News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by sykh on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:45PM (#17120221)
It is unreasonable in my opinion to consider Janus a constitutional issue. It's not a free speech issue even though it has been popularly cropped as such. People who benefit from collective bargaining ought to help pay for it.

I'm not a lawyer and you'll be able to cite a thousand cases to my one. My sister's neighbor is on the state Supreme Court where I live. He's said to me that a good lawyer can argue any case and cite a bunch of reasons to support his/her case.

For me the case is simple. The collectively bargained rules apply to everyone in the workplace. As such those who benefit from said bargaining ought to pay for it. This has been an established practice for many, many years. Each state has the right to negate this and many have enacted misnamed right to work laws. There is no compelling reason to change the current practice. Janus' speech is not currently threatened and the greater public interest should be the one that prevails. It won't though.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by mmt on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:07PM (#17121392)
> It is unreasonable in my opinion to consider Janus a constitutional issue.

I'd agree with you if it weren't for the fact that this is about the government and government employees everywhere you look.

I never understood how we as a society and how the labor union movement could tolerate the existence of public employee unions in the first place, as they end up intermingling two otherwise very distinct worlds, as I believe has happened here.

What you call "collective bargaining" in this case I could call "pure political pressure", since the "bargaining" is against politicians.

That sounds awfully Constitution-ey to me.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by sykh on Monday May 21, 2018 @05:13PM (#17121873)
Government is an employer. With the exception of the military employees have a right to unionize subject to certain constraints. Why distinguish between public vs. private? Why shouldn’t a union be political? Don’t workers have a right to gather in a group and be political? Government workers should be excluded from this activity?

Janus is not really about free speech. It’s an attempt to destroy unions by letting people benefit from collective bargaining without paying for it. It’s called the free rider problem.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by mmt on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:40PM (#17122446)
> Why distinguish between public vs. private?

Because one is the government and the other isn't. That's my whole point about it being reasonable that this is a Constitutional issue.

There's also the, arguably separate, issues of incentives and who ultimately pays. In the case of private employers, it is, presumably a powerful few trying to exploit the labor of the many. In the case of government, it's the taxpayer/voter who is ultimately being bargained "against".

What are public employee unions trying to prevent? The exploitation by the many (voters) of the labor of the few? That seems wholly unreasonable to me.

> Why shouldn’t a union be political? Don’t workers have a right to gather in a group and be political? Government workers should be excluded from this activity?

(Again, not a union, but a public employee union:)

Because they are, in effect, circumventing the normal political process. By using the power to strike, they're seizing power from the voters.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by sykh on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:51PM (#17122507)
A public employee union is not the government. With limited exceptions being a public employee does not mean you forfeit your rights. There should not be distinction between public employee union and private employee unions. If workers come together to bargain as a unit then they should be allowed to do so wether they are public employees or not.

Unions do not circumvent the normal political process. They are not seizing power from voters. Your view appears a bit extreme.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by mmt on Monday May 21, 2018 @07:47PM (#17122768)
This response strikes me as mainly "truth through repeated assertion", without any refutation.

> A public employee union is not the government.

I'm not suggesting it is, as such. It is, however, made up of the people who operate the "machinery" of government, and it's the government witholding the dues from the paycheck that funds this union, so, again, of Constitutional significance.

> There should not be distinction between public employee union and private employee unions.

And I say there should. There's my assertion :)

> Unions do not circumvent the normal political process. They are not seizing power from voters. Your view appears a bit extreme.

They may be extreme, but that doesn't make them invalid on their face. I don't have a vested interest here, either.

Here's my vision of public employee unions not circumventing the normal political process:

Instead of "negotiating" with the power to strike, they can just go to the voters (and elected representatives) and campaign for their share of the tax dollars (or working conditions or whatever other legislation), just like every other special interest.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by sykh on Monday May 21, 2018 @09:22PM (#17123136)
We assert different things. I claim your view that unions circumvent the political process is a bit extreme. Workers should be able to band together to advance their cause without regard to whether or not they are public employees. Working for the government should not necessarily mean that your rights get limited. There are exceptions. Like for the military.

