News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by munk-a on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @02:35PM (#17249780)
Similar to a quote often attributed to Churchill that goes...

> Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all the others.

in this case I think the burden of improvement is on those trying to tear down the union and we can rework it a bit to say

> Unions are the worst form of worker protection, except for all the others.

I don't disagree that Unions can de-incentivize workers and become corrupt, but it's the best tool we have right now.

Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by conanbatt on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @03:56PM (#17250521)
I think the burden of proof is on the other side: no special protections should be given to unions, they should be voluntary and thats it.
Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by Avshalom on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @05:52PM (#17251419)
Right-To-Work laws are special protections for the business not vis a versa.

Without them business' and union get/have to freely and voluntarily come to an agreement about employment terms.

With them the union is handicapped in favor of the business.

Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by hpcjoe on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @07:12PM (#17251931)
Wrong in most aspects. Right to work effectively ends most labor monopolies that unions have erected. By removing the monopolies, workers have far better choices about whom to work for, and how to negotiate wages.

Here's a simple example of the power of monopoly and oligarchy. The recent wage fixing kerfuffle over at google, apple, FB, and others resulting initially in depressed wages for workers. Upon breaking up that oligarchy, and putting those companies on notice ... what has happened to wages?

If I believe the pro-union folks here, then they have fallen dramatically, and workers are at a disadvantage in negotiations.

However, I believe in market economics, the invisible hand of the market, and see it in action here. Wages have risen dramatically, as the market distortion due to the oligarchy has been removed, and labor is free to discover its price.

Had there been a union ... this would not have happened. You would have a floor and a ceiling. More productive workers would not seek to increase their wages by working harder, or switching companies. Demand would be distorted.

If you want to be able to negotiate wages, you need leverage. Leverage in the form of a union is well understood, and has consequences for locales. Leverage in the form of demand (get multiple job offers, create a market making enterprise for selling your labor, select the highest/best offer).

Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by Avshalom on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @07:28PM (#17252018)
Also hold on a fucking second: you consider class action lawsuits against employers as some how not part of organized labor?
Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by hpcjoe on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @09:16PM (#17252494)
Language.

The class action was done via antitrust mechanisms as I understand it[1][2][3]. If you want to assume that a class formation is a union, albeit a temporary one to effect good, I FULLY support that. This is how a union should work. It should come into being frictionlessly, and upon completion of its mission, or a specific timeout, it should be destroyed.

Otherwise we get the rent seeking behavior, corruption, etc. which appears to be the normal for unions.

[1] http://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-tech-job...

[2] https://www.cnet.com/news/apple-google-others-settle-anti-po...

[3] https://www.nexsenpruet.com/insights/criminal-antitrust-expo...

Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by Avshalom on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @07:17PM (#17251954)
Those "labor monopolies" were negotiated voluntarily in environments that were already actively hostile to unions. Right to Work laws interfere with the right to association idea that libertarian capitalism champions as a absolute good.
Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by hpcjoe on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @09:21PM (#17252516)
Paraphrasing that economic philosopher Inigo Montoya ... You use that phrase "negotiated voluntarily" ... I do not think it means what you think it means.

Right to work laws limit the power of unions to form labor monopolies, opening up the market for labor. You may form a union or not. You may join one, or not. But you can no longer coerce someone to pay dues/fees for something they do not wish to associate with.

That is, fundamentally, the breaking of a monopoly over labor. Everyone has an inherent right to negotiate on their own if they so choose. Or not, they can join the union if they so choose. But they are no longer coerced into funding activity that they may not wish for on their own behalf.

Right to work does exactly what it says on the label.

Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by TheCoelacanth on Thursday June 07, 2018 @03:26PM (#17259315)
"Right to work" makes it illegal for unions to form exclusivity contracts with businesses. That denies them the ability to freely form contracts that every other type of organization is allowed.

If a business wants to hire people who aren't part of a union, then they shouldn't have signed a contract saying that they won't.

Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by hpcjoe on Friday June 08, 2018 @01:13PM (#17267553)
This is incorrect. Right to work, prevents a monopoly on labor that a business must consume via a union, from using its power to preserve its monopoly.

Previously, businesses, even if opposed in principle to a union forming, had little recourse but to deal with the labor monopoly once formed. NLRB specifically went after businesses opposed to union formation, or who wished to purchase labor on the free and open market.

They had little choice in signing of the contracts. Blaming them for acquiescing to unreasonable demands in order to avoid further material harm ... isnt ... a win, for anyone.

This specific action, that unions so happily crow about, costs employers more. Which drives them to look at investing in new sites where costs are lower, and automation. You are seeing exactly this in the rush to $15/hour areas.

Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by stale2002 on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @03:25PM (#17250229)
No, the burden is instead on the people who are trying to force everyone to join their club.

The baseline default should instead be that nobody is forced to join your organization, and it.is on THEM to convince you to join.

Freedom of association is an important value, that is enshined in the Constitution.

Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by sequoia on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @03:33PM (#17250307)
If you prefer, think of it thus:

1. People in a shop voluntarily associate with the union or not 2. If the shop hires non-union workers, the union workers stop working 3. Mgmt decides whether or not this is worth it to them to hire non-union workers

No one is coerced or forced into an involuntary association. A "union shop" is just a shorthand for the process above.

Incidentally, who is lobbies/bribes politicians for "right to work" etc.? Is it management or individual, non-organized workers? (If you think it's the latter I've got a bridge to sell you...). Why might management be interested in promoting the "right to work"? The interests don't seem to line up.

Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by bmelton on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @06:09PM (#17251511)
> No one is coerced or forced into an involuntary association

That is provably false in at least some states, because joining some professions in certain states required you to pay agency fees whether or not you chose to be a member of the union at all.

That's been the case since 1977, and was decided with __Abood v Detroit Board of Ed__[1], hich compelled teachers to pay union dues, no matter their stance on the union.

To whit:

> A Michigan statute authorizing union representation of local governmental employees permits an "agency shop" arrangement, whereby every employee represented by a union, even though not a union member, must pay to the union, as a condition of employment, a service charge equal in amount to union dues.

That issue is currently up for dispute in __Janus v American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, Council 31__[2]

[1] - https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/431/209/case.htm...

[2] - https://www.oyez.org/cases/2017/16-1466

Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by sequoia on Friday June 08, 2018 @04:51PM (#17269580)
> because joining some professions in certain states required you to pay agency fees whether or not you chose to be a member of the union at all.

You can't work at a private school or as a tutor or private instructor in Michigan without being part of the teacher's union? I dispute your characterization of the "profession" compelling union membership, at least in the case of teachers.

The Detroit Board of Education is a "shop", not a profession. Police officer would perhaps be a better illustration of your point, as one can't really be a "private police officer" but shrug the state has a total monopoly on that law-enforcement profession, so you've got more than unions to contend with there. (Why can't I start my own police department?)

Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by bmelton on Friday June 08, 2018 @07:14PM (#17270495)
You point out that I made a misrepresentation, which I did do by exclusion of a better example and citation.

In Harris v Quinn, the plaintiff quit work to care for a sick relative. Finding out that Illinois had a program to assist home health care workers to help defray the costs. She enrolled in the program and was awarded a grant to help her take care of her relative. According to the Service Employees International Union, this made her an employee of the state of Illinois. Because the state of Illinois was a "union shop", it meant that all people of this sort were de facto "home health care employees of the state", and all home health care workers who received grants of this sort were compelled to pay union dues, whether they were employed by the state, the individual to whom they were providing health care, or whomever else.

In this regard, anyone who the union deemed to be in the home health care profession, and who availed themselves of state assistance, were members of the union, and obligated to paying dues.

[1] - http://apps.washingtonpost.com/g/page/politics/supreme-court...

Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by stale2002 on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @05:09PM (#17251151)
Management is not allowed to fire union people and hire non-union people in their place.

Once the union is created, nobody has any choice but to join it.

Thats the law. Once the union is voted in, they now represent all workers, and it is highly illegal to just decide to fire all the union people. There is nothing voluntary about that.

Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by TheCoelacanth on Thursday June 07, 2018 @03:31PM (#17259382)
When a company agrees to a contract, they are expected to abide by the terms of that contract. Why should unions be disallowed from forming exclusivity contracts when every other type of organization is allowed to?
Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by stale2002 on Friday June 08, 2018 @11:40PM (#17271410)
If a union is allowed to make such an exclusive contract, then management should be allowed to fire everyone for starting the union, before such a contract is made.

The rights work both ways. Either everyone should be allowed to make exclusive contracts, INCLUDING a contract that disallows unions, or nobody should be allowed to do so.

Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by conanbatt on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:39AM (#17253554)
3b. Mgmt decides to fire employees that are defaulting on their contract to work. 4. Mgmt hires new non-union workers.
Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by sequoia on Friday June 08, 2018 @04:52PM (#17269588)
Exactly. No one is "compelled" to do anything, the employer can fire everyone–that's their choice.
Re:The New Yorker has formed a union by stale2002 on Friday June 08, 2018 @11:45PM (#17271429)
Employers can't fire people for being in unions. That's illegal.

Either everyone should be protected, ie you can neither be fired for being in a union or for NOT being in a union, or nobody should be able to be fired for these things.