Re:Telegram App Says Apple Is Blocking Updates Over Dispute ...
by codedokode on Friday June 01, 2018 @03:26AM
(#17203303)
> "must comply with all legal requirements"
Every country has its own legal requirements. As Telegram is a British company I assume it must comply only with British laws, right?
Re:Telegram App Says Apple Is Blocking Updates Over Dispute ...
by floatingatoll on Friday June 01, 2018 @01:58PM
(#17208123)
Telegram may absolutely ignore non-British laws and refuse to concern itself with them. Independent of laws, Apple may refuse Telegram access to the App Store if a guideline is not met.
Re:Telegram App Says Apple Is Blocking Updates Over Dispute ...
by y_molodtsov on Friday June 01, 2018 @06:47AM
(#17204170)
Tell that to GDPR.
I’m pretty sure Apple meant the compliance with the regulations of the countries where the app is available.
Apple received a notice of illegality from Russia regarding Telegram, a third-party app. This notice was inappropriately delivered to Apple, who currently has no responsibility for Telegram. Telegram's compliance with Russian law is not Apple's problem unless a Russian court orders Apple to de-list Telegram. Until such an order occurs, Apple has no reason to de-list Telegram.
Therefore, I believe that Apple did three things:
[1] Apple temporarily suspended Telegram app updates worldwide after receiving a notice of illegality.
[2] Apple immediately forwarded the notice of illegality to Telegram, without any assertion of validity.
[3] Apple notified Telegram that they may resume updates by either declaring in writing to Apple that Telegram is legal in Russia or de-listing Telegram in Russia.
And Telegram did no things:
[4] Telegram has refused to declare in writing to Apple that Telegram is legal in Russia, and has refused to de-list Telegram in Russia.
And Telegram, after two months of refusing to act on [3], is trying to pressure Apple into giving up on [3] using the "woe is me" GDPR excuse.
[5] https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#leg...