering keeping the human position around. For example, teachers.

I heard a quip that computers are passing the Turing Test more these days… but not just because they are getting more sophisticated — human beings are failing the test more (are acting more like computer programs). The point being that "human interactions" in the argument here implies humans engaged in natural human thought and intuitions and communication and not just following protocol so rigidly that they effectively are just carrying out program instructions.

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by darawk on Thursday June 21, 2018 @02:24PM (#17367932)
> Whatever the argument is, there's an argument that having real people instead of programs matters for some things. And the standard we can use is something like "the things where they aren't interchangeable" at least (although others may have other qualities to emphasize). So, a person who literally just does the exact same thing a program can do can be replaced by the program.

I agree. But my point is that most people who talk about these things don't do a very good job in thinking about which things should and should not be automated. They basically just look at whatever has been automated (which they love being automated, now that it has been) and say "Automating that stuff was great!", and look at the things that haven't been automated and say "Automating that stuff is bad! It is essential to the human experience!".

> For example, data entry. A person who cannot be duplicated nearly exactly by a program is where we want to be careful about considering keeping the human position around. For example, teachers.

Why? Why would automating teachers be bad? I'll give you two separate arguments why this would not be a bad thing:

1. Access: Teachers require human labor, which is in finite supply. This means that not every child on earth has access to teachers, and sometimes if they do, the teachers they do have access to are spread incredibly thin, making them effectively useless. Automating teaching has the potential to massively expand access to the extremely underprivileged. Teachers also operate on a set schedule. If the class starts at 8pm, and you have a job that requires you to be at work at that time, well, tough luck for you. If you automate teaching, this problem goes away.

2. Personalization, optimization, and equity. Human teachers can tailor their lessons a little bit to the individual, but high quality AI instruction promises to expand that greatly. Also, not all human teachers are good. Figuring out which ones are and are not good takes a lot of time, and wastes thousands of hours of child development, and sometimes doesn't happen at all. If we had artificial instructors, they would be the same for everyone. We would be able to optimize their methodology, and ensure they are teaching at a minimum standard of quality - however we want to define that. This also opens up massive opportunity for improving equity among races, classes and whatever other social divisions you want to impose. Now, that isn't a given, AI has the potential to encode our own biases. But unlike in human instruction, we actually have the opportunity to correct those biases if we're careful in designing the AI - we have no such opportunity for human instructors.

The problem, I think, is that when people think about AI replacing teachers, they think about all their favorite experiences with human teachers, and how those might be lost. And that may well be true. But what about all of the negative ones? What about all the kids who's teachers were lazy or having a bad day that day? AI doesn't have bad days. It doesn't get tired. It doesn't dislike children because they're queer. It doesn't get frustrated by insolence. It teaches at the same standard of quality every day.

So yes, maybe some of the great human experiences may be lost. But so too will the negative ones. And it's really not obvious which side of that equation is more important. But that's sort of the point: it's not obvious.

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by quadrangle on Saturday June 23, 2018 @08:54PM (#17384361)
Well, yeah. I agree with all this, including the premise that automated teaching is potentially positive, maybe substantially so. But the case has to be made for it. And the argument that there are things that should stay human relies on the presumption that we have not gotten to an adequate understanding that automated teaching would be as good as quality human teaching…

I mean, everything I'm saying is based entirely on taking a charitable interpretation of someone else's comment. Instead of asserting that a comment is just a useless circular logic, I'm saying that we can make sense of it better.

An assertion like "should be human interactions" is an assertion that there exist things that will never be better automated (at least compared to the higher-quality examples of human interactions). I'm disagreeing with your argument that such an assertion needs to specify which interactions those are. It's merely stating that it's a non-zero list and leaving the determination to others at a future time.

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by gorpomon on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:20PM (#17375175)
No need to get into it online. Simply put there are situations that can be successfully automated, like hailing taxis. There are also situations where we automate them to our detriment, like in this case.

Also, yes! I would ask a librarian to search for me! Librarians are AWESOME and can find things in places you didn't think to look. Everyone should ask a librarian in addition to doing their own Google search.

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by paganel on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:45PM (#17360549)
> You'd rather call the taxi company and make an appointment with a person than use Uber?

Not the OP, but yes, I actually do that, I mean, I've avoided installing an extra app that would track my every move (the Uber app) and I prefer calling the taxi company on the phone. I also very frequently take random taxis from street corners or the like.

