News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The 9.9 Percent Is the New American Aristocracy by bzbarsky on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @12:35AM (#17176525)
As a simplified thought experiment, consider an a priori perfectly equal, static (equal numbers of people of all ages) society with the following characteristics:

* People are in school until age 20.

* Assets at age 20 are 0.

* People work until age 65.

* People die at age 85.

* Assets at death are 0.

Assume that inflation and investment returns are 0. After-tax income while working is uniform, say at $100k/year. Expenses are uniform. We'll pretend expenses before age 20 are 0 (covered by taxes). A really super-simplified model.

Total lifetime after-tax income is $4.5 million. This is 65 years worth of expenses, so expenses are $69231/year.

Peak wealth, at 65, is $1,384,605. Wealth around that peak is distributed like so as a function of age:

  59 -- $1,199,991
  60 -- $1,230,760
  61 -- $1,261,529
  62 -- $1,292,298
  63 -- $1,323,067
  64 -- $1,353,836
  65 -- $1,384,605
  66 -- $1,315,284
  67 -- $1,245,963
The top 10% of the population by wealth are all in that age range (because 9/85 > 1/10). Note that by construction this is a perfectly equal society.

The point is, looking at wealth numbers without considering lifecycle effects is usually pointless. Yes, having a paid-off house and a bunch of saved-up retirement money is not something most people have. It's something that generally only people approaching retirement would have. Younger folks have neither yet; someone who has been retired for a while may have the former but no longer the latter.

Now looking at wealth distributions while holding age constants is a more interesting exercise. You can still run into issues because of differences in lifeycles, of course. As a simple example, what can one say about the lifetime earning prospects of a 30-year old making $60k a year? Well, it sure depends on whether they're an elementary school teacher or a neurosurgery resident.

Unfortunately, good analysis of this stuff is hard. It's even hard to figure out what sort of questions make sense to ask....

There are no comments on this comment yet.