Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ...
by vengefulduck on Saturday June 02, 2018 @12:30PM
(#17215243)
I'm nearly certain the parent commenter was being sarcastic.
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ...
by zer00eyz on Saturday June 02, 2018 @01:19PM
(#17215440)
The original analogy was good - the commenter diminishes it by trying to portray the NSA person responsible as a different actor. This is the same person who has burned the community before. That old adage about fooling someone once applies here, and for good reason.
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ...
by mindslight on Saturday June 02, 2018 @01:34PM
(#17215505)
Focusing responsibility on the individual NSA agent is a red herring - the entire organization is the hostile party. Would you judge the situation differently if it were a different operative pushing Speck?
The asset themselves probably isn't even privy to the actual existence of a backdoor, due to compartmentalization and for the sake of their own sincerity.
They're more akin to the waiter. A waiter that doesn't want to think too hard about whether your food was spit in, as their job depends on not knowing. How are you doing today? smile
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ...
by setquk on Sunday June 03, 2018 @03:21AM
(#17218370)
This is my entire original point. Literally being associated with the organisation taints the product if it is 100% legitimate or not.
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ...
by mindslight on Saturday June 02, 2018 @12:31PM
(#17215245)
That's the waiter.
> The NSA (in particular, the exact same person who previously promoted DUAL_EC in ISO) proposed to include Simon & Speck
The author is pointing out that the same person spit in your food before.