News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by lkrubner on Thursday June 14, 2018 @05:59AM (#17310541)
The thesis statement of this essay is buried fairly far into the essay, but it seems this paragraph is the heart of their argument:

"The lesson to be learned from quantitative easing, zero-interest rate policy, and the bubble advance of recent years is simple: one must accept that there is no limit at all to the myopic speculation and self-interested amnesia of Wall Street. Bubbles and crashes will repeat again and again, and nothing will be learned from them. However, that does not mean abandoning the information from valuations or market internals. It means refraining from a negative market outlook, even amid extreme valuations and reckless speculation, until dispersion and divergences emerge in market internals (signaling a shift in investor psychology from speculation to risk-aversion). A neutral outlook is fine if conditions are sufficiently overextended, but defer a negative market outlook until market internals deteriorate."

Basically, this can be read as a complaint about how distorted the financial markets become when we rely on the Fed to protect us from recessions. If Congress would do its job, and provide sufficiently large deficits to absorb the productive capacity of the modern economy, then there would be no need for the Fed to engage in such extreme behaviors, and we would not see this kind of distortion in the financial markets.

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by clarkmoody on Thursday June 14, 2018 @09:55AM (#17311673)
> provide sufficiently large deficits to absorb the productive capacity of the modern economy

Are you serious? How about letting the productive capacity of the economy work for consumers rather than for politicians?

Of course I agree that there should be no bailouts for Wall Street firms, but I would also argue that the business cycle itself is induced by the lack of a sound money in the economy. Easy money tricks entrepreneurs into investing in long-term capital projects prematurely and causes malinvestment.

So Wall Street is not to blame for business cycles. It's the soft-money fiat system that causes so much economic calamity. When the Fed steps in to stop recessions, nobody asks why we had the boom that preceded the bust, which was fueled by the Fed itself.

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by njarboe on Thursday June 14, 2018 @10:18AM (#17311833)
There was a time before the soft-money fiat system. Not really that long ago. It was also marked with many boom/bust cycles. The business cycle was probably first formally named and studied by Jean Charles Léonard de Sismondi and described in the 1819 book, "Nouveaux Principes d'économie politique"[1]. I would suggest that the cycle is not necessarily bad. During good times ideas are tried that would not be otherwise and people with little experience can get jobs and show their competence. Then some bad year forces some tightening and a serious evaluation of investments of all types.

The big downfall with recessions is that people with little or no savings can end up in a very bad place economically. Not sure how or if our consumer culture could change to a saving culture, but I'd be interested in reading a book that compares the two.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Business_cycle

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by haskellandchill on Thursday June 14, 2018 @11:42AM (#17312479)
Savings culture has beat me into submission, it only took a couple near death experiences from hitting zero in the bank account. So now what? My life is boring, fine. I accept I am a simple piece of human meat. Save for enough years and I suppose I can dream again.
Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by yuhong on Thursday June 14, 2018 @01:49PM (#17313657)
IMO it really became bad after US left the gold standard in 1971 and the petrodollar was invented.
Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by Latteland on Saturday June 16, 2018 @12:20AM (#17325813)
there seem to be serious problems with the gold standard because of what attracts people, that it is rigid and unchanging. If the us economy grows a lot, how do we get more gold? what if a ship with a lot of our gold on it goes down in the middle of the ocean?

What problems would it improve? if we have a recession, how would the govt help keep things going (ie print dollars)? Most people wouldn't have been better off if most large banks had failed then.

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by yuhong on Saturday June 16, 2018 @01:19AM (#17325983)
The point would be to not print more and more dollars to "boost" the economy and run more trade deficits, especially using debt. With the gold standard trade deficits would result in less money being printed.
Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by lkrubner on Thursday June 14, 2018 @10:33AM (#17311981)
"How about letting the productive capacity of the economy work for consumers rather than for politicians?"

