Re:Hacker News Highlights: April and May 2018
by samcampbell on Friday June 08, 2018 @02:39PM
(#17268472)
Love it. IMHO comments are the best part of HN. I always read the top few comments before clicking the linked URL.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Hacker News Highlights: April and May 2018
by hereathomie on Friday June 08, 2018 @03:26PM
(#17268891)
Many times I'll just read the comments and not bother reading the linked article at all.
Re:Hacker News Highlights: April and May 2018
by LeoPanthera on Friday June 08, 2018 @09:11PM
(#17270950)
I think most people do this. It's often striking how many people ask questions that are answered in the linked article.
The Tesla story currently on the front page is a great example of this.
Re:Hacker News Highlights: April and May 2018
by klez on Saturday June 09, 2018 @03:54AM
(#17272017)
Sometimes I do read the comments without reading the op, but then I won't comment, unless it's something unrelated (like this very comment, for example, even thought in this case I did read the OP).
But yes, there's plenty of "Didn't read the article, but...".
Re:Hacker News Highlights: April and May 2018
by asafira on Friday June 08, 2018 @11:56PM
(#17271462)
I always feel somewhat bad when I do this, but it really is much easier to read the first few comments. For really long articles, I often only read the beginning, catch something I want to comment on, and hope I didn't need the rest for my comment to be valuable.
It's not great, and honestly feels a little like in high school when you didn't actually do the full reading assignment for english class, but it can be hard to keep yourself to high standards.
Re:Hacker News Highlights: April and May 2018
by Bromskloss on Saturday June 09, 2018 @06:17AM
(#17272326)
The articles are almost never as short and to the point as they could have been. The article authors are at fault.
Re:Hacker News Highlights: April and May 2018
by overcast on Saturday June 09, 2018 @12:04AM
(#17271476)
I like to think of it as delegating :)
Re:Hacker News Highlights: April and May 2018
by simonebrunozzi on Friday June 08, 2018 @03:15PM
(#17268779)
I do the same! An TL;DR at the beginning of the thread would be super useful though. Especially when it's a WSJ article behind a paywall.
Re:Hacker News Highlights: April and May 2018
by samcampbell on Friday June 08, 2018 @04:00PM
(#17269191)
Agreed. I'm sure someone is working on this and can be easily applied to HN (maybe https://www.agolo.com/)
Re:Hacker News Highlights: April and May 2018
by nickpsecurity on Friday June 08, 2018 @06:29PM
(#17270255)
It's something we do on Lobste.rs. Its guidelines allow a short, purely-factual description just to save people time. On CompSci papers, I always put the abstract in there either whole or trimmed. Some people TL;DR the articles in their comments which happens here, too.
Allowing a super-short summary might be a good practice here, too. Especially for long articles or videos. On videos, maybe link to transcript or slides, too, so people don't have to dig them up. It's another thing I try to do over there.