Re:Can we talk about GitHub's recent censorship instead of f...
by aarongray on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:32PM
(#17258101)
Hey Daniel, thanks for chiming in, and for unflagging this.
I can't speak for anyone other than myself, but my desire in sharing these stories was to start a respectful conversation based upon open dialogue - to help this community - not tear it apart. I also don't want to start a flamewar or delve into conspiracy theories.
Its too bad that these posts have been buried now due to how the algorithm works, but I appreciate you taking the time to talk about it and to unflag it.
So anyway, just wanted to say thanks.
When people post things that HN users consider off topic or against the site guidelines (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html), users flag the posts. You can call this censorship if you like—one person's flagging is another's censorship, depending on how they feel about the topic—but HN has had this flagging system for many years and it's a core part of how the community functions.
The flags are not coming from some sort of Microsoft or Github brigade. How do I know that? First because stories like this, where some users are trying to drum up drama but most who look at the issue don't agree with them, always get flagged. And second because I checked the accounts of the flaggers and they are longstanding community members with no history of activity around this issue.
If the community felt you had a case that this was a MS/GH censorship scandal, the story would be all over the HN front page and there would be nothing that flaggers or moderators could do about it. Your problem is not that there's a gang of flaggers censoring you. You just don't have the community on your side.
(Also, no moderators touched any of these stories, except to unkill them so they could re-open for comments.)