Seriously, what are you talking about? If the government gives a large tax cut to every citizen, that citizen is also a consumer. When they take that tax cut money and they go spend it, then the large deficit is being put to work for consumers rather than for politicians.

Last time I checked, the Federal government was the consumer of about 1/3rd of the Federal budget. The rest of the budget is income transfers that are spent by someone else (for instance, Social Security, and also the money transfers to state and local governments, who then become the final consumers).

There are situations where it makes sense for the government to be the consumer of goods and services -- building bridges and ports and airports and such. Also, running the military. One can make the case that the USA would benefit from infrastructure spending right now. However, my original comment was completely neutral on the subject of who should spend the deficit. I only made the point that when productive capacity is going to waste due to lack of demand (in the context of this article, following a catastrophic shock to the financial system) then Congress should ensure a deficit sufficient to ensure the use of that productive capacity.

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by workinthehead on Thursday June 14, 2018 @05:11PM (#17315404)
If Wall Street is not to blame for "business cycles", why are you against bailouts?

There's no such thing as sound money, it's always being manipulated. This is by design.

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by DenisM on Thursday June 14, 2018 @11:54AM (#17312569)
If I may suggest, looking into “Keynesian economy” will make it clearer what the gp meant.

Both conservatives and progressives subscribe to this theory, so your time will not be wasted.

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by chapium on Thursday June 14, 2018 @09:12AM (#17311384)
“If congress would do its job...” is an interesting point. Congress have all sorts of incentives to consider “their” job is to stay elected by keeping special interests and local constituents happy. Perhaps we should have a few members of congress who are elected by the whole country and answer to the interests of the nation as a whole.
Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by lkrubner on Thursday June 14, 2018 @10:23AM (#17311874)
"a few members of congress who are elected by the whole country and answer to the interests of the nation as a whole"

I strongly agree. I would go further. The idea of a regional representative might have made sense in an era before the Internet, before the telephone, before the telegram and even before railroads could ensure fast delivery of written mail, but it does it make sense now? Why not have a legislature where every member is chosen based on a vote of the whole nation? Some parliamentary democracies do this, and their policies do seem more focused on national interests, as opposed to a bunch of local interests. Also evaporates the problem of gerrymandering.

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by zeveb on Thursday June 14, 2018 @10:49AM (#17312125)
> Why not have a legislature where every member is chosen based on a vote of the whole nation?

Because then whichever party currently has the support of the majority of the country would win every seat. Yes, you could do things like stagger elections, but overall I think it'd be worse: say each representative has a six-year term and there are six annual elections, you basically have six blocs in Congress instead of 435 members.

And of course the United States comprise a federal republic; most issues simply shouldn't be federal, and the vast majority are definitely not national. Who outside of Massachusetts cares if Massachusetts makes wearing a leek on St. David's Day compulsory or forbidden?

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by lkrubner on Thursday June 14, 2018 @10:55AM (#17312174)
"Because then whichever party currently has the support of the majority of the country would win every seat."

That is incorrect. Every democracy that I'm aware of, which uses national voting, also has proportional representation based on the vote. The rules vary from country to country, but generally speaking, if a party gets 10% of the vote, then it gets 10% of Parliament. If they get 43% of the vote, then they get 43% of Parliament.

About this:

"most issues simply shouldn't be federal"

This is a straightforward assertion of nostalgia, regarding an era that died out more than a century ago. Nowadays nearly all politics is either national or international. Small scale political divisions simply get in the way of efficient government.

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by mr_spothawk on Thursday June 14, 2018 @01:08PM (#17313208)
> Nowadays nearly all politics is either national or international.

I disagree. Just the politics you hear about. The rest of it is happening all around us, but your local paper went bust.

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by magissima on Thursday June 14, 2018 @01:18PM (#17313315)
Local papers going bust is a big part of why politics is so national now.

https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/all-politics-is-nationa...

