News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by dvfjsdhgfv on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:22AM (#17116724)
Everybody wants to hear it, but Google can't tell it. One part of the fight with the bad guys is never to tell them how they got caught, so they never know how to protect themselves.
Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by fauigerzigerk on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:59AM (#17117454)
There's a difference between telling someone what they did wrong and telling them how they got caught.

The former should be a legal requirement. But I'm not sure what actually happened in this particular case. We don't even know if it concerns a G Suite account and what the company was or wasn't told about why they got banned.

Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by gwerbret on Monday May 21, 2018 @12:40PM (#17119675)
Non-expert here, but I wonder if the obscurity actually points to an machine learning-based solution at Google's end.

Let's say that Google has developed a deep learning paradigm to identify -- and ban -- low-value users who violate their ToS. The low-value group would probably include all non-paying users, as well as small G Suite accounts. Let's also say that the paradigm was deployed as an automated solution, since it was 99% accurate during testing at picking out ToS violators, though the exact percentage doesn't really matter. I would imagine that the relevant Google execs did a cost-benefit analysis, and figured that the PR hit and revenue loss associated with a liberal and fully automated use of the banhammer against all supposed ToS violators -- including the 1% that were false positives -- was justified by the benefits to Google's bottom line.

Based on this possibility, it seems likely that Google employees would not _know_ why the banhammer fell in any particular instance -- nor would they care to know, since that would involve digging through the data to figure out which events triggered a positive hit in their machine learning implementation. It presumably wouldn't be worth Google's time and effort on behalf of users already classified as "low-value".

This might also explain why, as mentioned in another post, it took a few days for the banhammer to fall on a start-up, after a dev with a "poisoned" Google account joined the team. Presumably it took those few days worth of traffic and usage data for ToS-Hammer(tm) to figure that the dev had spawned new accounts elsewhere.

Again, I'm not an expert, so pardon any flaws in the relevant logic.

Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by fauigerzigerk on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @05:05AM (#17124613)
This seems realistic, if it's not like that today it may soon be. But I think this is exactly the sort of scenario that doesn't go together with all the claims of responsible use of AI powers.

Given the oligopolistic structure of the industry, throwing an unlucky minority under the bus without recourse just because it's statistically "rational" will not hold up.

I think Google knows that and there will be some sort of more systematic fix (compared to reddit posts and friends at Google).

Some AI algorithms can explain how they came to the conclusion they came to and why not have a paid support option as well.

Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by scardine on Monday May 21, 2018 @07:39AM (#17117619)
Sure. Let's go ahead and turn the world into a Kafkaesque nightmare where you are prosecuted but has no right to know why. Justice system is perfect so if the man says you are guilty it's because you are. /S
Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by nordsieck on Monday May 21, 2018 @07:50AM (#17117673)
> Sure. Let's go ahead and turn the world into a Kafkaesque nightmare where you are prosecuted but has no right to know why. Justice system is perfect so if the man says you are guilty it's because you are. /S

The great virtue of private industry over government is the ease with which you can opt out.

Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by scardine on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:24AM (#17119052)
Yes, changing to another cloud provider may be less annoying than moving to another country but for how long it will be the case?
Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by JasonFruit on Monday May 21, 2018 @10:15AM (#17118517)
Have you tried to opt out of Google services, especially if you got in early on? It's not easy, let me tell you.
Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by dvfjsdhgfv on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:09AM (#17118928)
I completely agree, it's extremely hard. I can do without Google on my servers at all, and I'm happy about it. On my notebook, it's much harder. On a phone, it's almost impossible, if you have and Android phone. Google is bending over backwards to make you turn on more sensors and gather more data. I recently discovered it's enough to use the Gmail app once with a given e-mail address and it will happily turn on the location service (.i.e. phone tracking) for these accounts, even though you use a completely different account for your phone set up, including Google Play. They want to lay their hands on everything, it's so annoying.
Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by hluska on Monday May 21, 2018 @10:19AM (#17118539)
Isn't Google a private company?
Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by ocdtrekkie on Monday May 21, 2018 @10:27AM (#17118597)
The fact that a private company can essentially execute you or your business from the Internet is exactly what's so terrifying.
Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by simias on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:20AM (#17119025)
Only if you give them that power. The popular wisdom not to put all your eggs in one basket is still relevant.

You generally can't opt-out from your government, you definitely don't have to opt-in Google services.

Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by scardine on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:58AM (#17119304)
You can opt-out from your government by moving to another country - you have more choice than you have on mobile where there is only Google or Apple... :-)
Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by hluska on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:04AM (#17118887)
How is that terrifying? I can access the web, use all the base protocols (email, etc) and store all my documents without having to rely upon Google. If I don't like/trust Google, I can easily migrate away. And, if enough people don't like it to make this "Kafka-esque nightmare" more than hyperbole, then the laws of private organizations will catch up and Google will either shape up or be no more.

This is almost the polar opposite of Kafka-esque.

Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by dvfjsdhgfv on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @03:34AM (#17124284)
> I can access the web, use all the base protocols (email, etc)

Well, sort-of, and still. If you use the web, you are constantly being tracked by Google as people mindlessly put GA code on all their websites. As for e-mail, it's more and more difficult to set up an e-mail server these days because of anti-spam measures, and Google/MS are dictating the terms here - but MS has a much more relaxed policy. Each time I set up a new mail server, I have to go through the same set of rituals, only to discover Google came up with another requirement and will not deliver my mail if I don't do it.

Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by scardine on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:48AM (#17119232)
So are you arguing that this behavior is acceptable from private companies but not from governments?

You can't argue both 1) companies are allowed to do anything they want and 2) they can grow unlimited monopolies.

If you do, sooner or later they will surpass national states in power and you have an even worst distopia.

Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by applecrazy on Monday May 21, 2018 @10:55AM (#17118810)
No, Google is a publicly traded company.
Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by hluska on Monday May 21, 2018 @10:57AM (#17118827)
Yes, of course, but they're not part of government. They're a company...

These Kafka-esque arguments are way over the top when applied to a private, profit seeking organization.

Re:Getting Google to ban our entire company by themaninthedark on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:54AM (#17119282)
Security through obscurity is a bad design.