It only takes a little bit of reading between the lines to see the author bought a site that sold fraudulent gear, didn’t realise this for a bit and then shut it down.
If stripe hadn’t frozen payouts they would be stuck holding the bag for 44 percent of the total charges in the account.
The new account thing does sound beuracratic but I guess it restarts the KYC process.
OP is definitely in the 'fraudster' category, and deep into it! I am surprised Stripe didn't flag way sooner.
If you get put into a monitoring program, it gets real expensive, real fast. Though Stripe would probably rather just ban you.
I don’t think that’s the case. It looks like they bought a flipping or drop ship site and they botched the transition process; orders weren’t getting fulfilled and customers were rightfully pissed about it, hence the chargebacks.
Stripe has a lot of rough edges once you have to talk to a person due to outlier activity, but this could’ve been mitigated by isolating businesses into their own Stripe accounts, as well as better handling the business acquisition that took place.
Also keep in mind that for such a large number of users to go through the trouble of filing the chargebacks, it means that A) it's been long enough that they seriously believe your shop is fraudulent and you have no intention of shipping them what they paid for, and B) your communication and customer support is so terrible that they felt this was their only recourse.
Agree with the shipping delay points.
We really need to call out these types of scammers better. Nothing you can do to stop me selling my crap fake "Apple" charges on amazon (amazon should be doing a much better job screening), my "ecommerce store" that is experiencing "fraudulant transactions" == trying to scam users by not shipping anything, too I bought a container of "north face" gear from china and there is nothing you can do to stop me.
In all these cases, the seller had a reasonable ability to think - hey, this is probably a fraud and stop doing what they are doing.
Seriously, for reputation reasons North Face and many other brand retailers do not sell containers of product on "clearance" to rando third party retailers.. Some even destroy amazing amounts of product to avoid to entering into this scammy reseller chain.
Your post did not consider the high likelihood that a container of product on "clearance" from north face is counterfeit.
My point is simple. We have to have less tolerance of the willful ignorance by scammers. The brand should not need to pursue this.
Stipe / Atlas CAN and SHOULD shut down merchants who exhibit characteristics of fraud. Amazon should shut down the fake apple product sellers.
And yes, my job interects with fraud / ripoff detection, and I've worked with folks like you. My advice to folks in business and elsewhere, someone that willfully ignorant is not someone you want to do business with.
I think folks like you confuse something not having a law against it as something that prevents honest businesses from doing anything about the issue. That is misinformation.
I'll let this lie here because you seem both unwilling to consider the source of the container, but unwilling to consider this a useful or meaningful business standard.
> We calculate the dispute rate a number of ways, but the two most common are:
> 1. The percentage of charges on your account that have been disputed (you are currently 23.74%)
> 2. The percentage of volume on your account that has been disputed (you are currently 44.82%)
[0]: https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1600/0*8f0gZoASFf20_-lM.
Stripe could have handled it a lot better. They withheld payments from us (over 250k) No notifications, or anything else. They waited until we contacted their support on why our payouts weren't processing before they lectured us on how we should be doing fraud review (we do. We also pay way to much to SiftScience to mitigate that as well)
tl;dr though, Visa, Mastercard, Amex, Discover, etc... all have their own hard limits.
If you go above that, Visa reserves the option of "potential disqualification from the payment system" [2]. That is, you can be banned from accepting Visa cards ever again.
[1] https://www.braintreepayments.com/blog/changes-to-visa-charg...
[2] (see "Chargeback Compliance Program") https://www.citibank.com.sg/gcb/credit_cards/pdf/Fraud_Charg... [PDF]
Thank you faitswulff for preserving the text at least for posterity.
This entire blog post reads like other posts of its type from people who don't understand credit card processing or how it all works.
"Shortly after sending the above information we discovered that the specific charges flagged as fraudulent were not fraudulent charges. They were, in fact, due to chargebacks related to a recently acquired eCommerce store where fulfillment was lagging heavily during the transition which led to some dissatisfied customers who opted to dispute charges."
No, the transactions weren't fraudulent. However, selling something and not delivering is grounds for a chargeback and would be labeled as fraud, and to any reasonable person, would be considered fraud.
"Somehow we moved from an issue of fraudulent activity to whether or not we’re allowed to sell specific products."
Yes, because with such a high chargeback rate, they are going to reevaluate your entire business. It's called Know Your Customer (KYC), and it's critical.
But seriously, 6.5% chargeback rate. Even when I was still working in an industry know to be high risk, I never had a rate that high.
"Stripe is quick to put all blame and responsibility on us by claiming that it is not their responsibility to prevent fraud."
Because in the end, yes, that's where the fault lies. Don't believe me? Go to a bank and get your own merchant account and see what happens when you just let whatever you want go through your system. Just because it's on a computer doesn't change the fact that you are responsible for the fraud you are swiping through your system.
tl;dr: a legit 6.5% chargeback rate.