I should point out too that many investors want to see a team of employees, because they are investing in the strength of the personnel. So they didn't like this idea of a startup built using contract / outside talents.
BEGIN THEORY
Startups hire in-house devs because, basically, management does not know exactly:
A. what to build
B. what's possible to build
C. how the real world will react to the initial product/service offering and how the company will need to adjust
So, they bring devs in close, as high availability, high dedication employees, people who are in the center of the decision making. These intimately involved, trustworthy, motivated devs will then be more likely to come up with features and products that workaround management's deficits. And the company will benefit from that quickly and the company will own those features and products.
END THEORY
But, if this were contracted out to an outside stable of roaming rockstar developers, all highly talented but still less motivated and more in need of detailed direction from management -- how much insanely great startup flash-magic would really happen?
Also, consider that not only could someone be contracted to you in a high availability/all hours arrangement, but that this would potentially also allow YC companies to benefit from roles they couldn't afford to full-time.
For example (here in the UK) Founders Factory and Forward Partners both maintain large stables of designers, developers and other specialist executors that they assign to their portfolio companies.
I was paid when I was "on the beach"(bench), but I was expected to train and get tech certifications
I find time-clocking incredibly irritating, as I may be inspired to a solution or want to fix something outside of hours, which is pretty common for me. And similarly, I don't want to feel bad about if I am doing something wrong or not the most efficiently, but still charging full price for that time. Possibly the most irritating thing for me in times I was on hourly was arriving at work a few minutes too early to clock in and having to twiddle my thumbs, or having to determine whether or not something I wanted to remote in and do met the official terms for being paid in after hours time.
My personal feeling leans towards paying for "a job well done", and leaving it on the idea that if you're doing your job well, I'd like to believe nobody will question how you spent the hours you were doing it.
Being paid while on the bench makes a lot of sense if they feel you're valuable enough to retain, and time to actually spend training is pretty nice when you can fit it in, and obviously works to their benefit.
Then there is no problem with just billing the spent hours without any fudging one way or the other.
- A lot of people at the company would feel guilty and put in free hours to the client. (They would usually also get rewarded with excellent customer feedback.)
If the business works, I'm thinking the transition from the fund swat team to "real" employees might be difficult as well, probably at a time when you need to be firing on all cylinders.
The idea here would not be for YC to have a constantly growing outsourcing team, but to ensure they didn't lose the good employees because a startup failed. In a given failed startup, there are likely some rockstar employees that definitely weren't why it failed, and it's in YC's best interest, presumably, to hang onto those great employees and get them placed with other investments of theirs, should the opportunity arise.
Regular comp does that if the company can afford it. Startup equity is there so companies that can't, can offer early hires the "maybe money". Pay 200k and you'll get fully committed employees.
This is also similar to how a lot of small software development firms work; they develop web sites and mobile apps for companies on contract.
That obviously creates a risk of perverse incentives, but from the PE folks' perspective it seems to work.
IIRC that's also how Berkshire Hathaway does it: builds managers for Berkshire Hathaway companies, and whether they're managing at GEICO[0] or Fruit of the Loom[1] depends on where they're needed and not whom they work for.
I don't know anything about how technical employees benefit (or not) from that setup but I suspect there is some amount of informal sharing of tech talent across portfolios.
It'd be really great to see something like that for tech people. Maybe YC can start and everyone else will follow. :-)
So I don't think stability is much of an issue in the current economy, developers are not afraid to lose their job because they know they'll have dozen of opportunities just by activating their network.
Whereas a outsourcing company would benefit by providing as many staff members as possible, if YC or the like were to do it, they'd likely want to zero out the "profit" on supplying employees: To keep it affordable for a startup, and to not break the incentive for YC: To push companies to success via whatever resources they can offer.
Particularly if YC's "cut" was solely in the form of share of the business, they'd have no benefit to over-pushing poor quality labor on their own companies: It'd just doom them.
Here's a crazy idea from the IT contracting industry: Maybe YC and the like should hire employees and contract them out to startups. I work for a company which contracts me out to another: Even if my position is eliminated with the client, I don't lose my job, I just get reassigned. Perhaps as part of this, YC (or other funding group) gets the investment options an employee would otherwise have had, for example.
- For the startup, they'd be getting employees who weren't worried if they'd have a paycheck in the next six months, and they'd know their VC folks are confident in that employee's ability. For all the other risks startups take, hiring a good developer/designer/business manager would be less of one.
- For the employees, they'd have a stable income they could base real estate and financial decisions on.
- For the fund, they'd have possibly gained more investment, and ideally, having known employees that they've seen the work of before should add confidence to the success of a given business they've funded.
Disclaimer: I have literally no experience or expertise in claiming this would work out financially or otherwise for the startup industry.