And also negotiates on his behalf for better working conditions and pay.
At the end of the day, that person wants all the benefits of being in the union (enhanced negotiating power, benefits, etc), without any of the cost.
Sounds like he doesn't believe that they do, and would prefer to be left out of the bargaining unit.
> At the end of the day, that person wants all the benefits of being in the union (enhanced negotiating power, benefits, etc), without any of the cost
There's literally no evidence that he wants the union to provide any of that.
If that were true, then he would be suing to be left out of the bargaining unit.
If so, could you point to such lawsuits, especially successful ones?
It's not. The suit Janus actually filed is the closest thing to that.
You keep hammering on this claim, except it's clear Janus doesn't believe that he's benefiting from it. It's actually quite easy to find examples - from the very beginning of the labor movement up through today - of labor unions screwing over certain classes of members for political reasons. So it's pretty easy to imagine how Janus would have reason to believe he's being forced to pay for something that has a net negative impact on him.
He’s already entitled to a refund of the portion of union dues (if he decided to join it) that go to political activities. This is the Beck decision in the late 80s.
Actually, it is the role of the judiciary to determine if the legislature has overstepped the bounds of the authority granted to it by Congress, by providing public labor unions with a degree of special authority granted to no other entity. And, as explained elsewhere in this thread by an actual lawyer, there's a pretty solid case that it has.
> It’s absurd
This isn't the first time you've used words that insult the intellect of someone who holds an opinion you merely disagree with.
You fail to address the specific points that others have made, instead choosing to tar their whole argument as "ridiculous" and "absurd". If it were either of those things, you wouldn't have to say so.
It doesn't further the conversation and strikes me as little more than a re-iteration of previous assertions.
Again, if this is what he believed, then he would be suing to get out of the bargaining unit.
The entire suit is a scam to weaken the power of unions. If the union has to act on behalf of you, but you don't have to pay, then very, very few people are going to actually pay for the union, and it will die.
The courts have already ruled that the unions can create contracts that exclude non-members from bargaining units (and therefore refuse representation to non-members) as long as they don't charge the non-members agency fees. If Janus wins the right not to pay an agency fee, that's what they'll do.
The only scam is in pretending that the unions are forced to represent people like Janus whether or not they receive fees. That's nonsense; it's their decision entirely to include non-members in the bargaining unit.
> Why shouldn’t a union be political?
By that argument, why shouldn't the government force you to donate money to political advocacy groups that it chooses, whether or not you support the group's agenda?
Heck, what if your employer decided that a portion of your paycheck would be deducted as a mandatory donation to either the Democratic or Republican party, as part of the terms of your employment?