Re:Billions spent on Ordinary Chemistry Was called Nanotechn...
by wmf on Sunday September 26, 2010 @05:23PM
(#1730019)
It's an interesting technique to claim that your opponent is worth rebutting but not worth linking to.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Billions spent on Ordinary Chemistry Was called Nanotechn...
by hga on Sunday September 26, 2010 @05:44PM
(#1730051)
It is indeed poor form but all you have to do is to follow the first link which will show you the one in question.
It's sufficiently vile and inaccurate (the guy's a small time Smalley who even ends his essay with a quote from that liar) that I can see why he refused to directly link to it. Plus since it's mostly a hand waving attempt to deny all of what Drexler has been saying, the author is not addressing the essay so much as pointing out why Drexler's proposition has never been tested (it's never been funded).
ADDED: On the other hand, I suppose all this is only fitting, given Drexler's belief back then that rational science policy was possible and his enthusiasm for mechanisms that would enable this. In the '70s and '80s there were clearly aspects of human nature he just couldn't wrap his head around.