It helps you realise that a lot of positive stuff will happen during your day that you don't notice, because the anxiety about what the future might hold dominates your attention. Even if it's as simple as making toast with that perfect level of crunchiness, or saying good morning to someone and noticing a smile.
I'm a strong advocate of finding a therapist you trust, though. These things can help a great deal on the surface, which is fantastic, but it's important to have somebody there if your awareness goes deeper into your past, which is where the 'why' is.
[0]: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=cynic+gratitude+journal
[1]: https://theweek.com/articles/734555/how-overcome-inner-cynic...
[2]: https://medium.com/the-mission/gratitude-journaling-for-cyni...
Being optimistic, without setting expectations so high that you're constantly disappointed, seems to be a more pleasurable way to live your life. Also, the consequences of failure to meet whatever high standards self-critical people put on themselves are rarely as bad as you think before it happens.
I like your way of finding some balance between being pessimistic and optimistic.
On the second part: or you could just set high expectations and learn how to live in a constant disappointment without being any less happy because of it.
I don't know, in my experience having high expectations seems to set you up for a higher fall and a lower upside, thus leading to less happiness. I have generally quite low expectations and am generally quite happy. Some people around me have generally much higher expectations and are generally quite unhappy. The things in life where I do have some higher expectations about are also the things I'm the least happy about.
I used to feel this way, but I no longer think that optimism and expectation have to be that closely linked. To me optimism is about having hope, not expectations. Similarly, my pessimism isn't about what I expect to happen, it's about what I fear happening.
So, I choose to balance my fear and hope.
Why do people always bring that in ? Suffering of the same stuff described in parent posts, I tend to focus on stability and appreciation of what is here and now. I guess it's another way to cope with it.
I think it started as a measure of self protection after a long string of broken promises when I was a kid, but it's a shitty way to live. My biggest realization was just that pessimism is no more logical than optimism.
My solution has been to give equal time to positive thoughts. So, if I find myself thinking for a couple minutes about how something might go horribly wrong, I spend the next couple minutes imagining what the best case scenario would be like.
I'm basically forcing hope back into my life.