1. network latency, in milliseconds, that affects stream quality and stability
2. the delay (lag) between real-time capture and what the end user is seeing; this one is usually measured in seconds. A stream needs to be ingested, transcoded, sent from distribution servers to edge servers in each target region - with each step adding to the delay.
Minimizing the lag is very hard, because stripping all buffers (to reduce the delay) makes the stream very sensitive to network conditions (which reduces quality). With most commercial CDN providers you will get 5..10 seconds. It can be reduced to 2..3 sec if you know what you're doing.
edit: in case anyone is interested - in the second scenario, where we achieved 2..3 sec broadcast lag vs real-time, stream source (ingestion) was in the US, and the viewers were in mainland China. Network latency was over 600 msec. Wasn't easy!
I know why there's a delay, I'm just amazed that people aren't concerned about it. The BBC used to offer multicast sources of live TV, which is a far more sensible solution, far more bandwidth efficient and allows end-to-end transmission in the satellite (or even less) range.
Wowza did a talk at demuxed last year about how to do "3 second latency end to end at scale", which I found amusing given that TV people have been doing sub millisecond latency at scale for nearly 100 years, so at least some people in the industry recognize the problem (which is mainly for sports events)
Twitch has recently implemented LHLS (looks like a "periscope-style" implementation) and I was seeing 1.2s glass-to-glass.
Maybe I just need to get away from the public streaming services which use HLS, switch to UDP streams and sub-1s buffer sizes.
https://help.twitch.tv/customer/en/portal/articles/2935005-l...
No matter what anybody says, the Internet just isn't well suited for massive live streaming events. That's what television is for!
It does amuse me when we were looking at latency for a program from a ropey bit of connectivity which we were using ARQ on. We were discussing whether we could push the latency up from 2 seconds to 6 seconds (it kept dropping out for 2 or 3 seconds at a time), as it's sport. Then we realised there was a good 30-40 seconds downstream before it even left to the CDN!
I still don't understand half of what Streampunk [1] are trying to do with their nmos grain workflows, but they are talking about sub-frame HTTP units
This is not an approach that supports line-synced timing and may not be appropriate for live sports action that requires extremely low latency.
However, for many current SDI workflows that can tolerate a small delay, this approach is sufficient.
With UHD you're talking 20MBytes for a single frame, or each "grain" (a subdivision of a frame) being in the order of a millisecond/megabyte.I think I prefer this approach to the SMPTE 2110 approach to be honest, especially with the timing windows that 2110 requires (it doesn't lead well to a COTS virtualised environment when your packets have to be emitted at a specific microsecond)
But I digress, this is all very off topic
[0] https://github.com/Streampunk/arachnid [1] https://www.streampunk.media/
There's a real opportunity for a sports-oriented OTT company to compete on latency, a DVR that actually works, and expansive rights (I never have to guess if I have access to any sporting event).
[0]: https://qz.com/150577/an-average-nfl-game-more-than-100-comm...
If you're watching a sports game, I can see that having a second stream (perhaps curated) with easy to access stats on that game, or a different angle to what the director thinks you want, or whatever.
I don't see the appeal of second stream in drama, but in things like sport, yes
It would be annoying if there were multiple devices nearby on different delays, but for me in my living room. I don't care if it's 30 seconds or 3 minutes. I've gotten spoiled by twitter feeds a few times, but it's not the end of the world.
In some cases international viewers may see the "live" footage before local ones.
How is this helpful in either of these cases? A sniper needs eyes on, a drone operator probably has live video from the drone. I don't see how a TV delay would have any effect.
We use the internet (and IP in general) to stream video. At high bitrates (200mbit+) we aim for sub 100ms end to end, for compressed services we're happy with 500ms, maybe upto a second if it's something like Sydney to London over the internet.
I was in a control room a couple of weeks ago watching some football. There were two displays, one end was the feed from the stadium, one was the feed from the web streaming service.
There were cheers and then groans from the live end of the room. nearly a minute later someone on the web end started running up the field to score. Of course I knew at that point that it wouldn't be a goal, as not only did the people watching the live stream tell me, but twitter was abuzz.
1 minute end to end delivery latency is shocking for this type of program. Heck 10 seconds is bad enough.