Re:First complaints under the GDPR lodged within hours
by alfredallan1 on Saturday June 09, 2018 @09:39AM
(#17272957)
If the service I offer is “communication tools with in built personal ads”, or “latest news reports with personal ads on the side” it is not possible to offer those services without access to personal info.
Re:First complaints under the GDPR lodged within hours
by Tomte on Saturday June 09, 2018 @09:41AM
(#17272966)
And if the service you offer is „communication tool with the ability to sell weapons online“, then the authorities are out of luck, because you have cleverly phrased your mission statement?
That‘s not how it works.
Re:First complaints under the GDPR lodged within hours
by alfredallan1 on Saturday June 09, 2018 @01:34PM
(#17274016)
Oh no. The trouble with “chat app with weapons sales feature” is that it is illegal to buy or sell weapons (online or offline) without specific licenses.
Now If I made a “communication tool” exclusively for registered gun dealers and people with valid (and verified) hunting licenses, it would in fact be perfectly legal. Similarly, if the tool were for use by government agencies and defense contractors or registered weapons manufacturers, it would also be legit.
In the context of “chat tool with personalized ads on the side” - there is nothing specifically illegal about “personalized ads”. Is there? (As long as there is user consent of course). So what’s the specific legal hurdle? Which paragraph of the GDPR prevents this?
But if you can argue with legitimate interest (which is more burdensome), the person cannot decline and still use the service.
Choose: either easy basis and accepting that you might not get your way, or difficult basis and getting your way.