Re:Student makes history with human-powered ‘flapping-wing’ ...
by jjcm on Wednesday September 22, 2010 @04:28PM
(#1717402)
I suppose my question here is such: Does the flapping actually generate enough lift to both sustain and initiate flight? We've had gliders that can stay afloat for ages with the right thermals, but they (like we see in this video as well) require something powered to get them started. It's beautiful, yes, but from what I can see in the video it looks like it's almost entirely aesthetics.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Student makes history with human-powered ‘flapping-wing’ ...
by faramarz on Wednesday September 22, 2010 @04:37PM
(#1717431)
I'll quote a comment made on the article
"There is a minimum requirement for flight which
it met. That involves maintaining altitude and
speed over a certain period of time, whereas in
a glide you either lose speed to maintain altitude
until stall or lose altitude to maintain speed until ground.
The flyer maintained and even appeared to gain
altitude after the pull cord was released from the car
and maintained speed throughout the flight. If you are
wondering how I get this from the video, it's because
I am familiar with the researchers who did this."
Re:Student makes history with human-powered ‘flapping-wing’ ...
by pepijndevos on Wednesday September 22, 2010 @04:47PM
(#1717465)
A good glider can easily do dozens of meters while losing only one meter in height(I flew one), so it is impossible to tell from the shaky video. But if he knows those guys and tells the truth, awesome!
It looks beautiful anyway though.
Re:Student makes history with human-powered ‘flapping-wing’ ...
by pepijndevos on Wednesday September 22, 2010 @04:49PM
(#1717469)
Sustaining, maybe; initiating, never.
If you own one of those X-twin foam planes, try mounting wheels on them. They only take of from tables and such, not form the ground.