News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by raldi on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:24PM (#17258011)
> The paint on the right edge of the gore marking, as seen in Google Maps, is worn

Indeed; here's a close-up of the critical area. Note that the darker stripe on the bottom of the photo is NOT the crucial one; the one that the car was supposed to follow is the much more faded one above that that you can barely see:

https://www.google.com/maps/@37.410912,-122.0757037,3a,75y,2...

(Note that I'm not blaming the faded paint; it's a totally normal situation on freeways that it's entirely the job of the self-driving car to handle correctly. But I think it was what triggered this fatal flaw.)

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by zo1 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:36PM (#17258153)
Wow. The start of that concrete lane-divider looks incredibly dangerous for a highway. It pretty-much just "starts", with only some sort of object that they call a "crash attenuator" in front of it. I would imagine its purpose is to dampen/dissipate kinetic energy and maybe deflect oncoming objects from hitting the concrete slab directly.

I don't even see any sort of road-bumps to warn drivers of this dangerous obstacle approaching.

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by panopticon on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:51PM (#17258328)
Out of curiosity, are you not in the U.S.? These types of lane dividers are incredibly common throughout the country.

Note that I'm not defending the safety of them; I'm just surprised to see someone call them out as a hazard as they're such a common sight.

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by crote on Thursday June 07, 2018 @02:07PM (#17258498)
Dutch citizen here, I have never seen something like this.

To compare, here's a similar situation in The Netherlands:

https://www.google.nl/maps/@52.0928662,5.1734685,3a,75y,281....

Points of interest:

- big solid white arrow, line-fade is nearly impossible

- white-green sign indicating that the road is splitting

- big shoulder in the continuation of the division

- loads of grass instead of immediately using a metal barrier

- gently rising metal barrier, so driving straight into it will result in something like this: http://cdn.brandweersassenheim.nl/large/269dezilkvangrail104...

Same goal, but a completely different approach.

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by hexane360 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @04:31PM (#17259969)
This is pretty apples-to-oranges. You see things like this in a lot of less dense U.S. areas as well. But in the crash example, it's right in the middle of an interchange, with the lane needing to form and rise quickly. Additionally, the gently rising metal barriers aren't safe in many situations because of their ability to launch cars. That's why they've been replaced by crash attenuators and sand/water barrels. Unfortunately the crash attenuator wasn't replaced after a recent (<1 week ago) accident, ensuring the next accident was fatal.

Here's an accurate U.S. analogue to your example: https://www.google.com/maps/@41.0286482,-102.1517159,3a,75y,...

Meanwhile, here's a Dutch example: https://www.google.com/maps/@51.9305956,4.4371182,3a,75y,66....

Turns out sometimes you need crash attenuators because space isn't infinite. Also, there's no grass in sight here.

Here's another example: https://www.google.com/maps/@51.9239112,4.4203482,3a,67.8y,2...

No sloping barriers, because they're not always safer.

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by crote on Thursday June 07, 2018 @07:39PM (#17261337)
Well, yes and no.

First, your counter-example is, ironically, pretty apples-to-oranges, as it is literally in the middle of nowhere. Meanwhile, the municipality where my interchange is located has a population density 1.5x that of Mountain View.

About the A20: it was built around 1970, inspired by American designs. Something like this would probably not be built today. Meanwhile, the specific ramp where the accident occurred, was constructed around 2006.

I do agree that safety measures should be adjusted according to their location, there is indeed no one-size-fits-all solution here.

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by hexane360 on Saturday June 09, 2018 @04:50PM (#17274915)
You're right that my first example is in the middle of nowhere, but there's a good reason for that. American and Dutch city designs differ so much to make them incomparable. Even NYC has 0.63 vehicles per household (http://www.governing.com/gov-data/car-ownership-numbers-of-v...), and San Jose (the closest to Mountain View I could find) has 2.12. There's a lot more traffic to deal with, and a lot more sprawl, meaning less space for interchanges and long ramps.
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by Kiro on Friday June 08, 2018 @02:22AM (#17263051)
Why are roads in the US so post-apocalyptic? Even your good example here looks horrible.
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by workinthehead on Friday June 08, 2018 @08:06AM (#17264485)
Hmm, perhaps something to do with there being more road miles in the US than in all of Europe combined?
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by koyote on Friday June 08, 2018 @09:22AM (#17265001)
The European road network is actually slightly larger than the US one (~6.5 million km vs ~7 million km).
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by hexane360 on Saturday June 09, 2018 @04:44PM (#17274878)
Which makes the point just fine, when you compare the U.S's 326 million to the EU's 508 million.
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by workinthehead on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @10:56AM (#17293806)
Well, 741 million, I don't believe the road network figures were restricted to EU members only.
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by lsaferite on Thursday June 07, 2018 @11:27PM (#17262361)
Here's an example of a crash attenuator right near your example: https://www.google.nl/maps/@52.0928978,5.1609792,3a,60y,305....

