The only reason it makes me uneasy instead of keeping me up at night is because I can point to the rest of the industry and say it's standard practice if a problem happens.
All we have are some general heuristics here. "Trust" is too strong a word for the relationship we have with the people writing and manufacturing our software and hardware and for the chain of custody between them and us.
That's akin to installing randomly downloaded software from warezRus.com and running it as root.
All right, then say that. Say that you view Docker Hub like warezRus.com or a site that opens in Chrome like this https://www.google.com/search?q=chrome+red+warning&tbm=isch
Don't say that "unless the image was created by a trusted party (a party that you trust, not that someone else trusts) then there is no reason to assume that it friendly." That is going too far.
It's a continuum, but the "Okay, I'll run it" end of the continuum shouldn't be something you "trust". It should be something you're willing to run. Like everyone else, I'm typing this on a device that I shouldn't "trust". You should replace your idea of parties you should "trust" with parties you are willing to run something from. If Docker Images isn't one such party, then say that.
Assuming Docker Images has reasonable security and that someone who I trust would upload a (signed by them) docker image to Docker Images then you could download that image and use it if you trust the uploader and their signature.
How about instead of:
* you could download that image and use it if you trust the uploader and their signature.
(your phrasing), what if instead you wrote:
* you could download that image and use it if the developer seems technically competent and benevolent, or seems like they wouldn't be playing shenanigans, and you're sure that the developer is who they it is (their reputations aren't being coopted by someone else with a similar or fake name).
(perhaps what you mean). or:
* you could download that image and use it if it is put up by some huge development team with a big brand to protect.
(if that's what you mean).
Basically there must be some more precise way to say what you mean. I just don't think you're expressing the concept very precisely.