News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube’s Piracy Filter Blocks MIT Courses, Blender Video... by tzs on Monday June 18, 2018 @03:30PM (#17340998)
Looking at the DMCA requirements, it doesn't appear like it would require a lot of human intervention.

1. Copyright owner provides written notification of the alleged infringement.

The notification has to provide reasonably sufficient information to allow Google to locate the alleged infringing material; provide contact information for the claimant; include a statement that the claimant has a good faith believe that the use is not authorized by the copyright owner, its agent, or the law; and a statement that the information the claim is accurate, and that the claimant is authorized to act for the owner.

2. Google then has to remove or disable the material, and take reasonable steps to notify the uploader of the issue.

If the uploader does not make a counter notification, it looks like that's the end of Google's obligations.

If the uploader files a counter notification, Google has to notify the claimant. If the claimant does not file a lawsuit against the uploader within 14 days, Google has to restore the material.

Note that nothing in here seems to require Google to actually look at the material and decide if they think it is infringing. Nor does it require them to proactively seek to find infringing material and notify content providers or block such material. They just have to check that the claimant (and the uploader if they get a counter notice) have included the things in their notice that the law requires. They should be able to automate that for most claims.

The ContentID system seems to be going far beyond what DMCA requires them to do to keep their safe harbor. I wonder why they are doing that? Maybe because they want to also be content sellers, and so want to keep the content providers happy with them?

Re:YouTube’s Piracy Filter Blocks MIT Courses, Blender Video... by mjevans on Monday June 18, 2018 @04:24PM (#17341407)
The problem is a lack of liability for the content creators. Confusion can happen (such as particular renditions of a work who's basis is public domain information (IE a classical music score)), but willful lies should be punished with actual consequences.

Right now things are stacked entirely against one class of content creators (video creators). Additionally if I'm a public institution or someone else that's against having ads I can't control what happens during the contest period* (or so I've heard, it's never happened to me).

As someone that has posted a few 'how to do X' in software videos before, who believes that ads should be far more limited (like the old soap operas / PBS sponsors at the end of programs), I'd rather my videos were in 'hold on publishing limbo' while not under my control.

Re:YouTube’s Piracy Filter Blocks MIT Courses, Blender Video... by seandougall on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @11:16PM (#17352292)
In the case of classical music, there are two things that need to be clarified:

1) Classical music is still being composed today, and there’s a huge volume of post-1927 work that is very much under copyright in the US (excessive though that may be IMO).

2) Even if a composition is PD, the recording is absolutely copyrightable if it’s post-1927, and the arrangement may be as well. This isn’t a matter of confusion; it’s an actual piece of intellectual property.

Not to say that any of this is right; I believe fair use protections need to go much, much farther than they do.

Re:YouTube’s Piracy Filter Blocks MIT Courses, Blender Video... by paulie_a on Monday June 18, 2018 @05:19PM (#17341788)
Will fill abuse of enforcement should invalidate the copyright entirety...it becomes public domain. Repeated violation revoke all copyrights under your control.
Re:YouTube’s Piracy Filter Blocks MIT Courses, Blender Video... by yason on Monday June 18, 2018 @04:41PM (#17341530)
The ContentID system seems to be going far beyond what DMCA requires

AFAIK the content id system was built to monetise works on YouTube. The system must know where a song or a video is being included to direct advertising money to the original author if s/he wishes to participate in that scheme.

Re:YouTube’s Piracy Filter Blocks MIT Courses, Blender Video... by sp332 on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @07:06AM (#17345488)
ContentID does go far beyond DMCA requirements. I think for a while, some big companies has carte blanche to delete any video. I guess narrowly winning a billion-dollar lawsuit against them will scare a company that way.