News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by parvenu74 on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @09:57AM (#17346623)
> "There are some 'BSD-inspired' networking improvements to Linux starting with the 4.16."

By "inspired by BSD" do the author mean the code has been copied and pasted from FreeBSD to Linux, something which cannot be done in reverse because of the encumbrance of the GPL?

Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by trasz on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @10:49AM (#17347180)
It can be done - kind of. Take a look at how the drm-next-kmod works in FreeBSD. It's a port of Linux GPU drivers using linuxkpi - a Linux kernel API compatibility layer, basically a huge set of wrappers to implement Linux kernel functions, eg printk(), using FreeBSD mechanisms (printf(9) in this case; https://svnweb.freebsd.org/base/head/sys/compat/linuxkpi/com... for the curious). Part of linuxkpi uses code transplanted from Linux, and that part does that that by living in the Ports Collection, like any other third party software.

Of course this prevents it from being committed to FreeBSD base. But from the user point of view it doesn't matter - it's just that you have both linuxkpi.ko and linuxkpi_gplv2.ko loaded automatically when you load i915kms.ko, which is the "real" driver, and there's no license compatibility problem.

Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by toast0 on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @01:45PM (#17348748)
Copy + pasting code between Linux and FreeBSD kernels isn't going to work (although see trasz's post about how code is reused for graphics drivers -- doing that for networking would probably not be good choice). There's a lot of differences in data structures, locking, etc. Copying concepts can be fruitful though.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by zeth___ on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @10:10AM (#17346749)
BSD is free to adopt the GPL at their leisure. Who knows, companies might then start contributing to the project instead of building OS's on top of it, looking at you osx.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by parvenu74 on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @10:16AM (#17346824)
GPL supporters are all about freedom -- until someone advocates for the freedom to make a proprietary product on top of the open source base.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by bonzini on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @11:13AM (#17347389)
More specifically it's about freedom for all users, transitively.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by ComputerGuru on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @12:24PM (#17348063)
Except for developers who wish to use GPL code without it virally requiring them to relicense everything under GPL, that freedom does not exist.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by bonzini on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @02:40PM (#17349223)
The key word is transitively. Those developers can do everything except depriving their users of freedoms originally granted by the copyright holder.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by belorn on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:19AM (#17353980)
GPL supporters are all about liberty, and like we all know, liberty does not give everyone freedom to do everything that they wish.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by cozzyd on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @10:37AM (#17347056)
Yes... that is the point.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by parvenu74 on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @11:15AM (#17347407)
Oh I forgot -- at HN you never question the GPL. And FreeBSD sux because it's not GPL. Got it. I'll stop wasting my time even mentioning it again.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by jhasse on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @12:04PM (#17347907)
You didn't question the GPL, you just explained how it works.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by x220 on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @08:39PM (#17351481)
It's about freedom for the users and developers.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by zeth___ on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @05:56PM (#17350599)
The freedom to enslave others is not a freedom that one protects. I believe there was a little thing called the civil war where that point was made.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by 2trill2spill on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @06:40PM (#17350860)
> The freedom to enslave others is not a freedom that one protects. I believe there was a little thing called the civil war where that point was made.

Allowing people to make proprietary code from BSD licensed code is not enslavement. Also if someone improperly used GPL licensed software to make proprietary software it would be breach of contract or copyright infringement not enslavement.

Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by belorn on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:23AM (#17354003)
Liberty involve many restrictive laws, with slavery being one of the biggest along with murder and assault. No one is suggesting that all laws must be only behavior worse than slavery or else the country does not believe in liberty.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by 2trill2spill on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @10:55AM (#17355968)
Thing is though that the BSD and GPL license have absolutely nothing to do with slavery. So I have no idea why you and the other poster keep bringing up slavery in the context of open source licensing.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by belorn on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @12:02PM (#17356608)
The reason is that some people use the word freedom and liberty as synonymous, while others put clear distinctions between them and argue that GPL do not fit their definition. Thus people who disagree have to take clear examples to explain why liberty laws restricts freedom in order to create liberty.

If you prefer to use philosophy terms, conditions are negative rights. Those are similar to things like "I have the right to not get assulted, I have to right to not get enslaved, I have the right to not get robbed, I have the right to not get murdered, I have the right to not get recorded in the shower, and so on. Negative rights is freedoms to not have things happen to you by restricting what other people may do. Positive rights is things like I have the right to health care, I have the right to be on public ground, I have the right to social security, or I have the right to ask the government in the Freedom of information act and so on. Positive rights usually but not always demand something from others. Most constitutional laws tend to be negative rights.

Combining negative and positive rights is how liberty is created. Its a balance between freedom to do things and restrictions to not do things to others, with the goal of maximizing free will and personal agency for society. GPL give freedom to do anything but with conditions that limit what you can do to other people. Just like with liberty the GPl tries to maximizing free will and personal agency and uses negative and positive rights to reach a balance.

One could ask why the free software movement picked freedom when they intended to say liberty, and the reason is historical and localized. RMS did not want to associate the movement with the libertarian political platform. Maybe they thought that most people don't really distinguish between freedom and liberty, but now days liberty is generally favored over freedom.

Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by 2trill2spill on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @01:21PM (#17357417)
What are you talking about? A previous poster said...

"The freedom to enslave others is not a freedom that one protects. I believe there was a little thing called the civil war where that point was made."

This was said in the context of the BSD and GPL licenses and GPL advocates not liking closed source software being made from BSD software even though its perfectly within the license to do so. This has nothing, and I repeat absolutely nothing to do with enslavement.

Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by belorn on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @05:53PM (#17360142)
"GPL supporters are all about liberty -- until someone advocates to make a restrictive product on top of the open source base."

"The liberty to restrict others is not a liberty. Laws [insert common law here] restrict behavior and it not against liberty to have such law."

Is that simple enough for you?

Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by zeth___ on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @12:02AM (#17352494)
It is. You allow your code to be used in the subjugation of others.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by 2trill2spill on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @08:07AM (#17354563)
Using code that I BSD license is not the subjugation of others.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by zeth___ on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @05:58PM (#17360190)
If you used it to create proprietary code it is.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by 2trill2spill on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:33PM (#17371090)
Using BSD licensed software to create proprietary code is not subjugation, in fact creating proprietary software from BSD code is perfectly within the license. If someone doesn't want their code used in proprietary work they would release it under a more restrictive license. Lastly you should probably look up the definition of subjugation before tossing it around liberally in conversation.
Re:FreeBSD has lower latency, and Linux has faster applicati... by riffraff on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @10:30AM (#17346986)
the OSX core/kernel (XNU+darwin) has actually been open source for a long time. The interesting bits of the userspace (cocoa, carbon or whatever) were not BSD derivative.