Of course this is just my opinion. I can’t claim it’s objectively correct.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by mmt on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:34PM (#17123535)
If you're claiming mere opinion, then why characterize my position as "extreme" and "unreasonable"?

It's one thing merely to disagree, but those words are another matter. They call for a bit more effort, especially since "reason" is usually objective.

I have made a concerted effort to outline how I come to the conclusion of circumvention of political process and Constitutionality, yet you've not directly responded to any of those explanations, especially not how someone reasonable might reach a less extreme conclusion.

> Workers should be able to band together to advance their cause without regard to whether or not they are public employees.

No disagreement there, but that's never been at issue. What's at issue is money, and money that's being forcibly taken. Alternatively, it's workers being forced to "band together".

What I'm saying is really going on is that they're able to "band together" to influence government appropriations in a way other than the normal political process (without saying normal process if fair/effective or not, since that's another topic).

> Working for the government should not necessarily mean that your rights get limited.

Why not? What happened to the notion of public service? No amount of wishing will ever turn it into the same kind of relationship as an employee has to a private employer.

> There are exceptions. Like for the military.

And why the inconsistency with respect to the military? To me, drawing a bright line there (instead of, say, at either, carrying a gun or "critical" public services) approaches a position of extremity.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by sykh on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:35AM (#17123732)
I claim it’s extreme and unreasonable because it’s outside of the view most people have on the issue. Most people do not see unions co-opting the normal political process. Most people don’t think being a public employee ought to mean giving up rights. The exceptions I mentioned are exceptions in current law, not necessarily exceptions that I support. The law has inconsistencies in it. In the comments one lawyer mentioned that the government can’t censor and this is of course not true. CIA employees have limits on their free speech rights for instance.
Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by mmt on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:05AM (#17123846)
> I claim it’s extreme and unreasonable because it’s outside of the view most people have on the issue.

I don't think those words mean what you think they mean. The word you're looking for is "unpopular".

> Most people do not see unions co-opting the normal political process.

You keep saying "unions", but I allege that this remains a verbal trick on the part of public employee unions, to lump themselves in with other unions.

I'm sure your statement is true on its face, but I'm not so sure it's true when applied only to public employee unions.

I'm much less sure of its truth when applied specifically to local groups of voters. Try asking some of the ones living in bankrupted municipalities.

> The exceptions I mentioned are exceptions in current law

This makes your argument/opinion very hard to follow, since you string together "should" statements with "is". Is that by design?

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by chimeracoder on Monday May 21, 2018 @05:37PM (#17122056)
Janus is about a case in which a person is being forced to pay money out of his paycheck to a group who directly lobbies for policies that he does not support.

> Why shouldn’t a union be political?

By that argument, why shouldn't the government force you to donate money to political advocacy groups that it chooses, whether or not you support the group's agenda?

Heck, what if your employer decided that a portion of your paycheck would be deducted as a mandatory donation to either the Democratic or Republican party, as part of the terms of your employment?

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by s73v3r_ on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:02PM (#17122237)
"Janus is about a case in which a person is being forced to pay money out of his paycheck to a group who directly lobbies for policies that he does not support."

And also negotiates on his behalf for better working conditions and pay.

At the end of the day, that person wants all the benefits of being in the union (enhanced negotiating power, benefits, etc), without any of the cost.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by chimeracoder on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:06PM (#17122269)
> And also negotiates on his behalf for better working conditions and pay.

Sounds like he doesn't believe that they do, and would prefer to be left out of the bargaining unit.

> At the end of the day, that person wants all the benefits of being in the union (enhanced negotiating power, benefits, etc), without any of the cost

There's literally no evidence that he wants the union to provide any of that.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by s73v3r_ on Monday May 21, 2018 @07:30PM (#17122684)
"Sounds like he doesn't believe that they do, and would prefer to be left out of the bargaining unit."