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by njarboe on Friday June 15, 2018 @12:05AM (#17317483)
Americans historically don't want an efficient government fucking them over efficiently. What do you want to do so efficiently at a national level? National defense, I'd agree, but with nuclear weapons, the early American ideal of no standing army seems like something to go back to.
Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by mnx on Thursday June 14, 2018 @11:50AM (#17312538)
Which countries have a nationally elected parliament?
Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by lkrubner on Thursday June 14, 2018 @06:45PM (#17316068)
Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by mnx on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @06:32PM (#17412443)
Yeah, okay, but the candidates in those parliaments are still selected locally. It's just that the proportion is selected nationally.
Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by murph-almighty on Thursday June 14, 2018 @09:19AM (#17311441)
Different branch, but isn't that effectively the President/Vice-President? Especially when you consider the VP is the head of the Senate.
Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by ianai on Thursday June 14, 2018 @09:41AM (#17311583)
Now it is, but the president originally won votes from representatives of the states (IIRC).

I think the US needs the ability for recall elections. It also needs newer voting procedures.

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by throwawayjava on Thursday June 14, 2018 @09:49AM (#17311641)
The President is only indirectly elected by the country as a whole. Therefore, the president is highly incentivized to pander to a half-dozen or so states. And a few key voters within those states. It's exactly the same problem created by regionally-allocated representatives; the only difference is that the mechanism is just a little more opaque.

Because strong presidents drive policy-making, this difference ("a few key states" vs. "the country as a whole") definitely shows up in Congressional behavior.

A much simpler (and more plausible) solution to chapium's problem is simply getting rid of the electoral college.

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by sulam on Thursday June 14, 2018 @10:11AM (#17311778)
So instead of pandering to one small set of states you’d rather they pander to a different small set of states?

Perhaps the problem is federalism.

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by ttul on Thursday June 14, 2018 @10:12AM (#17311793)
Hear hear... A parliamentary democracy would probably be better, but that’s not going to happen.
Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by yock on Thursday June 14, 2018 @10:33AM (#17311976)
> A much simpler (and more plausible) solution to chapium's problem is simply getting rid of the electoral college.

Which would then require that a candidate only pander to an even smaller number of densely populated cities.

It would be far better to revoke much of the power of the central government rather than to try and debug our way through to a mythical process by which all individual interests are considered. Because, in the end, minority interests will always be cast aside once the election is over anyway.

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by throwawayjava on Thursday June 14, 2018 @11:11AM (#17312277)
> Which would then require that a candidate only pander to an even smaller number of densely populated cities.

NYC/LA/Chicago combined is only 15M people. That's clearly not enough people to win a majority of a 300M+ population. Perhaps you mean a wider class of cities. But 80% of Americans live in cities! If you can't get elected by "pandering" to a whopping 80% of your electorate then something is terribly wrong. We have to choose a very "just right" definition of "city" for your assertion to be true.

But there's an even more important misunderstanding here.

When discussing this topic, many people get distracted by the fact that removing the electoral college would increase the voting power of Massachusetts residents and decrease the voting power of Montana residents in presidential elections.

This is a distraction because neither Massachusetts nor Montana is the winner in the current system! It's states like Pennsylvania and Wisconsin that have a truly distortionary amount of power in the current system. Those states are not particularly rural or particularly urban.

Here's the key observation that could make changes to the electoral college politically feasible: if you don't live in a presidential swing state, getting rid of the electoral college increases the power of your region in selecting the president regardless of the size of your state/city.

So, this is not a case of favoring one small set of states over another small set. Removing the electoral college would substantially weaken the power of 5-6 states over the Executive branch and increase the power of the other 45 states (some more than others, sure, but nearly everyone wins compared to the status quo).

> Because, in the end, minority interests will always be cast aside once the election is over anyway.

This is exactly why I favor keeping Congress as it is but reforming the electoral process for the Executive branch. Montana has a very loud voice in the Senate and House relative to its population. I do not suggest changing that.