Edit: Also, that gore is freshly painted. Here's the same gore with faded paint. Mind you, it wasn't as bad, but even there you get faded painting: https://www.google.nl/maps/@52.0928706,5.1608083,3a,75y,109....

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by Symbiote on Thursday June 07, 2018 @04:09PM (#17259745)
I've tried to find something similar in an urban area in Britain, here's one in Birmingham: https://www.google.nl/maps/@52.4901761,-1.889549,3a,69.6y,5....

That fence wouldn't be fun to drive into at full speed, and the lane markings are worn, but it's still far less awful than a concrete wall.

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by mcguire on Thursday June 07, 2018 @09:54PM (#17261948)
At highway speeds, if that "fence" is strong enough to prevent vehicles from falling from the raised left lane into the lower right lanes, then it would seem likely to cut a car in two. I think I'd prefer the crash attenuator.
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by sveiss on Thursday June 07, 2018 @11:35PM (#17262386)
That segment of the A38 has a 30MPH limit, with the right fork increasing to 50MPH. The dynamics of any crash would be very difficult.
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by dsfyu404ed on Thursday June 07, 2018 @02:55PM (#17258977)
The intersection in the Tesla crash is pretty sub par by US standards. Most highway off ramps are as you described. In space restricted areas we tend to use tons of reflectors then water/sand barrels or metal crumple barriers instead of gently rising barriers and a grass infield.

In basically all cases where there's a lot of pavement that isn't a lane there's diagonal lines of some sort that make it very clear that there isn't a lane there. A good chunk of the time there's a rumble strip of some sort.

In rural areas there's less signage, reflectors and barriers but the infield is usually grass, dirt or swampy depending on local climate.

Edit: and I'm wrong because why?

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by Piskvorrr on Thursday June 07, 2018 @06:39PM (#17260986)
I wouldn't think wrong, but it seems to imply "AVs need great roads or bad roads, on mediocre roads they might kill you for no obvious reason, gee, too bad."

Such "pretends to work but actually doesn't", IMNSHO, would be far worse than "doesn't work there at all"

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by panopticon on Thursday June 07, 2018 @04:18PM (#17259843)
Granted my experience is my own and shaped by the areas I've lived in, but I'd say the crash barrier is pretty standard by US standards.

A few reflectors, a crumple barrier or some barrels and you've got a highway divider start! Certainly not as lengthy or as well marked as the Dutch example. This one I used to drive by in KC almost daily looks similar to the Tesla accident one (granted, this example does have some friendly arrows in the gore): https://www.google.com/maps/@39.0387093,-94.6774548,3a,75y,1...

I have also seen so many people crash into this one that they put up yellow hazard lights: https://www.google.com/maps/@39.0790636,-94.594365,3a,75y,17...

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by mcguire on Thursday June 07, 2018 @09:42PM (#17261900)
That's an interesting (and amusing) picture, but I'd expect many more incidents of a "gently rising metal barrier" causing a vehicle to roll over.
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by zaarn on Friday June 08, 2018 @04:12AM (#17263535)
The metal barriers are usually quite safe and designed to absorb a lot of energy. (Plus rolling over is safer than crashing into concrete)
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by metafunctor on Friday June 08, 2018 @03:27AM (#17263335)
I'm in the EU. This road does look a little bit hazardous to me; like it was designed 60 years ago and never updated.

- The area one is not supposed to drive in doesn't appear to be marked. Where I live, it would be painted with yellow diagonal stripes.

- On a high-speed road, there would be grooves on the road to generate noise if you are driving too close to the edge of the lane.

- Paint on the road is rarely the only signal to the driver (because of snow or other conditions that may obscure road markings). There would be ample overhead signs.

- Unusual obstacles would always be clearly visible: painted with reflective paint or using actual warning lights.

- We rarely use concrete lane dividers here. Usually these areas consist of open space and a shallow ditch, so you don't necessarily crash hard if you end up driving in there. There's usually grass, bushes, etc. There are occasional lane dividers, of course, when there's no space to put in an open area. However, the dividers are made of metal and they are not hard obstacles and fold or turn your vehicle away if you hit them (and people rarely do because of the above).

I'm sure there are some dangerous roads here, too, but a fatal concrete obstacle like this, with highway speeds, with almost no warning signs whatsoever, is almost unheard of.

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday June 07, 2018 @03:46PM (#17259542)
Excessively long, unstriped gores are not at all common in the Eastern US. This is bad engineering and poor maintenance.
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by slededit on Thursday June 07, 2018 @04:11PM (#17259774)
If anything the US tends towards far too little merge space than excessive. Almost every city has a blind yield entering the freeway somewhere.
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday June 07, 2018 @04:32PM (#17259978)
This is a problem with old highways that were upgraded to substandard interstates. That isn't the case here with plenty of room to build a safer design.
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by zo1 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @08:32PM (#17261594)
I live in South Africa. We see items such as this more commonly:

https://www.google.com/maps/@-25.833477,28.2391574,3a,75y,75...

https://www.google.com/maps/@-25.8317095,28.2407035,3a,75y,7...

