News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by coding123 on Sunday May 20, 2018 @07:36PM (#17115314)
Curious thought process... we spend about 12-20 years of our life going at a specific pace to learning "stuff" in different categories. What if you were given a choice - Learn the stuff in a class in 12-20 years of wasted time OR just have a list of all the material you must know, along with sample questions (so you know you're learning the right material) and have a venue to turn in work (so you get feedback). But instead of spending 12-20 (or more) years, you are given the choice to do whatever pace you want. So in that sense, could really fast people basically "Doogie Howser" it and start a career by 15?

And possibly a related question - instead of doing ANY higher learning activities, we push all that into vocations - basically if you want to be a rocket scientist you ... start being a rocket scientist intern, learn the trade by being a peon in the shops?

Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by toomanybeersies on Sunday May 20, 2018 @09:03PM (#17115566)
In regards to self guided study, don't fall into the trap of thinking that because you could do it, everyone else could.

This is going to sound really conceited and condescending, but I'm going to write it anyway:

I reckon that I could've finished my BSc in Computer Science in probably half the time required. I attended only about 2 weeks of lectures per semester, generally didn't start assignments more than a week before they were due, and didn't study more than about 3 days before the exam.

For most people though, that doesn't work. They need to go to lectures, they need to study for a couple of weeks before exams, they need to attend the tutorials. Structured learning and the education system is made for the bottom 95% of the population. Schools spend a lot more time, money, and effort on special education and learning support for less gifted students than they do for the gifted ones. It's different at every school, but I remember that through most of primary school, there were no supplemental learning or other activities for gifted students. I was stuck in the same normal stream as everybody else. It wasn't until I got to high school, where students were streamed into different classes, that I actually got pushed to learn and use my abilities, the top stream was basically pushed a year ahead of all the other students.

Even for the normal stream of people though, there are people who will excel in certain areas and struggle in others. But a teacher has a class of 30 students to teach. The education system is made for the masses, we would likely get better educational outcomes from having much smaller class ratios, 10 students per teacher maybe, but nobody has the money to pay that many teachers, and there aren't that many teachers out there.

Anyway, my point is that for the HN community, being given a set of learning goals and being told to find a way to learn them would work. For most people, they would flail around and struggle.

Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by ZeroGravitas on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:18AM (#17116512)
Like with 'learning styles', it's easy to assume that lectures help others even though I personally found them stupid and pointless but the research is fairly consistent that they're worse than other options. And now we have cheap video recording, I'd imagine that live lectures are even worse. They're just "the way it's always been done" not an attempt to meet the learning needs of the majority of students.

I'd guess that applies to most other stuff that could be tweaked based on svience to benefit all students, rather than pit "gifted" against everyone else.

Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by toomanybeersies on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:48AM (#17116618)
Live lectures have the advantage that you can ask questions. However, nobody wants to ask questions (except mature students) as they don't want to hold up the lecture.

Most of my lectures at university were recorded. Whenever I watched them online I'd speed them up 1.3x, so a 1 hour lecture would only take 45 minutes, with no negative effects, I could speed them up even faster, but I had to pay more attention and sometimes rewind. Unfortunately, some lecturers didn't record their lectures, it was their choice, which seems sort of silly and discriminatory to those students who couldn't make it in for whatever reason (illness, anxiety, etc...).

I personally see no reason why for a lot of subjects we couldn't have online lectures, where we could sit in the comfort of our bedroom, and ask any questions to the lecturer online.

Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by forapurpose on Sunday May 20, 2018 @09:10PM (#17115595)
> for the HN community, being given a set of learning goals and being told to find a way to learn them would work

It depends very much on what you are learning. Even in computer science, much of what there is to learn - and most of the important things - can't be found in the book. Personal advice by an expert on technique, concepts, and perhaps most crucially, on what you don't know that you don't know, is invaluable. Also, a university has computer resources that no student can match. Then imagine chemistry, history, drawing, etc.

If you only mean passing courses in one field - that's vocational training, and passing courses is only a proxy measurement anyway. You're missing out on a lot if you think that's education.

Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by leetcrew on Sunday May 20, 2018 @10:47PM (#17115881)
> Also, a university has computer resources that no student can match.

this probably only matters for graduate+ level studies and perhaps a couple upper level electives for undergrads. in my whole time as an undergrad (at a well-regarded regional school), i only used our HPC cluster once for a trivial parallelism project in my algorithms class. the vast majority of my school projects required the compute resources of a 10 year old laptop, anyway.

having paid experts on staff that are required to hold office hours and field questions is a much more compelling advantage of university imo.

Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by didibus on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:48AM (#17116615)
> I reckon that I could've finished my BSc in Computer Science in probably half the time required. I attended only about 2 weeks of lectures per semester, generally didn't start assignments more than a week before they were due, and didn't study more than about 3 days before the exam.

Something seems to be missing from your reasoning. What were you doing the rest of the time and beforehand? Are you sure it didn't involve computer science related activities? This would mean no reading blogs, HN, programming, no math puzzles, and also no toying with advanced computer use like IT related things.

That's the first requirement, otherwise you already spent a lot of time and effort learning comp sci.

The other requirement I see for your reasoning to hold true, is that none of the downtime in between courses, exams and assignments was needed for your brain to process the info and absorb it, to relax and be ready for the next mental effort, and for your motivation to keep up and not get bored or distracted.

There's also a third implicit, were you actually good and knowledgeable in comp sci, or just successful at passing your university's curriculum? If we suggest changing the system, we want it to produce equally or better qualified individuals. You mention that you've not followed the traditional route, and went at your own pace, which involved short bursts and big downtimes in between (presumably). Did this actually made you a better comp sci practitioner?

Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by toomanybeersies on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:16AM (#17123681)
To be honest, in my time in between I was largely drinking and working in a restaurant.
Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by memebox3v on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:48AM (#17116402)
I agree. I think I could have done my degree in a year. Didnt go to any lectures, do any coursework or workshops, learnt the material in a month before the exams. Got 1st class marks (although pulled down to a 2.1 because i didnt do coursework). I used to think everyone could do this if they wanted and that the school/university system was absolutely terrible. Turns out, I'm very bright, who knew?

Point is: Most people are not like this, they need the structure, they need the help.

Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by throwaway3924 on Monday May 21, 2018 @09:01AM (#17118039)
Same here. I studied for an EE degree in a very demanding university. Learning exclusively from books proved to be more effective.

> Most people are not like this, they need the structure, they need the help.

Only because they've been educated to be passive learners!

For centuries, aristocrats could afford large family libraries and were very self-directed in their studies. Today we expect scholars and researchers to be avid readers and able to find their own sources.

There is no evidence that the remaining 95% is born without the ability to learn from books. (No, IQ is not very relevant here.)

Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by didibus on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:56AM (#17116648)
How many hours was spent on that month prior per given exam prep?

Did you have any prior exposure to comp sci? Had programmed before? Had spent a lot of time on math? Read about comp sci, blogs, articles, books?

What does 1st class marks pulled down to a 2 mean?

How qualified do you feel you are now compared to your coworkers who followed a more traditional style?

Do you think you could have done this one month prior exam cramming 12 months in a row with equal success and without losing the motivation to keep it going?

Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by michaelt on Monday May 21, 2018 @05:24AM (#17117148)

  What does 1st class marks pulled down to a 2 mean?
He means "I got a B+ overall, but I got an A+ on everything I turned in, I just didn't turn in some graded assignments" and his degree was graded using the British classification system [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_undergraduate_degree_c...

Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by walshemj on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:15AM (#17117295)
Seems a bit silly to blow of the course work and not get a first - also not a terribly good indicator that they will adapt well to the workplace.

Obvs if its a former Polly the difference between a first and a 2.1 isn't as important as an Oxbridge First.

Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by mitchdoogle on Monday May 21, 2018 @12:16AM (#17116103)
The Truth is you don't know how you might have turned out in a different system. Perhaps you excelled because of the system, and not in spite of it.
Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by mieseratte on Sunday May 20, 2018 @08:13PM (#17115429)
As someone who found their path earlier than most, and has a bit of the protestant work ethic I see the appeal. However, there's two problems to this that I can see:

First, most folks do not know what they wish to be from a reasonably young age. For the longest time I thought I wanted to be a geologist, probably until about high school, despite having discovered computing at an early age. Funny enough, I never really recognized that I could turn programming into a career. To me it was just something fun that I did.

Consider the trope of the college kid who goes to school to find themself, bounces around majors, and graduates late. I know some nations have success tracking students earlier, but that is usually around the high school timeframe at best. Part of early education is setting the foundation and teaching one how to learn. This reduces the amount of years available for "Doogie Howser" self-study down to only four or so, plus an additional three or four for higher learning.

