News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by TimTheTinker on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:46PM (#17111091)
Just my own perspective: as one who believes God is responsible for the origin, complexity, and diversity of life, this article makes me chuckle. The theory of evolution as an explanation of the origin of the major taxa of life really paints us into a corner from which it is difficult to wiggle out.

In my opinion, the panspermia/alien origin hypothesis (and its persistence as an explanation in some respected circles) illustrates how strictly limiting ourselves to natural explanations leaves not just a "gap" in our ability to explain origins, but a massive gaping hole. (Also, the insistence on a distinction between "alien" and "divine" has no rational basis.)

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by caconym_ on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:23AM (#17111207)
Science tries its best to discover the correct explanation for phenomena, and accepts gaps in knowledge as a natural consequence of the ongoing nature of its pursuit of the truth.

You are welcome to believe what you want, but you must understand that accepting faith-based explanations with zero supporting evidence is a fundamentally different sort of thing. Of course you think you have the answers, and that people still grubbing around looking for their own are short-sighted dummies, if you're willing to accept answers that somebody simply made up out of thin air.

> Also, the insistence on a distinction between "alien" and "divine" has no rational basis.

How do you figure that? They seem quite different to me, given the properties that are usually ascribed to hypothetical divine beings.

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by TimTheTinker on Sunday May 20, 2018 @01:04AM (#17111333)
I'm not arguing with the scientific method, or the power of looking for natural explanations through experimentation.

It's just that examining evidence related to past events can only go so far in explaining their cause. If you assume natural causes all the way back, you will inevitably reach the limit of a natural chain of events. If the origin of life isn't a big enough question, perhaps the origin of the big bang is -- how does anyone go there without stepping into the metaphysical?

> How do you figure that? They seem quite different to me, given the properties that are usually ascribed to hypothetical divine beings.

My point is that on the surface, philosophically speaking, there's no difference between the two explanations beyond their starting assumptions.

> zero evidence

Not at all. Everything that exists constitutes evidence for him in one way or another. (It’s late. Can provide more details tomorrow if you’re interested.)

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by caconym_ on Sunday May 20, 2018 @03:30AM (#17111672)
> It's just that examining evidence related to past events can only go so far in explaining their cause. If you assume natural causes all the way back, you will inevitably reach the limit of a natural chain of events. If the origin of life isn't a big enough question, perhaps the origin of the big bang is -- how does anyone go there without stepping into the metaphysical?

Why speculate in the absence of real knowledge? Maybe some questions simply cannot be answered? Maybe some answers are simply beyond our reach for now? Faced with these gaps, If I'm going to get metaphysical, I'd sooner reach inwards than outwards.

> My point is that on the surface, philosophically speaking, there's no difference between the two explanations beyond their starting assumptions.

Pretty vague, and I disagree in any case, I think—there seems to be a great difference between the two. One is based on phenomena we have directly observed (comets, life on Earth, etc.), and the other is not.

> Not at all. Everything that exists constitutes evidence for him in one way or another. (It’s late. Can provide more details tomorrow if you’re interested.)

If you presuppose that "He" exists and work backwards from there, sure. Otherwise no, I don't think so. Willing to read more, if you write it.

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by tree_of_item on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:17AM (#17111188)
> The theory of evolution as an explanation of the origin of the major taxa of life really paints us into a corner from which it is difficult to wiggle out.

I'm really not sure what you mean by this.

> Also, the insistence on a distinction between "alien" and "divine" has no rational basis

What?? You don't see a distinction between life on another planet and supernatural phenomena...?

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by TimTheTinker on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:34AM (#17111246)
> I'm really not sure what you mean by this.

If you assume the major groups of life evolved from common ancestors, the fossil record doesn't offer a lot of help to fill in the early details (i.e. transitional types). Also, you have the problem of the origin of the first single-cell organism.

> You don't see a distinction between life on another planet and supernatural phenomena...?

My point is that insisting on it being an alien life form that seeded life on earth (as opposed to the God hypothesis) is kind of begging the question. Philosophically, what is the difference between an unknown alien life form and God as the origin of life, other than different starting assumptions?

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by mbfg on Sunday May 20, 2018 @01:23AM (#17111375)
>> what is the difference between an unknown alien life form and God as the origin of life, other than different starting assumptions?

for one, we do know that there _are_ life forms.

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by oh_sigh on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:32AM (#17111234)
To be fair, Bruno declared a distinction and was burned at the stake.
Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by 0xBA5ED on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:01AM (#17111138)
"The theory of evolution as an explanation of the origin of the major taxa of life really paints us into a corner from which it is difficult to wiggle out."

Sure, it's easy to avoid corners when you can place them arbitrarily, or even move them when they're inconvenient.