If that were true, then he would be suing to be left out of the bargaining unit.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by mmt on Monday May 21, 2018 @07:51PM (#17122786)
Forgive my ignorance, but is that even possible?

If so, could you point to such lawsuits, especially successful ones?

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by chimeracoder on Monday May 21, 2018 @08:01PM (#17122839)
> Forgive my ignorance, but is that even possible?

It's not. The suit Janus actually filed is the closest thing to that.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by sykh on Monday May 21, 2018 @09:35PM (#17123181)
Janus is not about being left out of the bargaining unit. It’s about not being forced to pay for collective bargaining that all the workers benefit from. That they all benefit from it is clear when you compare non collectively bargained workplaces with those that are.
Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by chimeracoder on Monday May 21, 2018 @09:45PM (#17123211)
> Janus is not about being left out of the bargaining unit. It’s about not being forced to pay for collective bargaining that all the workers benefit from.

You keep hammering on this claim, except it's clear Janus doesn't believe that he's benefiting from it. It's actually quite easy to find examples - from the very beginning of the labor movement up through today - of labor unions screwing over certain classes of members for political reasons. So it's pretty easy to imagine how Janus would have reason to believe he's being forced to pay for something that has a net negative impact on him.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by sykh on Monday May 21, 2018 @10:36PM (#17123371)
He is free to believe this. He is free to advocate that his state become a so called right to work state. It’s not the place of the Supreme Court to play the role of the legislature. Janus’ claims to having his free speech impinged are ridiculous. He can’t point to an aspect of free speech that he can’t now do but could if he didn’t help pay for his collectively bargained contract. His claims in this regard are ridiculous.

He’s already entitled to a refund of the portion of union dues (if he decided to join it) that go to political activities. This is the Beck decision in the late 80s.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by chimeracoder on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:37PM (#17123543)
> It’s not the place of the Supreme Court to play the role of the legislature. Janus’ claims to having his free speech impinged are ridiculous. He can’t point to an aspect of free speech that he can’t now do but could if he didn’t help pay for his collectively bargained contract.

Actually, it is the role of the judiciary to determine if the legislature has overstepped the bounds of the authority granted to it by Congress, by providing public labor unions with a degree of special authority granted to no other entity. And, as explained elsewhere in this thread by an actual lawyer, there's a pretty solid case that it has.

[dead]
Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by mmt on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:17AM (#17123881)
> are ridiculous

> It’s absurd

This isn't the first time you've used words that insult the intellect of someone who holds an opinion you merely disagree with.

You fail to address the specific points that others have made, instead choosing to tar their whole argument as "ridiculous" and "absurd". If it were either of those things, you wouldn't have to say so.

It doesn't further the conversation and strikes me as little more than a re-iteration of previous assertions.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by s73v3r_ on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:14PM (#17127025)
"You keep hammering on this claim, except it's clear Janus doesn't believe that he's benefiting from it."

Again, if this is what he believed, then he would be suing to get out of the bargaining unit.

The entire suit is a scam to weaken the power of unions. If the union has to act on behalf of you, but you don't have to pay, then very, very few people are going to actually pay for the union, and it will die.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by chimeracoder on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:40PM (#17127251)
> Again, if this is what he believed, then he would be suing to get out of the bargaining unit. The entire suit is a scam to weaken the power of unions. If the union has to act on behalf of you, but you don't have to pay....

The courts have already ruled that the unions can create contracts that exclude non-members from bargaining units (and therefore refuse representation to non-members) as long as they don't charge the non-members agency fees. If Janus wins the right not to pay an agency fee, that's what they'll do.