Second, even if someone "knows" what they want to do I think many don't necessarily have the drive and resilience for self-guided study and the associated struggle. Many need the structure, and "hand-holding" that comes with a normal classroom.

Additionally, some see value in the "well rounded" model of education and so depending on what you want to be it may or may not make sense. Having been of the "I speak English, why study it" school of thought, well, I'm sure this "essay" and the comma atrocities therein speak for itself. Just imagine if I had spent even less time in an English course.

If we wanted a more utilitarian society of technicians this would be a good idea, but there are many facets to education besides occupation.

Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by cortesoft on Sunday May 20, 2018 @09:20PM (#17115626)
The most important skill I learned in school was how to deal with other people when you have to be together every day.
Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by jseliger on Sunday May 20, 2018 @08:32PM (#17115485)
If you are interested in this topic, the book you're really looking for is Bryan Caplan's The Case Against Education: https://jakeseliger.com/2018/03/12/the-case-against-educatio...
Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by j45 on Sunday May 20, 2018 @08:12PM (#17115427)
One issue is learning is largely prepared and delivered as a linear experience.

Our paths in life, are not linear.

What we learn, grow from, transfer skills through is not as pretty as a sequential grade or degree system.

Employers care about hiring competencies - institutions try to call it holistic but there remains a poor signal to noise ratio in terms of transferable skills.

The traditional 2,000 year old form of higher education is no longer able to keep up with the rate of change in society.

Today by the time higher institutions prepare new learning material release, it's outdated.

Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by EGreg on Sunday May 20, 2018 @07:54PM (#17115370)
Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by aje403 on Sunday May 20, 2018 @09:38PM (#17115680)
Great example, rocket science, let’s throw a bunch of 15 year olds who say they want to be a rocket scientist into nasa. What could go wrong? The mit engineering grad has proven for a few more years that he’s less likely to screw things up. The system sucks but it’s not an easy problem to solve
Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by itronitron on Monday May 21, 2018 @12:58AM (#17116224)
>> less likely to screw things up

By virtue of education or selection process?

The main problem with throwing 15 year olds into NASA is that, for a given year, there are far more of them than there are MIT graduates.

What is unbalanced about how we educate teenagers is that we saturate them with too many interactions with other teenagers (8 classes a day with 30 other students ~240 unique edges per student) and expect them to be able to focus on learning the course material. This despite the fact that adults outnumber teenagers by a considerable margin. It should be no surprise then that our society in the US is largely centered around childish interests as the majority of our social interactions have occurred as children with children.

Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by aje403 on Monday May 21, 2018 @08:35AM (#17117909)
By both virtue of education and selection process, and given that their education was adequately rigorous, they've likely been working hard at academics for > 10 years, they had the mental faculties to understand everything in their field, and they're certified by grades from the most educated people in their field on the planet (same is true for other top universities, as well). There are far more problems with hiring 15 year olds at NASA than sheer volume of applications - I would advise you to think more deeply about what you're suggesting as, even in your alternative education scenario, it's a truly terrible idea.

Devil's advocate: why is that a bad thing? Kids get social/organization exposure, to sports, music, basic education. The motivated ones are still apparently rising to the top despite the shitty environment. Most humans don't need to go into rocket science, and half of your graduating class will end up directly selling things to other people (in some form or another).As well, are you arguing that kids need less social exposure? That would be true if most kids were going to become software developers, which is not the case. Most of our social interactions do not occur in childhood; you're not speaking for everyone.

What I will say, that is somewhat similar to what you're arguing, is that it would be great if students had direct access to more challenging curriculums at every stage of their education. To my knowledge, ambitious high schoolers need benefactors willing to pay for college courses that are standard fare for secondary school in a lot of countries. If you're naturally bright and hard working without affluent parents, you're SOL in HS, which is not fair, and I think it's also unreasonable that they need to rely on being autodidactic from a young age, which is really the only alternative.

Re:Study: Students did not benefit from studying according t... by itronitron on Thursday May 24, 2018 @12:29AM (#17141105)
I do think kids need less social exposure, if only for their own sanity. There is only so much water bottle flipping, fidget spinning, and faggot calling that some children (and adults) can put up with in one day.

Because that is the social environment within large middle schools and high schools, it detracts significantly from their education. Since it is not something that they will experience often as adults it seems like a waste to force them through that during their education, just sayin'