News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

rtyuioikujhy

Re:The Wrong Stuff: NASA Astronaut on Making and Fixing Mistakes on Thursday September 23, 2010 @11:23AM (#1719934)
Ejector seats would work for a challenger stage accident. The first shuttle with only 2 pilots on board did have aircraft style ejector seats. The problem comes when you have a crew of 7 on two levels - you could have down/side-ward firing seats, as used on some B52 variants, but that compromises the heat shield.

But the most dangerous part of the flight is on the pad, a seat capable of firing you horizontally far enough to be clear of an explosion on the pad would be difficult - you would probably need the entire crew compartment to eject on it's own set of rockets - but this wouldn't work on landing, the other dangerous stage. Then there is the added danger of the rest of the flight - when inside the pressure hull you have the rockets necessary to blow a 2ton escape pod 3-5km clear of a pad fire.

Re:The Wrong Stuff: NASA Astronaut on Making and Fixing Mistakes on Thursday September 23, 2010 @11:16AM (#1719908)
This was the system where after the craft explodes and is falling to earth at mach2 - you jettison a hatch, extend a boom, put on safety harness, clip the harness to the boom and slide out to then end (to clear the wings and tail) jump off and open your parachute?

No mention of what happens if something goes wrong while you are still attached to 2Million lbs of liquid hydrogen/oxygen.

I remember the laughter at the time ....

Re:Stringbike: Chain-free bike on Wednesday September 22, 2010 @01:29PM (#1716847)
It's zero maintenance. For 'serious' bike riders who care about efficiency and clean/oil chains it's useless.

For riders who use the bike for one week/year, put it away when it rains and never touch it otherwise it's great

Re:The Wrong Stuff: NASA Astronaut on Making and Fixing Mistakes on Wednesday September 22, 2010 @01:26PM (#1716840)
Zero.

Remember there is no need to make an accident survivable because an accident can't happen "Failure is not an option" and lots of other macho chest beating.

If the Titanic had been built by Nasa it would have had no lifeboats, a crew of 10,000 safety inspectors but would still have hit the iceberg.

Re:The Wrong Stuff: NASA Astronaut on Making and Fixing Mistakes on Wednesday September 22, 2010 @01:24PM (#1716833)
the difficulty isn't just making this accident survivable, it's making any other accident at any other stage of the flight survivable.

So any escape system that would work for the specific Challenger failure - supersonic but at regualr aircraft altitude - wouldn't work for say a pad explosion, or a failure at higher altitude, or a failure where the boosters didn't separate, or a crash on landing or .....

Fitting a dozen different ejection seats to swap between during takeoff and landing is tricky!

Re:The Wrong Stuff: NASA Astronaut on Making and Fixing Mistakes on Wednesday September 22, 2010 @01:08PM (#1716788)
As someone else has said making an ejection system that could resuce the crew at each stage of the flight is very difficult.

What's more troubling (although not surprising) is Nasa's 'news management' in keeping this a secret because of fear of bad publicity.

20 years later this attitude hadn't changed with the Columbia - when Nasa prevented any in-orbit inspection of the damaged tiles. Just in case they then had the PR nightmare of a crew that were likely to die on re-entry and no way of rescuing them.