Also I think you may misunderstand who these people are. Take wonga.com for example, they're on ads on TV with their iPhone app. How many truly poor people have iPhones?? Their customers are people who need (want) cash for the weekend before payday to go drinking/clubbing/partying. It's a luxury (of sorts) and people always pay a premium for luxury.
I think "these people" are not a homogeneous group, so defining them as truly poor is tricky. I would argue though that it is still a social negative to lend to anyone who has an iPhone but doesn't have the money to go on a night out before pay-day. I can't think of a better example of socially-useless lending. I think that is bad for the state to allow that, but I can see not everyone would agree. There are however definitely much worse off people using such services, and they should be prevented from doing so [1].
The other issue thing I want to mention is that the state schooling system is woefully inadequate in the area of personal finance. Maybe it's the parent's job, but budgeting and managing your finances is too important a skill to be left to them, and schools waste plenty of time teaching "personal, social and health education" — it'd be easy to shove money management in there.
[1] With the possible proviso of a proper social emergency loan or payment system for people living below the poverty line with unexpected non-discretionary spending [2], e.g. car breakdown which prevents them getting to work.
[2] Don't even get me started on medical bills here. Pay-day loans are a third-level kludge on a totally broken system there.
How would you ensure your "social emergency loans" were ever repaid?
Taking credit with interest rate 2500% is rarely thought trough, free, conscientious market decision. If you don't have money this month how can you be sure that you will have such money, plus insane interest rate, next month?
I get a £400 authorised overdraft limit on which I only pay interest (at a pretty fair rate) and no annual fee and in the UK that's not a deal that's too hard to find (First Direct in my case but I'm sure similar deals are available through others). Seriously, there's no reason to put up with that sort of thing and if you can get an account with Barclays you're unlikely to be turned away by too many others.
I used to be with Barclays too but this sort of thing is one of the reasons that I'm not any more - that and their general air of not giving a <expletive deleted> about my custom.
400%? In the UK we've got companies charging over 2500% a year for payday loans.
While I accept these are high risk, there surely has to be a limit?