> It would be far better to...

1. An omniscient and beneficent dictator would be even better; the point of my post was to suggest plausible alternatives :-)

2. There are many merits to federalism, but this is quite a bag of worms and we're already straying OT.

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by logfromblammo on Thursday June 14, 2018 @10:46AM (#17312103)
When I think about history, and try to come up with initial conditions in government that could have brought the native tribes on board rather than deporting and destroying them, I thought that maybe people could make a voluntary declaration of their cultural identity during voter registration and again while voting. The House of Representatives would have a separate fixed pool of seats for cultural representation, but the cultural groups would not be guaranteed at least one seat, like the states; if your group doesn't have enough membership to meet the cutoff, you don't get seats that election. Every group with at least one Representative would get two seats in the Senate. Only those declaring for a culture could vote in the races for their seats.

You'd end up with the Senator from Southern Baptist arguing with the Senator from Postmodern Counterculture, or the Representative in Hispanic-American seat 5 hashing things out with the Representative from Secular Scientists. Mergers and schisms could cause the representation to track with changes in the population. Perhaps Iroquois Confederacy would have to merge with Algonquian Peoples and Five Civilized Tribes to stay politically relevant. Anglo Male Landowners might split into Urban-Industrial and Southern Whites.

It never could have happened, though. The only cultural group with representation back then was Anglo Male Landowners, and they were unlikely to share power voluntarily.

Anglo Male Landowners are still over-represented in US federal government.

I don't think an "at large" position would actually represent the whole country. It would give more power to the one of two political parties with support of the majority that election. You really need a mechanism to ensure minority positions can get more representation, such that any majority blocs have to seek consensus with at least one minority bloc to get anything done. The two-party system is washing out a lot of voices that never even get lip service from anybody, ever.

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by api on Thursday June 14, 2018 @09:14AM (#17311396)
> Bubbles and crashes will repeat again and again, and nothing will be learned from them.

This is a larger scale version of the same psychological factors that power Las Vegas. Go to a Vegas casino's slots section and you'll see people sitting for hours and hours and hours staring blankly into slot machines. They're kept there by those hits of dopamine they get when they occasionally win, and the slots are calibrated so as to time those wins so as to slowly empty their wallets over time.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operant_conditioning_chamber

Gamified social media, grinding-based MMORPGs, adversarial bullshit jobs, and many other things share similar characteristics.

Should we expect humans to behave differently on Wall St.?

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by atlasunshrugged on Thursday June 14, 2018 @01:36PM (#17313525)
I just want to make a point about the analogy (because it is a very commonly used one) given the additional and often overlooked aspects of what also powers casinos, namely social interaction. If you go to a casino today (almost anywhere but the few very touristy ones on the strip) you'll see a lot of folks who are just lonely and for whom gambling fills an emotional void. The dopamine hits from winning are nice, but the power of having someone who knows your name and your drink order and has a conversation with you shouldn't be overlooked as a motivating factor for why people are at those machines day after day hour after hour.

Source: Working as a bank teller near the Reno strip and having people of all walks of life come by day after day to get cash before going to the casino

edited last sentence for clarity

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by abecedarius on Thursday June 14, 2018 @12:37PM (#17312927)
What are "market internals"? I didn't see that defined in the article.
Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by cowpig on Thursday June 14, 2018 @09:07AM (#17311341)
> Basically, this can be read as a complaint about how distorted the financial markets become when we rely on the Fed to protect us from recessions.

I'm not sure how you get that from the quoted passage, nor from the article.

Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by parasubvert on Thursday June 14, 2018 @11:02AM (#17312230)
The author doesn’t seem to like fiscal deficits either, though, as they too can lead to asset bubbles.
Re:Hallmark of an Economic Ponzi Scheme by yuhong on Thursday June 14, 2018 @05:10PM (#17315391)
I don't like it either BTW. My favorite is how spending on the FBI/NSA is based on government debt.