News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by sien on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @05:24PM (#17298163)
Oh gawd. Please stop.

The Economist is doing it. 538 has done one. Everyone is doing it.

They all wind up with similar predictions.

Germany, Brazil, France and Spain are favourites.

This is what the betting odds, transfermarkt and the mean salaries of the teams also tell you.

There are limits to prediction. The WC is a good place for people to learn that.

Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by everdev on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @08:45PM (#17299350)
My biggest problem with these predictions is retroactive analysis of the prediction itself. If I have Brazil at a 99% chance to win the WC and they win, is my model the best?

I guess the idea is that over time, you measure prediction performance, but models are constantly changing and there's enough time in between WC tournaments that it'll take at least a century to have a good sample size of predictions.

If you take something more immediate like predicting tomorrow's stock prices or even the market (up/down), I wonder how their prediction models would fare.

Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by jamesrom on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @06:50PM (#17307682)
Yep, using many predictions you can calculate a 'brier score' which is a measure of your predictive performance.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brier_score

See also: https://predictionbook.com

Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by loggedinmyphone on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @08:06PM (#17299188)
People are so impressed now with predictive models based on any kind of correlation. Like: "we predict what kind of wine you will like based on your favorite candy bar" or "how long you'll live based on what you eat for breakfast". Only thing is, it's hard to find any two variables that aren't correlated, to some degree. Actuarial mathematicians have been doing this long enough to know how limited the "predictive power" really is.
Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by paulcole on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @07:03PM (#17298878)
> the mean salaries of the teams

This is new to me. Is the mean salary of a national team predictive? And are you using the mean salary the nation pays or their club salaries?

Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by avip on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @07:32PM (#17299017)
It's an established metric that uses club salaries. Is it predictive? The top 4 on that metric are Brazil, Germany, France, Spain.
Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by paulcole on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @10:15PM (#17299741)
Did I miss this year’s World Cup? How can something be predictive for an event that hasn’t happened?
Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by profunctor on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @06:33AM (#17301863)
Weather forecasts predict weather that hasn't happened yet. What is the point in predicting something that has happened?
Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by paulcole on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @09:56AM (#17303056)
I can say it’s going to rain 10 days from now based on whether it’s cloudy today. I wouldn’t say it’s a good prediction until it rains 10 days from now.

In other words: how effective has this salary prediction worked out in the past?

Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by everdev on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @09:14PM (#17299489)
There's a significant margin of error, but at a high level, the higher someone's salary, the better player you can expect them to be. There are some $10M players who aren't as good as $2M players, but a $30M player is likely considered far superior to a $2M player.
Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by paulcole on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @10:14PM (#17299736)
Yeah, I’m familiar with the concept of salaries.

My questions were: 1) is this an established metric that’s commonly used to predict football (soccer) results and 2) what salary are we talking about, the amount the nation plays to its team’s players (e.g. Brazil pays more than England) or the amount a nation’s players earn on their club teams (e.g. Neymar earns more at PSG than Rooney does for Everton)?

Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by lsiq on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @11:01PM (#17299911)
(1) At a high level, yes, they look at it. There is a very strong relation between winning and team pay in soccer. There is a reason why Real Madrid has won 4 out of the last 5 champions leagues. Similarly, PSG and Munich are by some distance the best paid teams in their leagues and win their respective leagues pretty much every year. This market today is quite efficient, sure there are always going to be some undervalued middling players here and there, but the very best players do not go unnoticed and so they are paid well and bought by the richest teams.

(2) the discussion is naturally about how much they earn for their clubs presently. National teams pay no salary and many top players do not, and in some cases, have never played in their birth country's own league.

Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by paulcole on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @11:32PM (#17300023)
Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by heyheyhey on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @07:26PM (#17298986)
Club salaries.
Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by vermontdevil on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @06:52PM (#17298807)
For all the hype with World Cup and I love the event, it’s pretty much these 4 (Italy if they qualified) that has won the event. Last time a country outside of the big four(five) is Argentina back in 86

Makes for a bit of a dull ending sometimes.

Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by sien on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @07:22PM (#17298964)
The winner for an individual WC is hard to pick and there are usually 4-5 big teams that could win but they have changed a little bit.

France hadn't won a WC and kept choking until 1998. Spain were the same until 2010.

Italy and Argentina have been in and out of the favourites as well.

England were #1 in Elo rankings in the late 1980s and got to the semis in 1990 and were only knocked out with the help of a handball in 1986.

With a bit of luck Holland might also have been able to win a WC. Finals in 74, 78 & 2010.

But outside a few big teams it is pretty unlikely that there will be a real surprise winner. There are too many big good teams so that one or two surprises isn't enough to win. For example South Korea shocked Italy in 2002 but then Germany beat them. Or Croatia beat Germany in 1998 but then got beaten.

Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by paulcole on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @07:06PM (#17298893)
It's pretty rare that the championship is the best game/series in a tournament/playoffs. Look at the history of Super Bowls, NCAA tournaments, NBA playoffs, etc.

More about the journey than the destination.

Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by loblollyboy on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @07:53PM (#17299118)
Argentina is also part of that top (6) - they’re the Liverpool of international football.
Re:Prediction of the FIFA World Cup 2018 – A random forest a... by OscarCunningham on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @08:00PM (#17299158)
According to Betfair, the probability of one of those teams winning is around 70%. So there's still 30% chance of an upset (most probably from Belgium).