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by TimTheTinker on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:12AM (#17111167)
> place them arbitrarily, or even move them when they're inconvenient.

I know others have been accused of that; I endeavor to maintain integrity.

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by peteretep on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:30AM (#17111228)
This is ridiculous, and I'd also point out, despite my being atheist, that it's blasphemous.

Monotheistic religions (almost all) believe in an omnipotent God. Omnipotent means that nothing binds the hand of God, at all. An omnipotent being can literally contrive any situation; they can change anything, from moment to moment, without leaving any traces whatsoever. They can change the very nature of logic itself without consequence.

You are saying that you try to understand and talk about and reason about God inside of some kind of logical framework, where you can't just _deus ex machina_ your way out of any situation, but this explicitly binds the power of God. God and logic can't be combined, God and debate can't be combined, because both deny the omnipotent nature of God.

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by TimTheTinker on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:48AM (#17111282)
Speaking for Christianity, God's omnipotence does not mean he can violate his own nature. In fact, he is very limited in the sense that there are an infinite number of things that he cannot do because they are inconsistent with his nature -- his holiness, truth, love, and wisdom.
Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by peteretep on Sunday May 20, 2018 @02:15AM (#17111478)
> In fact, he is very limited in the sense

That's blasphemy, and you take it upon yourself to interpret and understand His divine will, and second guess Him, despite being warned over and over that His will is beyond your understanding. Your comments are a textbook example of the type of human arrogance that gets Biblical characters unstuck, over and over and over again.

> he is very limited in the sense that there are an infinite number of things that he cannot do

I would be interested to see canonical scriptural references for this statement.

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by TimTheTinker on Sunday May 20, 2018 @09:56AM (#17112687)
Not blasphemy, since these statements are proceeding directly from what God has said about himself in scripture.

I’ll break out the Bible references and reply this evening. Cheers :-)

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by TimTheTinker on Monday May 21, 2018 @12:35AM (#17116162)
> you take it upon yourself to interpret and understand His divine will, and second guess Him

God's complete will is absolutely beyond human understanding (as he is infinite), but deducing facts about him and his will based on what he has said about himself is not human arrogance or second-guessing him. It's just straightforward thinking.

> I would be interested to see canonical scriptural references for this statement.

Ok, got some direct scriptural examples of a few categories of things God cannot do, because they are inconsistent with his character.

1) God cannot lie.

- Titus 1:2: "... in the hope of eternal life that God, who cannot lie, promised before time began"

- Hebrews 6:18: "... so that through two unchangeable things, in which it is impossible for God to lie, we who have fled for refuge might have strong encouragement to seize the hope set before us."

2) God cannot deny himself

- 2 Timothy 2:13: "if we are faithless, He remains faithful, for He cannot deny Himself."

This implies that he can't go against his own word or his own express will.

3) God cannot be tempted with evil and does not tempt anyone.

- James 1:13: "No one undergoing a trial should say, 'I am being tempted by God.' For God is not tempted by evil, and He Himself doesn’t tempt anyone."

---

This isn't to say he is restricted to doing only what he wants to do or actually does. Other passages refer to his ability to do things that he doesn't end up doing. One example is Matthew 3:9: "... God is able to raise up children for Abraham from these stones!" -- something he didn't do and never said he would.

Please understand, AFAIK when the Scriptures speak of what God can't do, it's always meant as a comfort and encouragement to his people. E.g. from the above examples -- if he can't lie, deny himself, or be tempted with evil (much less do it), and if he is all-powerful to accomplish his holy will, then his words can be taken as rock-solid and trustworthy.

[Quotations from the HCSB translation.]

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by flukus on Monday May 21, 2018 @12:50AM (#17116207)
> God cannot be tempted with evil and does not tempt anyone.

Is creating evil in the first place not being tempted by it?

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by TimTheTinker on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:07AM (#17116255)
God didn’t create evil. Is there something specific you’re thinking of?
Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by flukus on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:14AM (#17116273)
God created everything directly and indirectly, everything includes evil. Even if it was indirect, being omniscient makes him ultimately responsible for it.

Either that or you start to get into pantheistic territory.

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by TimTheTinker on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:36AM (#17117362)
He created several classes of beings with the capacity for free will, since love freely chosen is the only kind of real love. Knowing that some would choose to hate him (or do anything else, for that matter) doesn’t shift responsibility away from them for that choice.

Actually, the existence of evil is one of the biggest arguments for God’s existence via showing that there are universal, objective moral values and duties. Summary is —- one cannot call some actions evil except by contrast with what is morally good. We all know certain things are absolutely evil (although some atheists deny that). And moral accountability is impossible without a moral law and a moral law-giver.

