Re:Research Finds Tipping Point for Large-Scale Social Change
by mc32 on Saturday June 09, 2018 @11:46AM
(#17273552)
I’d be curious to know how this would apply to group dynamics in company meetings. Often it’s very hard for an outside idea to be considered seriously.
Re:Research Finds Tipping Point for Large-Scale Social Change
by staticautomatic on Saturday June 09, 2018 @02:56PM
(#17274444)
I agree. To my eye it more closely resembles small group dynamics research, including the findings.
In this study, “Experimental Evidence for Tipping Points in Social Convention,” coauthored by Joshua Becker, Ph.D., Devon Brackbill, Ph.D., and Andrea Baronchelli, Ph.D., 10 groups of 20 participants each were given a financial incentive to agree on a linguistic norm. Once a norm had been established, a group of confederates — a coalition of activists that varied in size — then pushed for a change to the norm.
When a minority group pushing change was below 25% of the total group, its efforts failed. But when the committed minority reached 25%, there was an abrupt change in the group dynamic, and very quickly the majority of the population adopted the new norm. In one trial, a single person accounted for the difference between success and failure.
Though I'm quite curious why they call this a study in "large scale social change" and not just peer pressure? I have no idea how to possibly design an experiment for "large scale social change" but if I was going to create an experiment for peer pressure this seems to be just about exactly what I would do. Though even there it might be a bit sketchy. Mercenaries don't tend to be particularly loyal to the country they're fighting for, and 'providing a financial incentive to agree on a linguistic norm' is creating linguistic mercenaries.
Another issue that I hope they are being forthright about is "majority." If 25% of the population is made up of confederates are they describing a majority as 50% of the total (confederate + subjects) population? If that's the case then it undermines its own conclusion as it only means that 1/3rd of the subjects actually changed their view. This is something that should be obvious, but just the phrasing makes me wonder and the study itself is paywalled so I can't check.