Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ...
by mindslight on Saturday June 02, 2018 @12:15PM
(#17215167)
No, no. You don't understand. That's the other side of the kitchen that was spitting in people's food last week. Your friendly waiter obviously got your food from the clean side this week! And it's clearly offensive to even ask whether your plate could have gotten near the known spitters, which is why he refuses to answer.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ...
by zer00eyz on Saturday June 02, 2018 @12:28PM
(#17215233)
LOL -- you didn't read the article did you?
> The NSA (in particular, the exact same person who previously promoted DUAL_EC in ISO) proposed to include Simon & Speck
The author is pointing out that the same person spit in your food before.
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ...
by vengefulduck on Saturday June 02, 2018 @12:30PM
(#17215243)
I'm nearly certain the parent commenter was being sarcastic.
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ...
by zer00eyz on Saturday June 02, 2018 @01:19PM
(#17215440)
The original analogy was good - the commenter diminishes it by trying to portray the NSA person responsible as a different actor. This is the same person who has burned the community before. That old adage about fooling someone once applies here, and for good reason.
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ...
by mindslight on Saturday June 02, 2018 @01:34PM
(#17215505)
Focusing responsibility on the individual NSA agent is a red herring - the entire organization is the hostile party. Would you judge the situation differently if it were a different operative pushing Speck?
The asset themselves probably isn't even privy to the actual existence of a backdoor, due to compartmentalization and for the sake of their own sincerity.
They're more akin to the waiter. A waiter that doesn't want to think too hard about whether your food was spit in, as their job depends on not knowing. How are you doing today? smile
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ...
by setquk on Sunday June 03, 2018 @03:21AM
(#17218370)
This is my entire original point. Literally being associated with the organisation taints the product if it is 100% legitimate or not.
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ...
by mindslight on Saturday June 02, 2018 @12:31PM
(#17215245)
That's the waiter.