It’s only about sending your location when you specifically ask for help in an emergency situation.
—
That being said, mobile phones are inherently trackable by mobile carriers using triangulation. I know it’s obvious, but it’s worth considering that staying untrackable with a mobile is, as far as I understand, fundamentally impossible.
No, it's not. Go back and re-read the comment I was responding to. Pay particular attention to the following passages:
> Consider how much real-time location info — and live HD video streams — can 1 mobile phone produce, and how close to none of that is available in an emergency situation.
> Consider how 911 is but one service, and that this is a worldwide problem. And that smartphones are worldwide too, and that there’s hundreds of millions of them.
The GP is specifically talking about expanding the capability beyond just location and beyond just 911, and talking about this as if it were a foregone conclusion that this will be an unalloyed good. That is what scares me.
I apologize if my original comment was not clear, or could leave itself open to a different interpretation.
I really did mean that when someone in an emergency situation needs help, presently, they do not have the ability to send their location, a text message, an image or a video.
That’s it — I was only referring to emergency situations, and anything that I am discussing would be user-initiated.
Oh, sorry, I didn't see that. (This thread has grown a lot of tentacles.)
> I was only referring to emergency situations
That was very unclear. When you wrote:
> Consider how 911 is but one service
that sure sounded to me like you were advocating making this information available very broadly.
Right or wrong, I think you're in the extreme minority here.
Edit: I'm not necessarily speaking for myself here, but then I'm in a low-risk area and demographic, so am not especially likely to need 911. But I think the average "man on the street" would not give a second thought about it.
I don't think that's true as often as our pessimistic sides would assume:
People risk their lives for freedom, in fighting wars, in challenging oppressors, in trying to escape. To say it more dramatically: A few people once agreed to risk their lives, their fortunes, and their honor for liberty, not the other way around.
It's an emergency, you are calling an emergency line. That line should have priority access to information while you are calling for help.
Don't want any of that?... Well I guess don't call the emergency line... or whatever...
I'm reminded a bit of the sanctuary city debate. Sanctuary cities are doing their best to let anyone call for help without worrying about whether immigration will be the first responders.
Anyway, I think there's some excessive paranoia in this discussion, but there is nonetheless a kernel of a valid point.
Your argument is very similar to the argument advanced by the government for key escrow and other backdoors in encryption systems: this mechanism will only be used with proper legal safeguards to catch "bad guys". Don't you want that?
No, I don't. I really don't.
I don’t understand why you’d be ok with a cell phone as it stands today, but think that a cell phone which can send a bunch of data when you send 911 is completely unacceptable.
I can't.
> I don’t understand why you’d be ok with a cell phone as it stands today, but think that a cell phone which can send a bunch of data when you send 911 is completely unacceptable.
I didn't say that it's completely unacceptable. What I said was that talking about expanding this kind of data sharing is if there were a consensus that only good things could result scares me.
The reason I'm OK with my cell phone today is that the default assumption today is that my location is private, or at least under my control. There could be a back door, but that is a risk I'm willing to take.
What scares me is that we seem to be oozing slowly towards bringing up a whole generation who have never known privacy, and so have no idea what its value is.
Is that assumption accurate? Cell providers are already tracking your location and providing the data to resellers.
https://krebsonsecurity.com/2018/05/tracking-firm-locationsm...
Yes. That's why 1) the story you linked to describes how users are prompted for consent and 2) the leakage of this data is sufficiently scandalous to be newsworthy.
Yes, but in the past that's required a warrant. Has that changed?
If you're emitting any sort of signal, the government can track you. That ship sailed about 70 years ago.
I am, and it scares the hell out of me. If I have to choose between having emergency responders possibly not being able to locate me, and having the government be able to track my every move along with everyone else's, it's not even a hard choice: I'll take the former as by far the lesser of the two evils.
Being able to reliably hide my location is every bit as important to personal freedom as being able to encrypt my communications. If that means I have to take some additional steps to summon help in an emergency, so be it. It's a price I'll happily pay. Life's quality metric is a vector, and safety is not the only dimension.