I can't legally set up a WiMax tower like I can set up a WiFi hot spot. Doesn't opening whitespaces mean that you could set up, say, a city-wide access point without asking permission? Or did I miss something? If that's the case, it's likely to spawn LOTS more competition than assigning frequencies to the highest bidder - which is actually 0 competetion, actually; it's a granted monopoly.
If I'm understanding right, there could be networks that are not for profit, or indirectly so. Like, maybe a hospital could have a Wi-Fi-like network that spans the whole city, which their ambulances could use to transmit vitals to the hospital while bringing in a patient.
Cell phone wise - lets say we have 3000ft range in superWiFi instead of WiFi 300ft. Would the overlaps be enough to imagine a robust voice/data carrying by hoping from router to router (FidoNet style) with coverage similar to the early days of cell phones?
So while there wouldn't be an end to the carriers (whom we're kidding - the Ma'Bell is practically still alive) there are big improvements to come.
First, the 2.4ghz spectrum is not the best for wireless comms, there were many reasons for opening up that spectrum and very few of those reasons were because it was an optimal signal frequency.
Second, bandwidth. The 2.4ghz spectrum is confined within an 82mhz band. The available whitespace spectrum has a significantly larger bandwidth.
Third, technology. 802.11b and g are based on technology that is now stale by more than a decade. Today's wireless broadband tech makes those protocols look like a 56k modem.
The combination of these factors allows for stunning possibilities. More efficient broadband technologies, better broadcast frequencies, more bandwidth. These allow for more users with higher data rates at farther distances from base stations. It also makes things like bridging access points a lot easier. There's little reason to believe that in 10 years whitespace broadband access points won't be utterly ubiquitous.
As for WiMax, that's not open spectrum, consumers can't buy a WiMax AP on newegg. That makes it an entirely different beast.
Intuitively, the more information you want to transmit, the more you have to mess up with the frequencies. Hence the bandwidth per Hz thing.
(Disclaimer: I don't know much about the subject. Corrections, clarifications, and precisions are welcome.)
Given that this isn't the way it works, there must be some major flaw with it.
That's why your method doesn't work.
In terms of utilizing frequencies that can provide connections over longer range than 2.4GHz, that's exactly what WiMax already is. And WiMax specs aren't leading us towards any kind of free internet, they're the new high priced 4G service you now buy from the same cell companies as always.