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by flukus on Monday May 21, 2018 @07:02AM (#17117465)
> He created several classes of beings with the capacity for free will, since love freely chosen is the only kind of real love. Knowing that some would choose to hate him (or do anything else, for that matter) doesn’t shift responsibility away from them for that choice.

If you knew your child was going to be the next Hitler would you conceive a child? If I told you I was buying a gun so I could go on a shooting rampage would you sell me a gun? Knowing the outcome of your actions makes you at least partially responsible.

> one cannot call some actions evil except by contrast with what is morally good

But if evil didn't exist we wouldn't need to contrast it with anything, it's not like it makes being good any better than it would have been in an evil free world.

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by 0xBA5ED on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:57AM (#17111306)
This literally means that God is not "all powerful". And if there are things he is simply incapable of experiencing, this also means he is not "all knowing".
Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by TimTheTinker on Sunday May 20, 2018 @01:08AM (#17111341)
Yes it does mean that. However, he is "all powerful" where it matters - to accomplish his own will, which is consistent with his character.
Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by 0xBA5ED on Sunday May 20, 2018 @01:30AM (#17111392)
If he is controlled by "his nature", then it isn't HIS will.
Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by TimTheTinker on Sunday May 20, 2018 @02:30AM (#17111517)
But it is his will to remain self-consistent, i.e. he cannot change and has no desire to do so. God is entirely different from us in that there is no contradiction anywhere in his person, nature, or work.
Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by 0xBA5ED on Sunday May 20, 2018 @02:47AM (#17111567)
You're saying that he chose to have no choice. This implies there was a point at which he had a choice, then chose to have no choice. Can you see how nonsensical this is?
Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by TimTheTinker on Sunday May 20, 2018 @09:47AM (#17112639)
> He chose to have no choice

I never said that. God’s existence and nature are eternal and outside of spacetime. Neither changes with time.

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by mbfg on Sunday May 20, 2018 @01:20AM (#17111369)
Evolution doesn't make any claims about the origin of life, only how it evolves over time, and how speciation occurs.

You want to rail against abiogenesis i suppose, because a magic being with fairy dust outside of time and space is more likely.

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by jryan49 on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:35AM (#17111249)
> limiting ourselves to natural explanations

So you mean looking into supernatural explanations? How does that fill any of the holes? It's by definition out of the realm of explanation... Also, saying that "God did it" has about as much content as panspermia ("somewhere else made it").

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by khazhoux on Sunday May 20, 2018 @02:42AM (#17111550)
You're right. It's not nearly as clean a solution as "God did everything, QED"
Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by TimTheTinker on Sunday May 20, 2018 @02:42PM (#17114164)
I’m not saying “God is the origin” removes all the unknowns or difficulties, or is sufficient to explain every detail. Quite the opposite: it adds another dimension of unknowns and mystery, because it allows “why?” to be a meaningful question (speaking of ultimate meaning/purpose, beyond natural preconditions and mechanisms) in scientific inquiry, in addition to “what”, “how”, etc.
Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by khazhoux on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:13PM (#17120937)
It doesn't really add many unknowns or mystery. It's quite simple: "God created everything". Now you're left with only one unknown, "who/what/how created God?"

But the answer to that can't be a "who" or you have the problem of a Super-God, which (by convention) is disallowed. So instead, people say "God is eternal both into the past and into the future" and neatly tie up any possible question. God always was and always will be and he created everything -- a clean solution where if you accept the premise of God, then any and all follow-on questions just point back to the premise.

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by TimTheTinker on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:35PM (#17122422)
> Now you're left with only one unknown

That doesn't make any sense to me. "God created everything" is nearly content-less even if you assume it. If you stop there, you're left with nearly zero understanding of how the world/nature/universe works. Inquiry of all sorts (scientific included) is still indispensable for discovering content about the world.

> "who/what/how created God?"

The only way to know anything about the Christian God, at least, is to look at what he’s done and what he says about himself - again a line of inquiry involving discovery, questions, deductions.

> a clean solution where if you accept the premise of God, then any and all follow-on questions just point back to the premise.

Agreed, it does tie it up neatly. But again, assuming the Christian God, we have no ability to know anything about him unless he chooses to reveal it (him being an infinite being). And assuming everything that begins to exist has a cause, there must be something that did not begin to exist -- which must then be defined as having no beginning. You might be familiar with logical systems if you're a developer. At the most basic levels, where everything is bootstrapped, a lot of self-references are often involved.

Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by maxerickson on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:49PM (#17111099)
A few billion years is like, a pretty long time.
Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by oh_sigh on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:32AM (#17111236)
For you.
Re:Group of scientists suggest that octopuses might actually... by legostormtroopr on Sunday May 20, 2018 @01:38AM (#17111416)
You’re a big guy