Ironically enough, our renewable electrification process is like a turbo coming up to speed. There is simply so much energy hitting the Earth from the Sun (if I recall off hand, about an hour of sunlight can power humanity for a year, or thereabouts) that if we continue to rapidly deploy solar and wind, we'll have orders of magnitude more energy than humanity currently requires for a first world lifestyle while also having enough energy to sequestor all of the original carbon burned through fossil fuel based industrialization.
"A long way around the block" if you will.
https://www.iea.org/publications/renewables2017/
https://www.energy.gov/eere/articles/4-charts-show-renewable...
- Nwabudike Morgan
I myself am working on transitioning out of security engineering into renewable energy/utility storage deployment.
It goes without saying, if you’re in the industry and hiring, I’m interested! (Wink wink nudge nudge Tesla Puerto Rico)
Solar panels take huge amounts of energy to produce, which may not be recovered in the life of the panel.
Its only sustainable if it's possible to have a solar panel factory powered by solar panels... Which seems unlikely
> Also, did you just use technical debt as a metaphor for regular old debt?
Hahahaha, good catch. I just might have.
Energy wise this process might still be favorable to producing biofuels from plants or algae, so I hope they're successful.
If sequestering CO2, combining it with CaO to make CaCO3 (calcium carbonate) makes more sense, and is even exothermic. It's also biologically harmless and can be safely dumped, used in building materials, etc.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_sequestration#Mineral_c... (last paragraph of section)
So I would guess the reason for producing synthetic CaO from CaCO3 is that extracting natural CaO is uneconomical.
Why would you be putting energy into the ground? If you're producing hydrocarbons, those will presumably be burned or used for something else (e.g. plastics).
Quoting from the paper:
> An industrial process for large-scale capture of atmospheric CO2 (DAC) serves two roles. First, as a source of CO2 for making carbon-neutral hydrocarbon fuels, enabling carbon-free energy to be converted into high-energy-density fuels. Solar fuels, for example, may be produced at high-insolation low-cost locations from DAC-CO2 and electrolytic hydrogen using gas-to-liquids technology enabling decarbonization of difficult-to-electrify sectors such as aviation. And second, DAC with CO2 sequestration allows carbon removal.
So, to summarize their first role, they would produce hydrogen from water, combine it with CO2 extracted from the atmosphere, and then burn it. Thus no net carbon added to the atmosphere.
Essentially, instead of moving carbon from fossil fuels to the atmosphere, you would borrow carbon from the atmosphere, turn it into fuels, burn it, and return it to where you borrowed it from.
In that case, it's like you're using hydrocarbons as a storage and transport mechanism for renewables. Also lets you have nearly net-zero carbon emissions from the billions of hydrocarbon-burning engines in the world.
Carbon sequestration is a real thing, we just lack either economic or political will to prioritize it.
That sounds like a problem into you translate it into "leave rice straw on the fields".
95% of hydrogen is produced by splitting hydrocarbons, not by splitting water. Clearly, the assumption is the hydrogen comes from some miracle carbon-neutral source...but it doesn’t.
The hydrogen production, FT reactors, post-treating refinery will cost a lot more.
If you want hydrogen from water, you need electricity. A lot of it. Nuclear reactors will be the most viable way to do that.
[1] https://www.cell.com/joule/fulltext/S2542-4351(18)30225-3
But my big question is why would you want to convert it into hydrocarbons for transport then? Direct air capture (DAC) is a maybe-way-out-in-the-2050s technology, but even assuming it were readily and cheaply available in large scale today, doing DAC straight to storage and then just using oil and gas like we've always done would be a much cheaper and more efficient method than going what you propose. Basically:
air->CO2->storage AND (CH3)n->burn
versus
air->CO2[a] AND (CH3)n->CO2[b] + H2[b] AND CO2[a] + H2[b] -> (CH3)n->burn AND CO2[b]->storage
(Obviously not taken to be real well-defined balanced chemical reactions).
This article is about using carbon dioxide to produce usable fuel, that you would burn. Scaled up it would provide a carbon-neutral solution to long-term energy storage.
That really makes this whole process a way of converting energy stored in hydrogen to energy stored in hydrocarbons. This is pretty desirable - hydrocarbon fuels are much easier to work with, fit in with our existing transport - but not really a new source of energy.
The problem with sequestering CO2 as hydrocarbons is that you need to put a whole load of energy (embodied in the hydrogen you're combining it with) into the ground and leave it there. Fortunately renewables (especially solar) are heading in the right direction. On a sunny day in an area with lots of solar panels, electricity is essentially free. We're still some way from having enough free energy available to be able to put large amounts of it back into the ground though.