`a` is permitted for other apps; `b` is, as far as I know, not a criteria anything else gets judged on; and `c` is the point of having a curated store, because any app "may allow [...] abuse".
For instance, ad blocking also works with Feedly - my RSS reader.
This isn't theoretical. iOS apps were in fact storing and selling data that went across the ad blocking VPN solutions.
Ad blocking Chrome plugins have a sordid history. Why would I trust them on my phone when I can set up my own solution relatively easily?
The IOS solution for in browser plug ins is more secure and it protects your privacy.
There is one exception. Overcast, my podcast player. There is a no ads in app purchase, but the ads are usually for other podcasts in the same category that I'm listening to. The ads are actually useful.
I think the main reason they block apps using VPNs for other things is that it’s very easy for them to break internet on the whole phone with buggy software, and Apple don’t want lots of support time at the Genius Bar of turning off crappy ad blocking VPN apps.
Walking the line between the pro-privacy aspects of VPN ad blocking and the the very anti-privacy possibilities that such functionality enables isn't easy. There's nothing to stop any VPN from scary levels of metadata collection, but Apple did close the door to one way of promoting or selling these services.
App devs hate hearing this, but I've always found it interesting that Apple doesn't try to take a cut of ad revenue that apps receive. And yet they insist on taking a cut of "tips" and pretty much any other revenue stream. I'm glad they don't because it would put them in an adversarial position with privacy.
I guess they tried with iAds, but even that was going to be optional I believe.
What I do now -though on Android- is using WireGuard as VPN to my home router which runs basically a Pi-Hole (and WireGuard).
The benefits:
1) I get a system-wide adblocker on top of uBlock Origin.
2) My mobile provider cannot perform DPI (Though its owned by same company as my cable company. YMMV, plus it will work when you roam internationally. Heck, I can perform DPI on it via my router.)
3) When on a public WiFi (e.g. railway station) all my data is encrypted.
4) When I switch networks it automatically swaps connection.
5) Far less performance hit and battery usage than traditional VPNs such as OpenVPN. Home router also barely uses any Watt.
Brilliant software, I can highly recommend. My only beef with it is that a full blown SDN such as ZeroTier is a lot easier to set up.
[1] https://www.wireguard.com/install/
Easiest way to address the claims, let me know if you need a more detailed breakdown: Note Facebook's VPN is still available - they're just not allowed to advertise it blocks ads, which they never did in the first place.
There are still a lot of apps using the VPN API for additional purposes. For instance, AdGuard Pro for iOS is still there, and it lets users use DNSCrypt or block domains manually. The difference is that it does not do system-wide ad blocking by default.
I note from reading AdGuard’s App Store description that it seems to do as blocking with the content blocking APIs, and uses the VPN only for DNS changes.
Apple explicitly allows and provides APIs to develop content blockers.
Apple does not allow content blocking through custom VPN implementations, seemingly because these a) introduce a performance impact, b) may be confusing for users as it’s abusing the point of VPNs, and c) may allow more easy abuse, as VPNs can do a lot more than just block content. This is what the article linked as evidence for Apple’s policy covers, and the statement provided by Apple, while not especially clear, does match up with this.
I think the title should be reverted to remove Apple, as they do allow ad blockers on the store (I personally use 1BlockerX https://itunes.apple.com/gb/app/1blocker-x/id1365531024?mt=8 )