The only scam is in pretending that the unions are forced to represent people like Janus whether or not they receive fees. That's nonsense; it's their decision entirely to include non-members in the bargaining unit.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by rayiner on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:09PM (#17121408)
The issue is that public unions are highly political animals. Being forced to fund them, just to have a government job, is akin to being forced to donate to a political party. We're not talking about neutral entities just looking out for worker's rights, but partisan entities typically in bed with the Democratic party.
Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by sykh on Monday May 21, 2018 @05:01PM (#17121797)
There is no distinction between public employee unions and private employee unions. People are not forced to join unions. They are, for the time being, in some states required to pay for fair share dues to cover the costs of collective bargaining, grievances, and other administrative costs. People who join the union can get a refund of the portion of their dues that go to political activities.

Since you are making a distinction about public vs. private unions it appears that this is not a constitutional issue. It seems to be one where you don’t like that they generally endorse and support one party over the other. There are very few entities that are neutral. All sufficiently large entities become political to some degree.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by chimeracoder on Monday May 21, 2018 @05:43PM (#17122105)
> People are not forced to join unions.

This is completely false. People absolutely are forced to join unions.

Furthermore, the overwhelming majority of union members - over 90% - never voted in a certification or authorization election. That means that, even if they're members of the union, their membership cannot in se be considered an endorsement of the union by the bargaining unit. Because it's all-but-impossible to successfully decertify a union in practice[0], it's not uncommon to have the majority of employees oppose union membership, but still be compelled into membership.

> They are, for the time being, in some states required to pay for fair share dues to cover the costs of collective bargaining, grievances, and other administrative costs

People within the bargaining unit are usually forced to pay dues whether or not they are members.

[0] The NLRB has the power to overturn the results of decertification, and a very strong incentive to do so. In addition, unions have learned that they can change the definition of the bargaining unit after an election is held in order to invalidate the election retroactively.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by s73v3r_ on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:04PM (#17122255)
Why is it that conservatives, when discussing any other aspect of a job (pay, working conditions, abuse, etc) will say that "you have a choice; you don't have to take the job," but when it comes to unions, suddenly everyone is forced?
Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by rayiner on Monday May 21, 2018 @07:33PM (#17122696)
When it comes to public unions the "unconstitutional conditions" doctrine comes into play. The Supreme Court has long held that the government cannot indirectly infringe free speech rights by imposing conditions on government employment, such as requiring employees to contribute to or join a particular political party. As Rehnquist pointed out, those cases are "indistinguishable" from situations where public employees are required to join particular unions. The public unions in Janus, for example, which are given special status and powers by state law, are nothing more than adjuncts of the Democratic party.
Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by s73v3r_ on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:28PM (#17127712)
"The public unions in Janus, for example, which are given special status and powers by state law, are nothing more than adjuncts of the Democratic party."

This is absolutely not true in the least. Unions tend to support candidates that will help and support them, just like anyone else who backs any other candidate.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by chimeracoder on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:12PM (#17122300)
> Why is it that conservatives, when discussing any other aspect of a job (pay, working conditions, abuse, etc) will say that "you have a choice; you don't have to take the job," but when it comes to unions, suddenly everyone is forced?

Why are you asking me? Go find some conservatives and ask them.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by sykh on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:55PM (#17122527)
OK, so you are not a conservative. The essence of the question remains. Perhaps answering it would be helpful instead of the response you gave.
Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by chimeracoder on Monday May 21, 2018 @08:03PM (#17122850)
> OK, so you are not a conservative. The essence of the question remains. Perhaps answering it would be helpful instead of the response you gave.

Perhaps asking someone who has actually made both those statements would be more helpful than asking me.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by rayiner on Monday May 21, 2018 @05:55PM (#17122192)
> Since you are making a distinction about public vs. private unions it appears that this is not a constitutional issue.

Private entities can limit free speech all they want; public entities cannot.

Re:Supreme Court Upholds Workplace Arbitration Contracts by sykh on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:54PM (#17122521)
AFSCME is not a public entity. NEA is not a public entity. These unions do not in any way limit speech.