Then why in the world would they have to regulate it?
>> the body that enacted that would not have been allowed to enact the regulation
That 100% wrong legally. No one ever has been able to avoid regulation by claiming that the regulation imposes a net cost. That's the entire point of a regulation, to shift behavior in the absence of direct economic incentives.
In reality, this regulation is a tradeoff between higher net costs for new home builders and the need to reduce carbon emissions.
http://www.energy.ca.gov/efficiency/savings.html
There is no net new cost, overall, this is all win, and if it were not, the standards would not be allowed to be set. In particular, on average, the CEC found $80 of savings on $40 of finance cost:
http://www.energy.ca.gov/releases/2018_releases/2018-05-09_b...
Now, you seem to be implicitly assuming that if this cost savings were true, it would already be done by builders and consumers. However, human behavior is sticky. Even though this is a good idea now, it takes people a long time to realize that.
Witness all the people in this thread that seem to doubt it's not a cost saving measure. Even taking a small peak at the cost of solar should reveal how much of a cost saving measure solar is in California. Even residential, which has high labor costs, and where 30% of the cost of an install goes to customer acquisition costs. For new large builds, that customer acquisition cost goes away, so it becomes an even better deal. And you've already got people on roofs, building them, so it becomes yet an even better idea.
This is why there are companies willing to lease your roof space to install residential solar.
If $40 / month is what you can expect from electricity savings, it's an absolutely awful investment.
The average estimated numbers are $80 of savings for $40 of finance cost:
http://www.energy.ca.gov/releases/2018_releases/2018-05-09_b...
If you consider it an "awful investment" then you simply not make the investment, let a solar company make the investment and do it through a lease instead, with zero upfront cost:
http://www.residentialsolar101.org/solar-lease
In any case it's absolutely clear that this move decreases the cost of a new house after 2020.
Private solar energy will also reduce costs of maintaining a grid, reduce odds of widespread power failure, and reduce costs of environmental externalities of other forms of energy production. California is also pushing hard for electric vehicles. Solar powered electric vehicles reduce reliance on oil production and imports. I don't live in CA but it seems to me they're playing the long game by reducing government ownership/operation of energy systems while reducing the costs of energy for all Californians to a low equilibrium state that reflects the cost of solar panels, which will drop over time. I wish Texas were more interested in these kinds of programs rather than bathroom legislation.
That statement doesn't make sense. You have to compare the net present value of an upfront investment with the electricity savings over time. If you amortize that amount over 30 years it doesn't change the fact you made the upfront payment, you just pay the bank extra money (interest) for the privilege of differing payment.
>>Private solar energy will also reduce costs of maintaining a grid, reduce odds of widespread power failure, and reduce costs of environmental externalities of other forms of energy production. California is also pushing hard for electric vehicles. Solar powered electric vehicles reduce reliance on oil production and imports. I don't live in CA but it seems to me they're playing the long game by reducing government ownership/operation of energy systems while reducing the costs of energy for all Californians to a low equilibrium state that reflects the cost of solar panels, which will drop over time. I wish Texas were more interested in these kinds of programs rather than bathroom legislation.
None of that supports the claim that it is a worthwhile investment to install solar panels on homes. It doesn't follow logically at all. Externalities are the exact reason regulations exist. If you want to argue that the cost is worthwhile for society do it, but none of that has anything to do with the price to a homeowner of installing solar panels.
The societal benefit is a separate bonus, as you stated, but not one to ignore.
You have claimed this multiple times in this thread, but I'll need a citation to believe this. How, exactly, will residential solar make maintaining the grid cheaper? The houses are still tied in to the local utility, so unless you are trying to claim that what causes maintenance costs is literally the amount of power flowing through the wire and not weather/age then I don't believe this for a second.
Edit:typo
The big thing is time-shifting the generated energy; in the spring there's already curtailment of utility-scale installs of solar.
With appropriate time-of-use rates on new installs, keeping older sites grandfathered in, combined with dramatically falling costs of home storage, the market will solve this nicely.