However, it's not consistent. Some end quite abruptly as well, and have a plain sign in the middle without any slowly-rising divider.

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by vilhelm_s on Thursday June 07, 2018 @10:29PM (#17262098)
I had never heard of crash attenuators before, but they seem really impressive! This one was the "SCI smart cushion" model. According to the manual[1] it can reduce the acceleration from a collision at 100 km/h (63 mph) to less than 10G, so even a direct frontal collision at highway speed would be survivable[1]. That's pretty amazing.

[0] http://4fhmzg4ct6wezwll3wmp9kl9.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com/wp-c... [1] http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.212...

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by dhruvrrp on Thursday June 07, 2018 @10:59PM (#17262247)
The crash attenuators are usually good enough to save people's lives. There are small grooves in the sides on some of the freeways in CA but they aren’t everywhere.

The problem with the attenuators are that they don’t get replaced fast enough which makes these accidents a lot deadlier.

You can see the difference between a used and unised attenuator in this article. http://abc7news.com/automotive/tesla-claims-missing-safety-b...

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by wjamesg on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:44PM (#17258244)
Agree. The area leading up to the barrier could at least be striped off.
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by caf on Thursday June 07, 2018 @08:15PM (#17261511)
Yes, I'd expect to see something like https://goo.gl/maps/dbp2fx79ihz

I could easily imagine a stressed human driver unfamiliar with the area following that unstriped gore area as a 'lane', too.

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by prawn on Thursday June 07, 2018 @08:33PM (#17261600)
And you'd think that basic paint striping would be comparably cheap. It's incredible that such a deadly point wouldn't have it.
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by metafunctor on Friday June 08, 2018 @03:00AM (#17263226)
Are these kinds of lane-dividers not painted with heavy yellow diagonal stripes in the US? Is the divider equipped with reflective material and/or lights to make sure drivers notice it? Is the divider actually necessary, or could it be replaced with gravel so people don't need to hit a concrete wall when they make a mistake?

I don't think a road like this would be possible in most of the EU. Autopilot needs to be fixed, but this road is also super dangerous and probably would not be allowed in the EU.

How often do non-autopilot cars fatally crash here? This does look like a bit of death trap to me!

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by jacquesm on Friday June 08, 2018 @03:44AM (#17263425)
> I don't think a road like this would be possible in most of the EU.

I've driven in almost all countries in the union and I'm sure that and worse is readily available in multiple EU countries. While it's true that the EU subsidizes a lot of road construction local conditions (materials quality, theft, sloppy contractors) have a huge impact on road and markings quality.

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by metafunctor on Friday June 08, 2018 @04:36AM (#17263624)
Hmm, "possible" was probably too strong of a word. Of course it's possible.

However, I've driven a significant number of hours in Spain, Switzerland, Germany, UK, Ireland, Sweden, Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Finland, Estonia, and I wouldn't say that this kind of concrete divider is "readily available" as a normal part of a high-speed road, lacking the high-visibility markings I outlined in the post above, year after year as a normal fixture. In fact, I don't remember ever once seeing a concrete divider like this in the EU, even temporarily, but please prove me wrong (and maybe we can tell them to fix it!).

At highway speeds, lane dividers are only used when there is a lane traveling in the opposing direction right next to you. There is no point in concrete dividers if all the traffic is traveling in the same direction. At highway speeds, opposing lanes should be divided by a lot of open space and metal fences that don't kill you when you hit them.

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by jacquesm on Friday June 08, 2018 @07:45AM (#17264389)
Try: Poland, Romania, Hungary, Bulgaria, Greece, Slovenia, Slowakia, Czech Republic. Those are also part of the EU and road quality there varies wildly from the countries you use as your examples.
Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by btilly on Friday June 08, 2018 @12:11PM (#17266843)
How often do non-autopilot cars fatally crash here? This does look like a bit of death trap to me!

A non-autopilot car crashed at this exact spot a week earlier. This crumpled a barrier that is intended to cushion cars going off the road here, and contributed to the death of the Tesla driver.

The fact that a human crashed at this exact spot confirms that it really is an unsafe death trap.

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by alejohausner on Friday June 08, 2018 @12:38PM (#17267142)
I have noticed that, on two-lane non-divided roads, the dividing line (separating you from oncoming traffic) is yellow, while the right-side solid line is white. White means it's safe to cross the line, but yellow means it's dangerous to cross it.

You can see that yellow line at the accident site.

Now, why didn't they start a new yellow line where the lane split? That would give drivers (and software) an important cue: if you are driving down a "lane" with a yellow line on the right, something is seriously wrong!

Re:NTSB: Autopilot steered Tesla car toward traffic barrier ... by raldi on Friday June 08, 2018 @01:41PM (#17267858)
In the United States, "A yellow line (solid or dashed) indicates that crossing the line will place a driver in a lane where opposing traffic is coming at the driver."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yellow_line_(road_marking)#Uni...