For reentry safety, the best approach IMO is reducing reentry speeds via a lifting body fuselage. This is what SS1 uses. With drag bodies (e.g. Apollo capsule) there's all this worry over heatshields and reentry angle; with a lifting body, the vehicle glides into the atmosphere subsonically and heating is a nonissue. SS1 has minimal heat shielding, and no active cooling. A capsule is apparently simpler to design and easier to understand than something more airplane-like, but so is an ornithopter over a fixed-wing aircraft (kids ask how planes fly without moving their wings, because flapping flight is more obvious). One design requires delicate control and handling though, while the other is elegantly robust, more reliable, and safer.
But the most dangerous part of the flight is on the pad, a seat capable of firing you horizontally far enough to be clear of an explosion on the pad would be difficult - you would probably need the entire crew compartment to eject on it's own set of rockets - but this wouldn't work on landing, the other dangerous stage. Then there is the added danger of the rest of the flight - when inside the pressure hull you have the rockets necessary to blow a 2ton escape pod 3-5km clear of a pad fire.
So any escape system that would work for the specific Challenger failure - supersonic but at regualr aircraft altitude - wouldn't work for say a pad explosion, or a failure at higher altitude, or a failure where the boosters didn't separate, or a crash on landing or .....
Fitting a dozen different ejection seats to swap between during takeoff and landing is tricky!