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by darawk on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:47PM (#17360568)
What do you feel this affords you?
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by paulie_a on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:09PM (#17360726)
You get the pleasure of dealing with some of the most miserable people in the first world. Seriously though taxi drivers are unequivocally the worst customer facing people to deal with.
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by paganel on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:51PM (#17360601)
In case yours was a serious question: human interaction (actually talking with a human on the phone), not giving my CC details to yet another company, like I said, not being tracked by the same company (which was caught doing some pretty not-cool stuff).
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by gowld on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:54PM (#17360618)
Why isn't using an app a human interaction? Just like a phone call, it's a communication mediated by technology, not a direct contact.
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by paganel on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:57PM (#17360638)
Because there's no human voice at the other end of the communication channel...? I mean, I don't want to sound rude or anything, but isn't that obvious? Am I already in the wrong demographic because of my age (late 30s)? Do people nowadays equate using a phone app with genuine human interaction?
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by dual_basis on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:57PM (#17360981)
"Yeah, and nobody writes letters anymore!" - Grandpa

"Are you kidding? Too many people write things down, it causes forgetfulness." - Socrates

I don't see what value a 2 minute conversation with a human who is essentially following a script and pressing the same buttons on their end that you could have pushed on yours has. Despite the audio portion of the human's voice, this is still an extremely shallow form of human interaction. You are better off saving the time and having a more meaningful connection with someone else later.

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by paganel on Thursday June 21, 2018 @02:27AM (#17362614)
Then you have to wonder: why speak with non-strangers at all? Apart from a couple of friends and close family pretty much all human interactions are “shallow” by definition. You might see that as a “bug” that wastes us time but instead I see it as a feature that helps us remain in one congruent piece as a functioning society. Thanks for bringing Socrates into the discussion, but I think Asimov is more suited for it, I’m thinking of one of his stories where sometime in the future humans live isolated from each other on big farms, surrounded only by robots, with all communications happening through some sort of screens (if I remember correctly).
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by briandear on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:03PM (#17360692)
I specifically don’t want human interaction for menial things. It’s a waste of my time and adds no value to the transaction. If I neee a friend, I’ll talk to a friend. As far as CC details, we have fraud protection and can disable a card at the first sign of trouble. With Apple Pay it’s even more secure.
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by paganel on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:12PM (#17360743)
> It’s a waste of my time and adds no value to the transaction. It’s a waste of my time and adds no value to the transaction.

I find this attitude extremely alienating, at least in my case. I've been through several dark periods in my life and having constant human interactions even for "menial things" was one of the things that has kept me above the water, so to speak. I also don't associate human interactions (even with strangers) to making "transactions" or the like, that, to a person like me, looks like treating people as means instead of ends in themselves (I'm a kantian when it comes to morals, or at least I try to). We cannot keep a compact and well-functioning society if we start seeing talking with other people as "menial things" or "transactions".

> as far as CC details, we have fraud protection

In my country (in Eastern-Europe) CC fraud protection is a joke. Even if that weren't the case, I don't want a 3rd party to have access to my finances if I can avoid it.

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by haskellandchill on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:43PM (#17360529)
Honestly if things keep trending this way, I would. Assuming I have a choice which it seems I don’t. Luckily as the other commentator pointed out it is not an either or decision.
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by matte_black on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:55PM (#17360627)
Don't be so hyperbolic. Try to focus on all the good things this kind of technology can do. Kids skipping class, kids beating up other kids, even someone walking in with a weapon: these kinds of things can be detected and handled more efficiently and promptly with a system like this at scale.
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by DoreenMichele on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:58PM (#17360651)
Being able to ever more efficiently and effectively prove just how bad things are so punishment can be doled out after the fact isn't some means to foster a trusting, trustworthy and civilized environment.
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by matte_black on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:07PM (#17360714)
Trust, but always verify.
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by DoreenMichele on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:13PM (#17360749)
Policies along the lines of The beatings shall continue until morale improves have a very long track record of failure.
Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by matte_black on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:24PM (#17360807)
I know many of you in HN live in perfect idealistic communities, but let me tell you: I went to a shitty school with police coming by everyday and a poor graduation rate. I got the shit beaten out of me more times than I care to remember, for things like "not helping some kid cheat on a test". Nobody cared, and there was no way to prove it anyway. If I said anything it only meant I would get beat up outside of school.

I felt unsafe every damn day in high school, and it certainly wasn't because some facial recognition tech was watching my every move.

But whatever, keep trusting those kids to eventually behave. Personally, I just hope karma got them in the end.

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by DoreenMichele on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:30PM (#17360838)
I'm extremely sorry for your experience. Your assumption about my life is inaccurate.

I was homeless for nearly six years. I got off the street last September.

I currently live in a dirt cheap SRO. I have lived in high crime neighborhoods and was last in Fresno while homeless (where murder and arson were routinely in the news).

"Eyes on the street" is how you prevent such things. Human monitors who can serve as witnesses are a deterrent to crime in a way that cameras are not. Furthermore, adult supervision and the right policies can help troubled kids learn how more pro social behavior.

I'm talking about prevention, not sweeping it under the rug and ignoring it.

Re:Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools by throwawayjava on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @09:37PM (#17361366)
> Don't be so hyperbolic. Try to focus on all the good things this kind of technology can do.

Agree! Could you imagine having millions or billions of records of students learning the same set of concepts? Big data pedagogy, here we come!

> Kids skipping class, kids beating up other kids, even someone walking in with a weapon

Oh... Disagree :-(

Schools are places of learning, not prisons. Technology in schools should enable learning, not surveillance.