Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece
by Svip on Monday June 18, 2018 @06:44AM
(#17337145)
Greece's logic in disapproving of the name Macedonia is that they fear that Macedonia (the republic) could some day claim the Greek province of Macedonia. By that logic, so should Luxembourg (the grand duchy) be able to claim the Belgian province of the same name.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece
by seszett on Monday June 18, 2018 @06:50AM
(#17337179)
There's a difference though, in that the province of Luxembourg was indeed a part of Luxembourg (the country) not even 200 years ago. So it would be a much more legitimate claim.
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece
by Tharkun on Monday June 18, 2018 @08:03AM
(#17337569)
I don't think the rich Grand Duchy would be terribly interested in acquiring the empoverished Belgian province.
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece
by jcranmer on Monday June 18, 2018 @11:39AM
(#17339043)
A more appropriate parallel is the US state of California, which is named as it was once a part of a region named after Alta California, the name California first being applied to the then-thought-to-be-an-island peninsula in modern Mexico.
The country of Macedonia was part of a region generally called Macedonia for over a thousand years, as the initial named unit of Macedonia (which was in Greece) expanded to cover a wider area.
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece
by phobosdeimos on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:22PM
(#17339445)
Bad logic because Greece's borders are internationally recognized. Nobody legalised Russia annexing the Crimea. You cannot just claim territory unless you're a superpower.
Besides I think the people in Greece-Macedonia are happy being Greek.
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece
by fibbra on Monday June 18, 2018 @10:57AM
(#17338696)
That is not an official stance.
Macedonia is part of the Greek identity. FYROM (still the official name until the agreement gets implemented in a few months) have been claiming this Greek identity by misappropriating history.
Think of it as a trademark violation.